Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 8;2021(8):CD012720. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012720.pub2

Gandhi 2016.

Study characteristics
Methods Study design: single‐centre, quasi‐experimental pilot study
Setting: not reported
Timing: the study was conducted for a period of 6 weeks.
Interventions: control group received myofascial release therapy for the shoulder whereas the experimental group received myofascial release therapy with shoulder taping. The treatment was given on alternative days.
Sample size: 38 collegiate basketball players were recruited for the study. Sample size was not calculated.
Analysis: not reported
Participants Criteria for defining the condition being treated: clinical diagnosis of subacromial impingement syndrome, positive shoulder impingement test
Restriction on duration of symptoms – if yes, participants specified this

Inclusion criteria: male basketball players, age group 18‐22 years

Exclusion criteria: history of previous injury around shoulder, severe labrum or capsule tear, patient with radiating pain, severe pain around the shoulder, allergic to tape and skin infections

Baseline characteristics:
Overall cohort of participants:
Number of participants at enrolment: NR
Number randomised: 38
Number included in analyses: 38
Age: 20 ± 2 years
Sex: M 38 (100%)
Diagnosis: subacromial impingement syndrome
Intervention: myofascial release therapy + Kinesio Taping (KT)
Mean (SD) pain (NPRS 0‐10): 6.39 (not reported)
Mean (SD) function (SPADI): 79.4 (not reported)
Intervention: myofascial release therapy
Mean (SD) pain (NPRS 0‐10): 6.47 (not reported)
Mean (SD) function (SPADI): 79.4 (not reported
 
Pretreatment group differences: not reported
Interventions Experimental: kinesio taping [KT]
Tape: not specified; taping method: not specified; target: deltoid; number of applications: 18; single application duration: 2 dd; provider: not reported
Co‐intervention: myofascial release therapy (stretch of pectoralis minor and pectoralis major, and anterior part of deltoid)
Control group: myofascial release therapy (stretch of pectoralis minor and pectoralis major, and anterior part of deltoid)
Outcomes
  • Pain: the numeric pain rating scales (NPRS) were used to determine the patients’ subjective assessment of pain. Pain intensity was assessed in the first visit and then on every alternate week.

  • Functional disability: Shoulder Pain Disability Index (SPADI). Higher scores in SPADI indicate worse‐off functional disability


Outcomes used in this review
The following outcomes were considered at the end of treatments:
  • Pain (NPRS 0‐10)

  • Function (SPADI)

Notes The authors did not reported any source of funding. The authors declared any conflict of interest.
Trial registration: not reported
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk "players were divided into two groups with equal number of participants". "Block randomization process was used" Insufficient information for judgement
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Low risk "Block randomization process was used and randomly done 1 or 2 labeled envelopes to determine their groups allocation, the subjects done 1 of remaining 2 envelopes to and the process was repeated".
Blinding of participants (performance bias) High risk Nature of delivered intervention
Blinding of personnel (performance bias) High risk Nature of delivered intervention
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias)
self‐reported outcomes High risk No information for judgement. However, blinding of participants not possible because of the nature of the delivered intervention
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias)
assessor‐reported outcomes Low risk No objective outcome planned and assessed
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias)
All outcomes Unclear risk No data regarding loss to follow‐up. Insufficient information for judgement
Selective reporting (reporting bias) Unclear risk No published protocol
Unequal use of co‐intervention Low risk KT with other conservative treatment versus the same conservative treatment