Characteristic Study ID |
Intervention(s) and control(s) | Country | Duration of intervention | Duration of follow‐up | Co‐medications | Co‐morbidities |
Auvichayapat 2008 | I1: green tea extract C1: placebo |
Thailand | 12 weeks | ‐ | Participants were excluded if taking prescribed medications, (e.g. antipsychotics, antidepressants, anti‐obesity medications, hormonal therapy) | Participants were excluded if they had a history of metabolic disease (e.g. diabetes mellitus, hyper‐ or hypothyroidism, Cushing's syndrome) or systemic disease, (e.g. heart, renal, liver disease) |
Diepvens 2005 | I1: green tea C1: placebo |
The Netherlands | 84 days | ‐ | Excluded if on medications | Excluded if not healthy |
Hill 2007 | I1: green tea extract C1: placebo |
Australia | 12 weeks | ‐ | Antihypertensive, lipid‐lowering or obesity medications not allowed | Note: participants excluded if had diabetes, liver, gastrointestinal or CV disease, or abnormal thyroid function |
Hsu 2008 | I1: green tea extract C1: placebo |
Taiwan | 12 weeks | ‐ | Obesity medications not allowed – no other details provided | ‐ |
Hursel 2009 | I1: green tea‐caffeine mixture + AP diet I2: green tea‐caffeine mixture + HP diet C1: placebo + AP diet C2: placebo + HP diet |
The Netherlands | 3 months | ‐ | Medication use not permitted | Participants had to be in good health, no further details were provided |
Kajimoto 2005 | I1: catechin drink – low dose group I2: catechin drink – high dose group C1: placebo drink |
Japan | 12 weeks | 8‐week withdrawal period | Participants were excluded if taking medicines that might affect lipid metabolism | ‐ |
Kataoka 2004 | I1: catechin beverage 278 mg I2: catechin beverage 570 mg: I3: catechin beverage 845 mg C1: control beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | No medications that affected weight were allowed | Participants with co‐morbidities were excluded |
Kovacs 2004 | I1: green tea C1: placebo |
The Netherlands | 13 weeks | ‐ | Participants were excluded if taking any medications | Participants had to be in good health, no further details were provided |
Kozuma 2005 | I1: catechin beverage C1: placebo beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | Medicine, specific health foods, beverages and supplements that had the possibility of influencing lipid and glucose metabolism and other energy levels were restricted | Note: participants were excluded if had serious liver, kidney, heart disease, or diabetes |
Maki 2009 | I1: green tea beverage C1: control beverage |
USA | 12 weeks | ‐ | ‐ | ‐ |
Nagao 2007 | I1: brewed green tea beverage with added catechins C1: brewed green tea beverage with no added catechins |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | Medicines or foods known to influence lipid or carbohydrate metabolism were prohibited | Participants with serious liver or renal disease were excluded |
Suzuki 2009 | I1: tea catechin C1: placebo |
Japan | 12 weeks | 4‐week post‐ consumption observation period | Note: use of pharmaceutical drugs or health
supplements that might affect fat metabolism
discouraged Use of over‐the‐counter drugs was not allowed |
Note: participants receiving medical treatment for obesity, hyperlipidaemia, diabetes or hypertension were excluded Participants with serious liver, kidney, heart, pulmonary, endocrine or metabolic disorder were excluded |
Takase 2008 | I1: catechin beverage C1: placebo beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | Medicine, food, beverages and supplements with possibility of influencing lipid and glucose metabolism and other energy levels were restricted | Participants undergoing medical treatment, with severe kidney, liver, heart disease or diabetes, were excluded. No further information available |
Takashima 2004 | I1: catechin beverage C1: control beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | Medications were not allowed | Participants with co‐morbidities were excluded |
Takeshita 2008 | I1: catechin beverage C1: placebo beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | ‐ | No treatment for high blood pressure, hyperlipidaemia or diabetes | Participants with severe liver, kidney, heart disease, or diabetes were excluded |
Tsuchida 2010 | I1: catechin beverage C1: control beverage |
Japan | 12 weeks | 12 weeks | Food products and medications that might affect energy absorption or lipid metabolism (e.g. dietary fibre supplements, psyllium) were restricted | ‐ |
Wang 2010 | I1: GT1 I2: GT2 I3: GT3 C1: control beverage |
China | 90 days | ‐ | No medications allowed except oral contraceptives and over‐the‐counter medications | Participants suffering from any medical or psychiatric condition were excluded |
Westerterp‐ Plantenga 2005 |
I1: green tea‐caffeine capsule ‐ low habitual caffeine consumers I2: green tea‐caffeine capsule ‐ high habitual caffeine consumers C1: placebo ‐ low habitual caffeine consumers C2: placebo ‐ high habitual caffeine consumers |
The Netherlands | 3 months | ‐ | Medications not allowed | ‐ |
Footnotes "‐" denotes not reported AP: adequate protein; C: control; GT: green tea; HP: high protein; I: intervention. |