Skip to main content
. 2004 Jan 26;2004(1):CD003133. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003133.pub2

Baba 1999.

Methods DESIGN: ‐parallel‐group 
 ‐3 arm study: 
 a. pranlukast 
 b. seratrodast 
 c. placebo
ALLOCATION 
 ‐random (means of allocation un‐specified)
BLINDING 
 ‐not specified 
 ‐placebo‐controlled
WITHDRAWAL/DROPOUTS 
 ‐not described
JADAD's Quality Score = 1
Confirmation of methodology not obtained
Participants WELL‐CONTROLLED PARTICIPANTS
‐RANDOMISED = 24 
 Pranlukast = 8/ 
 Control = 9/ 
 Seratrodast = 7
‐WITHDRAWALS: 
 not described
‐AGE: 
 not described
‐GENDER: not described
‐SEVERITY: 
 not described
‐Baseline FEV1(L) 
 not described
‐ALLERGEN TRIGGERS: 
 not described
‐ASTHMA DURATION: not described
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA 
 ‐AGE: not described
‐well‐controlled on non‐described dose of beclomethasone
Interventions PROTOCOL: 
 AL + ICS vs same dose 
 ICS (TAPERING ICS dose)
DURATION 
 ‐Dose optimisation period: not described
‐Intervention Period: not described
TEST GROUP 
 ‐Pranlukast (dose not specified) 
 + beclomethasone (dose not specified)
CONTROL GROUP 
 ‐Placebo + beclomethasone (dose not specified)
DEVICE 
 ‐not specified
‐CO‐TREATMENT: not specified
CRITERIA FOR TAPERING every 4 weeks by 50% the beclomethasone dose
MINIMAL DOSE OF ICS ALLOWED: 1/3 to 1/4 of baseline dose
Outcomes INTENTION‐TO‐TREAT ANALYSES 
 ‐not specified
PULMONARY FUNCTION TESTS 
 ‐PEF rates
‐SYMPTOM SCORES 
 not reported
FUNCTIONAL STATUS 
 ‐not reported 
 ‐exacerbations
ICS DOSE REDUCTION: 
 ‐not reported 
 ‐successful tapering
INFLAMMATORY MARKERS: 
 not reported
ADVERSE EFFECTS 
 ‐not reported
WITHDRAWALS 
 ‐not reported
Notes ‐Abs (1999)
‐funding source (not specified)
‐No contact information provided in abstract. Unable to request confirmation of methodology and data extraction until publication in full‐text of the report
‐User‐defined order: unable to be determined (re: un‐specified mean daily ICS dose )
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk Information not available (Cochrane Grade B)