Baba 1999.
Methods | DESIGN: ‐parallel‐group
‐3 arm study:
a. pranlukast
b. seratrodast
c. placebo ALLOCATION ‐random (means of allocation un‐specified) BLINDING ‐not specified ‐placebo‐controlled WITHDRAWAL/DROPOUTS ‐not described JADAD's Quality Score = 1 Confirmation of methodology not obtained |
|
Participants | WELL‐CONTROLLED PARTICIPANTS ‐RANDOMISED = 24 Pranlukast = 8/ Control = 9/ Seratrodast = 7 ‐WITHDRAWALS: not described ‐AGE: not described ‐GENDER: not described ‐SEVERITY: not described ‐Baseline FEV1(L) not described ‐ALLERGEN TRIGGERS: not described ‐ASTHMA DURATION: not described ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA ‐AGE: not described ‐well‐controlled on non‐described dose of beclomethasone |
|
Interventions | PROTOCOL:
AL + ICS vs same dose
ICS (TAPERING ICS dose) DURATION ‐Dose optimisation period: not described ‐Intervention Period: not described TEST GROUP ‐Pranlukast (dose not specified) + beclomethasone (dose not specified) CONTROL GROUP ‐Placebo + beclomethasone (dose not specified) DEVICE ‐not specified ‐CO‐TREATMENT: not specified CRITERIA FOR TAPERING every 4 weeks by 50% the beclomethasone dose MINIMAL DOSE OF ICS ALLOWED: 1/3 to 1/4 of baseline dose |
|
Outcomes | INTENTION‐TO‐TREAT ANALYSES
‐not specified PULMONARY FUNCTION TESTS ‐PEF rates ‐SYMPTOM SCORES not reported FUNCTIONAL STATUS ‐not reported ‐exacerbations ICS DOSE REDUCTION: ‐not reported ‐successful tapering INFLAMMATORY MARKERS: not reported ADVERSE EFFECTS ‐not reported WITHDRAWALS ‐not reported |
|
Notes | ‐Abs (1999) ‐funding source (not specified) ‐No contact information provided in abstract. Unable to request confirmation of methodology and data extraction until publication in full‐text of the report ‐User‐defined order: unable to be determined (re: un‐specified mean daily ICS dose ) |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Information not available (Cochrane Grade B) |