Skip to main content
. 2012 Mar 14;2012(3):CD007176. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007176.pub2

2. Characteristics of included trials with high risk of bias.

Trial Design Number participants Mean age Suppl (Y) Beta‐carotene (mg) Vitamin A (IU) Vitamin C (mg) Vitamin E (IU) Selenium (µg)
Gillilan 1977 Crossover 52 57 0.5       1600  
Mckeown‐Eyssen 1988 Parallel 185 58 2     400 400  
Burns 1989 Parallel 19 81 0.1     200    
Penn 1991 Parallel 30 84 0.077   8000 100 50  
Chandra 1992 Parallel 96 74 1 16 1333 80 44 20
NIT1 1993 1/2 (2 x 2 x 2 x 2) 29584 NA 5.25 15 5000 120 33 50
de la Maza 1995 Parallel 74 50 1       500  
Takamatsu 1995 Parallel 147 47 6       136  
ter Riet 1995 2 x 2 88 NA 0.23     1000    
Hogarth 1996 2 x 2 106 83 0.083   8000 500    
ADCS 1 1997 2 x 2 341 73 2       2000  
Girodon 1997 2 x 2 81 84 2 6   120 15 100
Bonelli 1998 Parallel 304 NA 5   6000 180 30 200
GISSI 1999 2 x 2 11324 59 3.5       330  
de Waart 2001 Parallel 218 60 1.8       400  
PPP 2001 2 x 2 4495 64 3.6       330  
Stevic 2001 Parallel 28 57 1       1200 31.5
Sasazuki 2003 2 x 2 439 57 5 15   500    
Takagi 2003 Parallel 93 63 5       600  
ADCS 2 2005 Parallel 516 73 3       2000  
SIT 2006 2 x 2 x 2 3411 NA 3.25 15   500 200 75
CTNS 2008 Parallel 1020 68 9   5000 60 30 25

Abbreviation: 
 NA, not available. 
 Blank cells indicate that the supplement was not part of the trial. 
 The years of follow‐up are the same as the years of supplementation.