Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 11;2021(8):CD005624. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005624.pub4

8. Recurrence.

EVLA versus RFA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yr
EVLA RFA
Nordon 2011 No results
Rasmussen 2011 3 yr 24/144 (17) 17/147 (12)
Recovery 2009 No results
Shepherd 2010 No results
Syndor 2017 Mention 'recurrent symptoms' but do not specify what this entails
EVLA versus EVSA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yr
EVLA EVSA
LAST 2014 No results
EVLA versus UGFS
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
EVLA UGFS
Magna 2013 1 yr 9/78 (12) 21/77 (27)
Rasmussen 2011 3 yr 24/144 (17) 20/144 (14)
Vernermo 2016 No results
EVLA versus CA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
EVLA CA
Calik 2019 1 yr 5/204 (2) 2/208 (1)
EVLA versus MOCA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
EVLA MOCA
Vähäaho 2019 1 yr 0/33 (0) 10/55 (18)
EVLA versus HL/S (surgery)
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
EVLA HL/S (surgery)
Darwood 2008a 1 yr No results
Flessenkämper 2013 2 yr 20/112 (17.8) 11/94(11.7)
HELP‐1 2011 1 yr 5/124 (4) 23/113 (20)
Magna 2013 1 yr 9/78 (12) 6/68 (9)
Pronk 2010 1 yr 5/62 (8) 5/68 (7)
Rasmussen 2007 2 yr 18/69 (26) 25/68 (37)
Rasmussen 2011a 3 yr 24/144 (17) 22/143 (15)
RELACS 2012 2 yr 28/173 (16) 33/143 (23)
Vernermo 2016 no results
RFA versus UGFS
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
RFA UGFS
Rasmussen 2011 17/147 (12) 20/144 (14)
RFA versus CA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
RFA CA
Morrison 2015 no results
RFA versus MOCA
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
RFA MOCA
Lane 2017 4/68 (6) 3/77 (4)
MARADONA 2019 2 yr 21/76 (28) 12/81 (15)
Vähäaho 2019 1 yr 0/32 (0) 10/55 (18)
RFA versus HL/S (surgery)
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
RFA HL/S (surgery)
EVOLVeS 2003 2 yr 5/36 (14) 6/29 (21)
Helmy ElKaffas 2011 2 yr 12/81 (15) 9/81 (11)
Rasmussen 2011a 3 yr 17/148 (11) 22/143 (15)
Rautio 2002 2 yr 5/15 (33) 2/13 (15)
Subramonia 2010 not reported
UGFS versus HL/S (surgery)
Study ‐ final time point Recurrence noted at final time point (%) < 5 yrs
UGFS HL/S (surgery)
FOAM 2010 2 yr 75/213 (35) 37/177 (21)
Magna 2013 1 yr 21/77 (27) 6/68 (9)
Rasmussen 2011a 3 yr 20/144 (14) 22/143 (15)
Vernermo 2016 not reported

aReported as limbs and not participants

CA: cyanoacrylate glue
EVLA: endovenous laser ablation
EVSA: endovenous steam ablation
HL/S: high ligation and stripping
MOCA: mechanochemical ablation
RFA: radio frequency ablation
UGFS: ultrasound‐guided foam sclerotherapy 
yr: year(s)