Skip to main content
letter
. 2021 Sep 1;370:130830. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2021.130830

Table 1.

Comparison of rapid detection methods for hazardous substances in foods and COVID-19.

Methods COVID-19
Hazardous
Characteristics Instruments Mechanism
Targets Specimens Targets Samples
high-throughput sequencing (HTS) DNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Foodborne pathogen, genetically modified composition, foodborne composition, etc. Fermented food, meat products, etc. No need to culture, no preference, can complete the detection of a variety of pathogens such as bacteria, fungi, viruses and parasites at one time Sequencer After the target RNA is made into a DNA library that can be identified and analysed by a sequencer, the simultaneous detection of millions of nucleic acid sequences can be achieved



Real-time fluorescent quantitative PCR (RT-PCR) DNA complementary to RNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Foodborne pathogen, genetically modified composition, foodborne composition, etc. Fermented food, meat products, etc. Not time-consuming, many test samples, simple and fast result judgment, low test cost, need professional instruments and operators UV analyser, electrophoretic instrument The complementary DNA obtained by the target genome RNA restore is used as a template to amplify the nucleic acid sequence of the pathogen, and the intensity of the fluorescent dye and the product is successfully detected by the intensity of the fluorescent signal



Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) DNA complementary to RNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Foodborne pathogen, genetically modified composition, foodborne composition, etc. Fermented food, meat products, etc. Fast amplification, simple operation, simple detection, and intuitive judgment of detection results Turbidity or visualization Design specific primers for specific areas of the target gene, then use strand-displacement DNA polymerase, and keep it at constant temperature for 10 min to achieve nucleic acid amplification



Recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) DNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Foodborne pathogens, genetically modified crops, food microorganisms, etc. Fermented food, meat products, etc. Sensitive amplification is achieved at normal temperatures, no equipment is required, the limit is low RPA analyser After the recombinase is involved, the protein-DNA complex is formed, the DNA chain substituted by the strand displacement enzyme is bonded to the SSB protein, and the DNA chain extends with the template DNA double helix continuously restricted to achieve product amplification



Constant temperature amplification chip RNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Food microorganisms Fermented food, meat products, etc. High sensitivity, strong specificity, no complicated sample processing, easy to miss the detection of rare pathogenic pathogens Analyser Nucleic acid amplification and nucleic acid extraction were performed using a chain shift DNA polymerase under constant temperature conditions, and perform corresponding labelling by means of fluorescein



Detection technology based on Cas enzyme RNA Upper or lower respiratory tract Low-cost, accurate, time-saving but requires high specificity of crRNA target recognition Fluorescence analyser CRISPR RNA binded the target sequence while the nonspecific endonuclease activity of Cas13 or Cas12 started, which led to the cleavage of nearby reporter RNAs and generated the signal



Colloidal gold immunochromatography assay (GICA) IgM, IgG, total antibody Blood or serum samples Pesticide residues, veterinary drug residues, hormones Meat products, crops, etc. Quick and easy, no special equipment is needed, no quantification, risk of exposure, low sensitivity, and easily interfered with by environmental factors Colloidal immunoassial analyser or visualization Based on the antigen–antibody specific immune response, colloidal gold particles are used as a tracer to mark one of them The marker is driven by solvent chromatography and immune response occurs on the C/T line



Enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) IgA, IgM, IgG, total antibody, plasma cytokines Whole blood, serum or plasma Veterinary drugs residue, antibiotic, pesticides residue, protein, offending drug, genetically modified, toxins, etc. Meat products, crops, etc. Highly sensitive and specific, many options for different determination and analysis, few requirements for reagents, the reproducibility of data is higher Enzyme detection instrument or visualization The principle of colour change occurs through the binding of antibodies and enzyme complexes while maintaining immunoactivity of antibodies



Fluorescence immunochromatography Total antibody and IgM Blood or serum sample Foodborne pathogen, metals ions, pesticides/herbicides/metabolites residues, preservatives, protein, etc. Fermented food, meat products, crops, water, etc. High sensitivity, high resolution, wide detection range and low reagent cost Fluorescence spectrophotometer Use fluorescent substances as tracer markers to label specific antibodies (or antigens), and then combine with the antigens (or antibodies) to be tested, and detect the specific fluorescence reaction with a fluorescence detector



Electrochemical biosensor Reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the sputum sample Sputum Foodborne pathogen, metals ions, pesticides/herbicides/metabolites residues, preservatives, protein, etc. Fermented food, meat products, crops, water, etc. Simple structure, convenient assembly, sensitive and accurate detection results Visualization Identifying the interaction of the target analyte and the biosensor to convert the chemical amount of the analyte to the electrical signal to achieve the monitoring of the target



Lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) IgM, IgG, total antibody Blood or serum sample Proteins, pathogens, toxins and antibiotics Processing food, dairy products, etc. Low sensitivity, material errors will affect the test results Visualization Based on a sandwich immunoassay that captures the target molecule and shows different signals (colours) on the test and control line using colloidal gold, carbon, or latex as commonly labels



Chest computed tomography (CT) scan Virus-infected lung Lung Painless, non-invasive, requiring highly trained personnel and sophisticated instrumentation Computed tomography scanner The detection of the virus in a patient is based on identifying the possible abnormalities caused by the viral infection in the chest by cross sectional X-ray images taken from different angles