Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 6;8(1):e000948. doi: 10.1136/bmjresp-2021-000948

Table 1.

Description of the included studies

Authors/design Study sample Nitrate (NO3-) dose Placebo Duration Wash-out Results
(following NO3- vs placebo)
Behnia et al, 2018/RCT28 N=25
GOLD stage 1–4
Age (y): 68±9
Sex (M/F): 13/12
70 mL BRJ + 180 mL black currant juice 70 mL water + 180 mL black currant juice 8 days No
  • No effect on VO2 at peak (p>0.05)

  • Significant change in SBP: 11 mm Hg (p<0.05) at peak exercise in the NO3- group only compared with pre-NO3-

  • Significant increase in FeNO (ppb) in NO3- group (p<0.05)

  • No effect on DBP (p>0.05)

  • No effect on heart rate (HR) (p>0.05)

Beijers et al, 2018/RXT26 N=18
GOLD stage 1–2
Age (y): 67±8
Sex (M/F): 13/5
FEV1%=69.2
Sodium NO3- (8 mmol) NaCl ingestion Acute and
7 days
7 days
  • No effect on endurance cycle time (p=0.08)

  • No effect on VO2 on day 1 and day 7 during submaximal cycling at 70% Wmax (p=0.56)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level on day 1 and day 7 (p=<0.001)

  • Significant increase on NO2- level on day 1 (p<0.001) and day 7 (p=0.003)

  • No effect on SBP on day 1 and day 7 at 150 min (p=0.66)

  • No effect on DBP on day 1 and day 7 at 150 min (p=0.35)

  • No effect on physical activity, counts/min (p=0.53)

  • No effect on HR on day 1 and day 7 at 150 min (p=0.76)

Berry et al, 2015/RXT16 N=15
GOLD stage 1–2
Age (y): 70±9
Sex (M/F): 12/3
FEV1%=61.8
140 mL BRJ (7.58 mmol) 163 mL prune juice (0.01 mmol NO3-) Acute 7 days
  • 28.8 s longer in endurance cycle time (p=0.031)

  • No effect on VO2 at end exercise (p=0.43)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p<0.001)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO2- level (p=0.001)

  • Significant change in resting SBP: 8.2 mm Hg, p=0.019

  • Significant change in iso-time DBP: 6.4 mm Hg (p=0.001)

  • Significant change end exercise in DBP: 5.6 mm Hg (p=0.08)

  • No effect on HR, p=0.70

  • No effect on O2 saturation, p=1.0

Curtis et al, 2015/RXT29 N=21
GOLD stage 2–4
Age (y): 68±7
Sex (M/F): 16/5
FEV1%=50.1
140 mL BRJ (12.9 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ Acute 7 days
  • No effect on median endurance time (p=0.50)

  • Significantly lower iso-time VO2 (p=0.04)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p<0.0001)

  • No effect on SBP

  • Significant change in DBP: 7 mm Hg (p=0.01)

  • No effect on MAP (p=0.07)

  • No effect on HR (p=0.06)

  • No effect on O2 saturation (p=0.26)

Friis et al, 2015/RXT30 N=15
GOLD stage 2–4
Age (y): 63±13
Sex (M/F): 9/6
FEV1%=44.7
140 mL BRJ 140 mL ND-BRJ 7 days 7 days
  • No effect on exercise capacity (p=0.46)

  • No effect on VO2 (p=0.31)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO2- level (p<0.01)

  • No effect on SBP (p=0.80)

  • Significant reduction on DBP (p<0.05)

  • No effect on HR (p=0.86)

  • No effect on physical activity (p>0.05)

Henrohn et al, 2018/RXT27 N=15
Pulmonary hypertension, WHO group 1
Age (y): 60±15
Sex (M/F): 7/8
140 mL BRJ (16 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ (0.118 mmol NO3-) 7 days 4–9 days
  • No effect on exercise capacity (p=0.445)

  • No effect on VO2 (p=1.00)

  • Significant higher in FeNO levels (p<0.001)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p<0.001)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO2- level (p<0.001)

  • No effect on SBP (p=0.482)

  • No effect on DBP (p=1.000)

  • No effect on HR p=0.191

Kerley et al, 2015/RXT17 N=11
GOLD stage 2–4
Age (y): 69±7
Sex (M/F): 5/6
FEV1%=43.4
140 mL BRJ + 200 mL black currant cordial 140 mL water + 200 mL black currant cordial Acute 7 days
  • ISWT distance increased 25 m (p=0.005)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p=0.000005)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO2- level (p<0.01)

  • Significant change in SBP: 12 mm Hg (p=0.03)

  • Significant change in DBP: 2 mm Hg (p=0.045)

  • Significant change in MAP: 5 mm Hg (p=0.018)

  • No effect on HR (p=0.19)

  • No effect on O2 saturation (p=0.71)

Kerley et al, 2019/RXT18 N=8
GOLD stage 1–3
Age (y): 63±7
Sex (M/F): 5/3
FEV1%=55
140 mL BRJ (12.9 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ (0.5 mmol NO3-) 14 days NA
  • ISWT distance increased 56 m (p=0.0004)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p=0.015)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO2- level (p=0.02)

  • No effect on FeNO level (p=0.095)

  • No effect on SBP (p=0.14)

  • No effect on DBP (p=0.35)

Leong et al, 2015/RXT31 N=19
GOLD stage 2
Age (y): 67±8
Sex (M/F): 5/14
FEV1%=62
140 mL BRJ (9.6 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ (0.0056–0.020 mmol NO3-) 3 days 4 days
  • Endurance distance increased 79 m (p=0.494)

  • Increase time to fatigue by 6% (p=0.693)

  • Significant change SBP in safety phase: 10 mm Hg at 1-hour standing (p=0.001) and 7.5 mm Hg at 4-hour standing (p=0.029)

  • No effect on DBP in safety phase: 0.1 mm Hg at 1-hour standing (p=0.966) and 2.7 mm Hg at 4-hour standing (p=0.352)

Pavitt et al, 2020/RCT
During PR19
N=122
GOLD stage 2–4
Age (y): 68±10
Sex (M/F): 69/53
FEV1%=49
140 mL BRJ (12.9 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ 56 days No
  • Significant increase in ISWT distance by 60 m (p=0.027)

  • Significant change in SBP: 5 mm Hg (p<0.0005)

  • Significant change in DBP: 5 mm Hg (p<0.0005)

  • Significant change in MAP: 5.0 mm Hg (p<0.0005)

  • Significant change in the FMD in BRJ group +6.6% (p=0.046)

  • Significant increase in physical activity by 348 step/day (p=0.02)

Shepherd et al, 2015/RXT32 N=13
GOLD stage 1–2
Age (y): 65±8
Sex (M/F): NR
FEV1%=57
140 mL BRJ (13.5 mmol) 140 mL ND-BRJ (0.004 mmol NO3-) 2.5 days 7 days
  • No effect on 6MWD (p=0.17)

  • No effect on baseline VO2(p=0.56) and end exercise VO2 (p=0.88)

  • Significant increase in plasma NO3- level (p=0.002)

  • No effect on SBP (p=0.91)

  • No effect on DBP (p=0.25)

BRJ, beetroot juice; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; FeNO, fractional exhaled nitric oxide; FMD, flow-mediated dilatation; GOLD, Global Obstructive Lung Disease; ISWT, incremental shuttle walk test; MAP, mean arterial pressure; 6MWD, 6-minute walk distance; N, number of participants who completed the trial; NA, not available; NaCl, Sodium chloride; ND-BRJ, nitrate-depleted beetroot juice; NO2-, nitrite; NR, not reported; RCT, randomised controlled trial; RXT, randomised crossover trial; SBP, systolic blood pressure; VO2, oxygen consumption.;