Table 1.
Model system | Strengths | Weaknesses | Examples |
---|---|---|---|
Cultured cell and organoid models | |||
Rodent-derived CMs | Primary cells Neonatal cardiomyocytes: easily harvested with well-established protocols; easy to transfect |
Neonatal cardiomyocytes: immature; express fetal gene program Adult cardiomyocytes: isolation and transfection are more challenging; contraction requires pacing; shorter time frame for performing assays |
Anthracyclines2 |
Human cardiovascular cell lines (eg, hiPSC-CMs) | Can be expanded endlessly; derived from multiple easily accessible cell types; ability to study pathways specific to humans | Immature cells; experimental and genetic variability; optimal media conditions that replicate in vivo cardiotoxicity have not been clearly defined | Anthracyclines3 Trastuzumab4 Proteasome inhibitors5 |
Microtissues and organoid systems | More physiologically relevant than isolated cell culture; potential to study multiple cell types simultaneously | Need for manual cell injection, resulting in nonstandardized organoids; absence of in vivo cell-to-cell communication and environment | Sunitinib6 |
In vivo models | |||
Zebratish | Vertebrate model with conservation of most disease-causing human genes; small size enables high-throughput screening; optical transparence facilitates imaging | Often used in embryonic/larval stage; 2-chamber heart without pulmonary circulation; zebrafish-specific reagents (eg, antibodies) may not be readily available | Anthracyclines7 Tyrosine kinase inhibitors8 Amyloid light-chain cardiotoxicity9 |
Rodents (mice, rats) | Most well-established in vivo model for studying toxicity; transgenic models and antibodies often already exist | Most models do not accurately reflect human comorbidities (hypertension, diabetes, aging) or concomitant cardiotoxic therapies | Anthracyclines10–12 HER2 inhibition1 Sunitinib13 |
Large animals (rabbits, swine, dogs) | Facilitate translation of diagnostic modalities and cardioprotective strategies | Costly and time-consuming; potential for gap in translation to humans | Anthracyclines14 |
HER2 indicates human epidermal growth factor receptor 2; HER2, human epidermal growth factor receptor 2; and hiPSC-CMs, human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes.