Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 8;2021(9):CD009437. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009437.pub3

7. Sensitivity analysis primary outcomes.

Outcome No. of studies No. of participants Studies omitted Effect Effect size 95% CI I² P value
1.1 SGRQ: short‐term (≤ 6 months)
1.1.1 SGRQ: total 12 1386 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.65 ‐5.66, ‐1.64 0.04 46
16 1788   MD ‐3.78 ‐6.29, ‐1.28 <0.00001 72
1.1.2 SGRQ: symptoms 9 919 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐1.94 ‐5.26, 1.38 0.09 41
13 1327   MD ‐1.56 ‐5.66, 2.53 <0.00001 71
1.1.3 SGRQ: activity 9 916 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.63 ‐5.66, ‐1.61 0.49 0
0 1320   MD ‐3.04 ‐5.80, ‐0.28 0.02 50
1.1.4 SGRQ: impact 9 917 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐4.1 ‐6.30, ‐1.90 0.17 31
  1322   MD ‐3.76 ‐5.94,‐1.57 0.04 46
1.2 SGRQ: medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months)
1.2.1 SGRQ: total 13 3889 Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.95 ‐6.06, ‐1.84 <0.00001 78
18 4321   MD ‐3.89 ‐6.16, ‐1.63 <0.00001 83
1.2.2 SGRQ: symptoms 7 2195 Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.11 ‐6.00, ‐0.21 0.04 55
12 2628   MD ‐3.88 ‐7.75, ‐0.02 <0.00001 79
1.2.3 SGRQ: activity 7 2175 Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.09 ‐5.98, ‐0.20 0.008 65
12 2608   MD ‐2.57 ‐5.53,0.38 < 0.0001 71
1.2.4 SGRQ: impact 7 2178 Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 MD ‐3.2 ‐6.19, ‐0.21 0.95 0
12 2610   MD ‐3.34 ‐6.26, ‐0.41 <0.00001 77
1.3 SGRQ: long‐term (> 15 months)
1.3.1 SGRQ: total 2 970 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 MD ‐1.02 ‐4.30, 2.27 0.09 65
4 1090   MD ‐0.69 ‐3.31, 1.93 0.22 31
1.3.2 SGRQ: symptoms 1 157 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 MD n.a. n.a. n.a n.a
3 279   MD 2.35 ‐5.49, 10.19 0.08 60
1.3.3 SGRQ: activity 1 157 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 MD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
3 278   MD ‐2.87 ‐6.17, 0.43 0.55 0
1.3.4 SGRQ: impact 1 150 Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 MD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
3 270   MD ‐2.21 ‐4.71, 0.29 0.49 0
1.8 CRQ: short‐term (≤ 6 months)
1.8.1 CRQ: dyspnoea 1 160 Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 MD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
4 277   MD 0.8 ‐0.01, 1.62 0.0001 86
1.8.2 CRQ: fatigue 3 196 Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 MD 0.01 ‐1.34, 1.35 0.28 21
6 314   MD 0.71 ‐0.19, 1.62 <0.00001 84
1.8.3 CRQ: emotion 3 196 Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 MD ‐0.33 ‐0.65, ‐0.01 0.37 0
6 314   MD 0.45 ‐0.26, 1.17 0.003 72
1.8.4 CRQ: mastery 3 196 Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 MD 0.38 ‐1.20, 1.96 0.22 35
6 314   MD 0.72 ‐0.08, 1.52 0.0002 79
1.9 CRQ: medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months)
1.9.1 CRQ: dyspnoea 1 159 Güell 2000 MD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
2 219   MD 0.29 ‐0.88, 1.46 0.004 88
1.9.2 CRQ: fatigue 3 195 Güell 2000 MD 0.35 ‐1.22, 1.93 0.21 35
4 255   MD 0.37 ‐0.53, 1.26 0.05 63
1.9.3 CRQ: emotion 3 195 Güell 2000 MD 0.26 ‐1.91, 2.43 0.9 20
4 255   MD 0.36 ‐0.84, 1.57 0.01 73
1.9.4 CRQ: mastery 3 195 Güell 2000 MD 1.06 ‐1.19, 3.30 0.08 60
4 255   MD 0.76 ‐0.41, 1.94 0.004 78
1.10 CRQ: long‐term (> 15 months)
1.10.1 CRQ: dyspnoea 1 104 Güell 2000 MD n.a. n.a.    
2 151   MD 0.47 ‐0.31, 1.25 0.07 70
1.10.2 CRQ: fatigue 3 137 Güell 2000 MD 0.42 ‐0.05, 0.89 0.75 0
4 184   MD 0.46 0.06, 0.85 0.88 0
1.10.3 CRQ: emotion 3 137 Güell 2000 MD 0.52 0.00, 1.04 1 0
4 184   MD 0.52 0.10, 0.95 1 0
1.10.4 CRQ: mastery 3 137 Güell 2000 MD 0.75 0.22, 1.28 0.67 0
4 184   MD 0.83 0.41, 1.26 0.78 0
1.11 SF‐36
1.11.1 SF‐36 MCS score 3 2212 Lilholt 2017, Vianello 2016 MD 0.44 ‐0.43, 1.31 0.44 0
5 3699   MD 0.36 ‐0.38,1.11 0.75 0
1.11.2 SF‐36 PCS score 3 2217 Lilholt 2017, Vianello 2016 MD ‐0.17 ‐1.05, 0.71 0.33 0
5 3704     1.06 ‐0.67, 2.79 < 0.0001 84
1.13 Functional exercise capacity: 6MWD
1.13.1 6MWD: short‐term (≤ 6 months) 8 886 Bendstrup 1997, Bernocchi 2017Cambach 1997, Gottlieb 2011, Güell 2000, Güell 2006, Mendes 2010, Tabak 2014, Wang 2017 MD 41 4.40, 77.60 < .00001 92
17 1390   MD 52.56 32.39,72.74 < 0.0001 90
1.13.2 6MWD: medium‐term (> 6
months to 15 months) 9 1576 Engstrom 1999, Güell 2000, Kessler 2018, Wang 2017 MD 40.49 9.71, 71.27 <0.00001 92
13 2071   MD 44.69 24.01, 65.37 <0.00001 90
1.13.3 6MWD: long‐term (> 15 months) 3 973 Gottlieb 2011, Güell 2000, Lou 2015 MD 36.4 ‐6.43, 79,24 <0.00001 94
6 7288   MD 48.43 16.37, 80.49 <0.00001 90
1.18 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions
1.18.1 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions: short‐term (≤ 6 months) 2 265 Bernocchi 2017 OR 0.71 0.28, 1.81 0.43 0
  377   OR 0.6 0.30, 1.22 0.65 0
1.18.2 Respiratory‐related hospital
admissions: medium‐term (> 6 to 15
months) 8 2224 Rea 2004, Smith 1999 OR 0.56 0.42, 0.76 0.06 48
  2449   OR 0.6 0.44, 0.81 0.01 57
1.18.3 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions:
long‐term (> 15 months) 2 0 n.a. OR n.a. n.a. n.a.  
2 1381   OR 0.85 0.59, 1.23 0.23 29
1.22 All hospital admissions
1.22.2 All hospital admissions: medium‐
term (> 6 months to 15 months) 3 760 Rea 2004, Kessler 2018 OR 0.91 0.66, 1.26 0.74 0
5 1212   OR 0.93 0.71, 1.21 0.33 14
1.22.3 All hospital admissions: long‐term
(> 15 months) 3 1485 Lou 2015 OR 0.88 0.61, 1.27 0.2 38
4 1920   OR 0.72 0.45, 1.04 0.007 55
1.23 Hospital days per patient (all causes)
1.23.1 Hospital days per patient (all
causes): short‐term (≤ 6 months) 2 0 n.a. MD n.a. n.a. n.a.  
2 273   MD ‐4.36 ‐6.41, ‐2.31 0.16 49
1.23.2 Hospital days per patient (all
causes): medium‐term (> 6 to 15
months) 5 2086 Engstrom 1999, Farrero 2001, Kessler 2018, Rea 2004, Vianello 2016 MD ‐1.01 ‐3.41, 1.38 0.001 78
10 2944   MD ‐1.73 ‐3.71, 0.25 0.0003 71
1.23.3 Hospital days per patient (all
causes): long‐term (> 15 months) 1 175 Titova 2017 MD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.
2 346   MD ‐1.6 ‐6.12, 2.92 0.1 63
1.24 ED visits 6 2343 Lou 2015, Rea 2004, Smith 1999, OR 0.69 0.50, 0.94 0.02 64
9 3005   OR 0.69 0.50, 0.93 0.02 68
1.26 Number of patients using ≥ 1 course of oral steroids 2 218 Farrero 2001, Rea 2004 OR 1.17 0.57, 2.40 0.19 42
4 433   OR 1.05 0.66, 1.64 0.25 27
1.27 Number of patients using ≥ 1 course of antibiotics 2 218 Rea 2004 OR 2.35 1.02, 5.42 0.15 53
3 321   OR 1.46 0.51, 4.18 0.007 80

Abbreviations. 6MWD: 6‐minute walking distance; CI: confidence interval; CRQ: Chronic Respiratory Questionnaire; ED: emergency department; MD: mean difference; OR: odds ratio; SF‐36: Short Form‐36; SGRQ: St. George's Respiratory Questionnaire.