7. Sensitivity analysis primary outcomes.
Outcome | No. of studies | No. of participants | Studies omitted | Effect | Effect size | 95% CI | I² | P value |
1.1 SGRQ: short‐term (≤ 6 months) | ||||||||
1.1.1 SGRQ: total | 12 | 1386 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.65 | ‐5.66, ‐1.64 | 0.04 | 46 |
16 | 1788 | MD | ‐3.78 | ‐6.29, ‐1.28 | <0.00001 | 72 | ||
1.1.2 SGRQ: symptoms | 9 | 919 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐1.94 | ‐5.26, 1.38 | 0.09 | 41 |
13 | 1327 | MD | ‐1.56 | ‐5.66, 2.53 | <0.00001 | 71 | ||
1.1.3 SGRQ: activity | 9 | 916 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.63 | ‐5.66, ‐1.61 | 0.49 | 0 |
0 | 1320 | MD | ‐3.04 | ‐5.80, ‐0.28 | 0.02 | 50 | ||
1.1.4 SGRQ: impact | 9 | 917 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐4.1 | ‐6.30, ‐1.90 | 0.17 | 31 |
1322 | MD | ‐3.76 | ‐5.94,‐1.57 | 0.04 | 46 | |||
1.2 SGRQ: medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months) | ||||||||
1.2.1 SGRQ: total | 13 | 3889 | Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.95 | ‐6.06, ‐1.84 | <0.00001 | 78 |
18 | 4321 | MD | ‐3.89 | ‐6.16, ‐1.63 | <0.00001 | 83 | ||
1.2.2 SGRQ: symptoms | 7 | 2195 | Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.11 | ‐6.00, ‐0.21 | 0.04 | 55 |
12 | 2628 | MD | ‐3.88 | ‐7.75, ‐0.02 | <0.00001 | 79 | ||
1.2.3 SGRQ: activity | 7 | 2175 | Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.09 | ‐5.98, ‐0.20 | 0.008 | 65 |
12 | 2608 | MD | ‐2.57 | ‐5.53,0.38 | < 0.0001 | 71 | ||
1.2.4 SGRQ: impact | 7 | 2178 | Engstrom 1999, Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017, Wang 2017, Wood‐Baker 2006 | MD | ‐3.2 | ‐6.19, ‐0.21 | 0.95 | 0 |
12 | 2610 | MD | ‐3.34 | ‐6.26, ‐0.41 | <0.00001 | 77 | ||
1.3 SGRQ: long‐term (> 15 months) | ||||||||
1.3.1 SGRQ: total | 2 | 970 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 | MD | ‐1.02 | ‐4.30, 2.27 | 0.09 | 65 |
4 | 1090 | MD | ‐0.69 | ‐3.31, 1.93 | 0.22 | 31 | ||
1.3.2 SGRQ: symptoms | 1 | 157 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a | n.a |
3 | 279 | MD | 2.35 | ‐5.49, 10.19 | 0.08 | 60 | ||
1.3.3 SGRQ: activity | 1 | 157 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
3 | 278 | MD | ‐2.87 | ‐6.17, 0.43 | 0.55 | 0 | ||
1.3.4 SGRQ: impact | 1 | 150 | Gottlieb 2011, Titova 2017 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
3 | 270 | MD | ‐2.21 | ‐4.71, 0.29 | 0.49 | 0 | ||
1.8 CRQ: short‐term (≤ 6 months) | ||||||||
1.8.1 CRQ: dyspnoea | 1 | 160 | Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
4 | 277 | MD | 0.8 | ‐0.01, 1.62 | 0.0001 | 86 | ||
1.8.2 CRQ: fatigue | 3 | 196 | Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 | MD | 0.01 | ‐1.34, 1.35 | 0.28 | 21 |
6 | 314 | MD | 0.71 | ‐0.19, 1.62 | <0.00001 | 84 | ||
1.8.3 CRQ: emotion | 3 | 196 | Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 | MD | ‐0.33 | ‐0.65, ‐0.01 | 0.37 | 0 |
6 | 314 | MD | 0.45 | ‐0.26, 1.17 | 0.003 | 72 | ||
1.8.4 CRQ: mastery | 3 | 196 | Cambach 1997, Güell 2000, Güell 2006 | MD | 0.38 | ‐1.20, 1.96 | 0.22 | 35 |
6 | 314 | MD | 0.72 | ‐0.08, 1.52 | 0.0002 | 79 | ||
1.9 CRQ: medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months) | ||||||||
1.9.1 CRQ: dyspnoea | 1 | 159 | Güell 2000 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
2 | 219 | MD | 0.29 | ‐0.88, 1.46 | 0.004 | 88 | ||
1.9.2 CRQ: fatigue | 3 | 195 | Güell 2000 | MD | 0.35 | ‐1.22, 1.93 | 0.21 | 35 |
4 | 255 | MD | 0.37 | ‐0.53, 1.26 | 0.05 | 63 | ||
1.9.3 CRQ: emotion | 3 | 195 | Güell 2000 | MD | 0.26 | ‐1.91, 2.43 | 0.9 | 20 |
4 | 255 | MD | 0.36 | ‐0.84, 1.57 | 0.01 | 73 | ||
1.9.4 CRQ: mastery | 3 | 195 | Güell 2000 | MD | 1.06 | ‐1.19, 3.30 | 0.08 | 60 |
4 | 255 | MD | 0.76 | ‐0.41, 1.94 | 0.004 | 78 | ||
1.10 CRQ: long‐term (> 15 months) | ||||||||
1.10.1 CRQ: dyspnoea | 1 | 104 | Güell 2000 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | ||
2 | 151 | MD | 0.47 | ‐0.31, 1.25 | 0.07 | 70 | ||
1.10.2 CRQ: fatigue | 3 | 137 | Güell 2000 | MD | 0.42 | ‐0.05, 0.89 | 0.75 | 0 |
4 | 184 | MD | 0.46 | 0.06, 0.85 | 0.88 | 0 | ||
1.10.3 CRQ: emotion | 3 | 137 | Güell 2000 | MD | 0.52 | 0.00, 1.04 | 1 | 0 |
4 | 184 | MD | 0.52 | 0.10, 0.95 | 1 | 0 | ||
1.10.4 CRQ: mastery | 3 | 137 | Güell 2000 | MD | 0.75 | 0.22, 1.28 | 0.67 | 0 |
4 | 184 | MD | 0.83 | 0.41, 1.26 | 0.78 | 0 | ||
1.11 SF‐36 | ||||||||
1.11.1 SF‐36 MCS score | 3 | 2212 | Lilholt 2017, Vianello 2016 | MD | 0.44 | ‐0.43, 1.31 | 0.44 | 0 |
5 | 3699 | MD | 0.36 | ‐0.38,1.11 | 0.75 | 0 | ||
1.11.2 SF‐36 PCS score | 3 | 2217 | Lilholt 2017, Vianello 2016 | MD | ‐0.17 | ‐1.05, 0.71 | 0.33 | 0 |
5 | 3704 | 1.06 | ‐0.67, 2.79 | < 0.0001 | 84 | |||
1.13 Functional exercise capacity: 6MWD | ||||||||
1.13.1 6MWD: short‐term (≤ 6 months) | 8 | 886 | Bendstrup 1997, Bernocchi 2017Cambach 1997, Gottlieb 2011, Güell 2000, Güell 2006, Mendes 2010, Tabak 2014, Wang 2017 | MD | 41 | 4.40, 77.60 | < .00001 | 92 |
17 | 1390 | MD | 52.56 | 32.39,72.74 | < 0.0001 | 90 | ||
1.13.2 6MWD: medium‐term (> 6 months to 15 months) | 9 | 1576 | Engstrom 1999, Güell 2000, Kessler 2018, Wang 2017 | MD | 40.49 | 9.71, 71.27 | <0.00001 | 92 |
13 | 2071 | MD | 44.69 | 24.01, 65.37 | <0.00001 | 90 | ||
1.13.3 6MWD: long‐term (> 15 months) | 3 | 973 | Gottlieb 2011, Güell 2000, Lou 2015 | MD | 36.4 | ‐6.43, 79,24 | <0.00001 | 94 |
6 | 7288 | MD | 48.43 | 16.37, 80.49 | <0.00001 | 90 | ||
1.18 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions | ||||||||
1.18.1 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions: short‐term (≤ 6 months) | 2 | 265 | Bernocchi 2017 | OR | 0.71 | 0.28, 1.81 | 0.43 | 0 |
377 | OR | 0.6 | 0.30, 1.22 | 0.65 | 0 | |||
1.18.2 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions: medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months) | 8 | 2224 | Rea 2004, Smith 1999 | OR | 0.56 | 0.42, 0.76 | 0.06 | 48 |
2449 | OR | 0.6 | 0.44, 0.81 | 0.01 | 57 | |||
1.18.3 Respiratory‐related hospital admissions: long‐term (> 15 months) | 2 | 0 | n.a. | OR | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | |
2 | 1381 | OR | 0.85 | 0.59, 1.23 | 0.23 | 29 | ||
1.22 All hospital admissions | ||||||||
1.22.2 All hospital admissions: medium‐ term (> 6 months to 15 months) | 3 | 760 | Rea 2004, Kessler 2018 | OR | 0.91 | 0.66, 1.26 | 0.74 | 0 |
5 | 1212 | OR | 0.93 | 0.71, 1.21 | 0.33 | 14 | ||
1.22.3 All hospital admissions: long‐term (> 15 months) | 3 | 1485 | Lou 2015 | OR | 0.88 | 0.61, 1.27 | 0.2 | 38 |
4 | 1920 | OR | 0.72 | 0.45, 1.04 | 0.007 | 55 | ||
1.23 Hospital days per patient (all causes) | ||||||||
1.23.1 Hospital days per patient (all causes): short‐term (≤ 6 months) | 2 | 0 | n.a. | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | |
2 | 273 | MD | ‐4.36 | ‐6.41, ‐2.31 | 0.16 | 49 | ||
1.23.2 Hospital days per patient (all causes): medium‐term (> 6 to 15 months) | 5 | 2086 | Engstrom 1999, Farrero 2001, Kessler 2018, Rea 2004, Vianello 2016 | MD | ‐1.01 | ‐3.41, 1.38 | 0.001 | 78 |
10 | 2944 | MD | ‐1.73 | ‐3.71, 0.25 | 0.0003 | 71 | ||
1.23.3 Hospital days per patient (all causes): long‐term (> 15 months) | 1 | 175 | Titova 2017 | MD | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
2 | 346 | MD | ‐1.6 | ‐6.12, 2.92 | 0.1 | 63 | ||
1.24 ED visits | 6 | 2343 | Lou 2015, Rea 2004, Smith 1999, | OR | 0.69 | 0.50, 0.94 | 0.02 | 64 |
9 | 3005 | OR | 0.69 | 0.50, 0.93 | 0.02 | 68 | ||
1.26 Number of patients using ≥ 1 course of oral steroids | 2 | 218 | Farrero 2001, Rea 2004 | OR | 1.17 | 0.57, 2.40 | 0.19 | 42 |
4 | 433 | OR | 1.05 | 0.66, 1.64 | 0.25 | 27 | ||
1.27 Number of patients using ≥ 1 course of antibiotics | 2 | 218 | Rea 2004 | OR | 2.35 | 1.02, 5.42 | 0.15 | 53 |
3 | 321 | OR | 1.46 | 0.51, 4.18 | 0.007 | 80 |
Abbreviations. 6MWD: 6‐minute walking distance; CI: confidence interval; CRQ: Chronic Respiratory Questionnaire; ED: emergency department; MD: mean difference; OR: odds ratio; SF‐36: Short Form‐36; SGRQ: St. George's Respiratory Questionnaire.