Author |
Country/Year |
Study design |
Patient characteristics |
Sample size |
Treatment group |
Control group |
Follow-up period |
Outcome |
Benedek et al. [8] |
Romania / 2014 |
CCT |
Adult with h/o STEMI and PPCI and abnormalities in wall motion and less than 50% stenosis |
18 |
Autologous MNC = 9 |
Placebo = 9 |
Four years with clinical examinations, ECG, Echocardiography, 64-slice CCTA |
A small improvement in EF and the plaque burden is lower in coronary segments treated with stem cells |
Alestalo et al. [9] |
Finland / 2015 |
Double-blinded RCT |
H/o STEMI, < 75 years, hemodynamically stable and no cardiogenic shock or rescue PCI/CABG |
26 |
BMMNC = 14 |
Placebo = 12 |
Cytokines after four days and LV angiogram after six months |
A balancing effect between the anti-inflammatory and proinflammatory cytokine BMMNC group at day four |
Bozdag-Turan et al. [10] |
Germany / 2012 |
CCT |
18–80 years with h/o STEMI, absence of co-morbidities, cancer, and active bleeding or trauma in the last two months |
24 |
BMC = 12 |
Placebo = 12 |
Six months with left ventriculography |
Infarct size and BNP level decreased, and global EF and infarct wall movement velocity were increased in the stem cell group |
Choudry et al. [11] |
5 centers in Europe [United Kingdom (3); Switzerland (1); Denmark (1)] / 2016 |
Double-blinded RCT |
Acute anterior MI with anterior wall motion abnormality and h/o PPCI |
100 |
BMMNC = 55 |
Placebo = 45 |
One year with cardiac MRI and Echocardiography |
Small non-significant improvement in LVEF |
Duan et al. [12] |
China / 2015 |
RCT |
H/o MI, < 75 years with planned CABG for triple-vessel disease, LVEF < 30%, and no aneurysm or valvular diseases |
42 |
CABG + BMMNC = 24 |
Only CABG = 18 |
One year with Echocardiography |
Improvement in left ventricular functions in the treatment group |
Gao et al. [6] |
China / 2015 |
Double-blinded RCT |
18-80 years with a h/o STEMI and reperfusion with stent implantation and LV local wall-motion abnormality. CK > three-fold the upper limit of the normal |
116 |
WJ-MSC = 58 |
Placebo = 58 |
18 months with F-18-FDG-PET and 99mTc-SPECT and two-dimensional Echocardiography |
LVEF significantly increased and LVESV and LVEDV greatly decreased in the treatment group |
Hu et al. [13] |
China / 2015 |
RCT |
18-75 years old with acute STEMI and PPCI with stent implantation or thrombolysis and LV local wall motion abnormality |
36 |
N-BMCs = 11, HP-BMCs = 11 |
Standard therapy = 14 |
Six and 12 months |
Improvement in changes of LVEDV, LVESV, and WMSI in the HP-BMC group. Myocardial perfusion defect ratio was reduced in HP-BMCs and N-BMC groups at six months |
Huan et al. [14] |
China / 2015 |
CT |
18-75 years old with a h/o acute STEMI and treatment with PCI, LVEF < 50% |
104 |
Group A = BMMNC within two hours after PCI = 27, Group B = three-seven days after PCI = 26, Group C = seven to 30 days after PCI = 26 |
Placebo = 25 patients |
Six months with angiography. SPECT and Echocardiography at six and 12 months |
Effects of cell therapy given within 24 hours are the same as to given three-seven days after PPCI |
Kim et al. [15] |
South Korea / 2018 |
RCT |
STEMI |
26 |
BMMNC = 14 |
Placebo = 12 |
Four and 12-months with SPECT |
Increase in the LVEF from baseline to the fourth month and twelfth month in the bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells group. |
Lee et al. [16] |
Korea / 2014 |
CT |
18-70 years old with STEMI |
69 |
MSC = 33 |
Placebo = 36 |
Six months with SPECT |
Safe with modest improvement in LVEF |
Makkar et al. [17] |
USA / 2012 |
CT |
H/o two to four weeks of MI and LVEF = 25–45% |
25 |
Cardio sphere-derived autologous stem cells = 17 |
Standard therapy = 8 |
Six months with MRI |
Scar mass was reduced, increase in viable heart mass and regional contractility in the CDC group. LVEDV, LVESV, and LVEF were the same in the two groups |
Malliaras et al. [18] |
USA / 2014 |
RCT |
Patients of CADUCEUS trial were followed up for a year |
25 |
Cardio sphere-derived autologous stem cells = 17 |
Standard therapy = 8 |
One year with MRI |
Scar size reduced, increased viable myocardium, and improved regional function of infarcted myocardium |
Micheu et al. [19] |
Romania / 2015 |
CT |
18-81 years old with STEMI & h/o angioplasty with stent implantation, LVEF < 40%. |
18 |
Autologous BMCs = 7 |
Standard therapy = 11 |
Six months with clinical examination, Echocardiography, 24 hours ECG |
Safe and LVEF was increased |
Moccetti et al. [20] |
Switzerland / 2012 |
CT |
Acute anterior STEMI treated by PPCI and LVEF < 50%. |
60 |
Autologous BMMNC = 23 |
Standard therapy = 37 |
Five years with Echocardiography |
Safe and LV function improved |
Moreira et al. [21] |
Brazil / 2011 |
RCT |
18-80 years old with h/o MI and reperfusion and involving more than 10% of the LV |
30 |
BMMNC via anterograde intra-arterial coronary (IAC) delivery = 14, BMMNC via retrograde intravenous coronary (IVC) delivery = 10 |
Placebo = 6 |
Cardiac MRI was performed before cell injection |
The retrograde approach to deliver stem cells was safe and cell retention by cardiac tissue is more in the anterograde approach |
Nair et al. [22] |
India / 2015 |
RCT |
Anterior MI and LVEF = 20-50%, 20-65 years with h/o CAG between one to three weeks |
250 |
Stem cell therapy + standard care = 125 |
Standard care = 125 |
Six months with Echocardiography |
Safe, but not clinically significant |
Naseri et al. [23] |
Iran / 2018 |
RCT |
18-75 years old with a h/o acute MI infarction, eligible for elective CABG |
77 |
CD133 (+) = 21, MNC = 30 |
Placebo = 26 |
Six and 18 months after CABG with SPECT |
Significant differences were seen between the MNC and placebo groups in LVEF and a decrease in the LV thickening |
Nicolau et al. [24] |
Brazil / 2018 |
RCT |
30-80 years, LVEF ≤ 50%, and regional dysfunction in the infarct-related area |
120 |
BMMNC = 66 |
Placebo = 55 |
Six months with MRI |
No significant effects |
Peregud-Pogorzelska et al. [25] |
Poland / 2020 |
CCT not randomized |
<65 years old with first MI and EF ≤ 45% |
34 |
Standard therapy + autologous BM-derived LIN- SPCs = 15 |
Only standard therapy = 19 |
One, three, six months, and one year with Echocardiography |
Safe and > 10% improvement in LVEF is noticed at 12 months |
Quyyumi et al. [26] |
USA / 2017 |
RCT |
STEMI with a stent and LVEF ≤ 48% and ≥ four days post stent |
161 |
Intracoronary infusion of autologous CD34 (+) cell = 78 |
Placebo = 83 |
Six months with SPECT |
Safe |
Rodrigo et al. [27] |
Netherlands / 2013 |
CCT |
First acute STEMI treated with PPCI and maximum CK level was > 1,600 U/L |
54 |
MSC = 9 |
Standard therapy = 45 matched but nonrandomized patients |
Three, six months, one year, four-five years with Echocardiography, Holter, and clinical examination |
Improvements in LV function but not significantly different when compared to controls |
Roncalli et al. [28] |
France / 2011 |
RCT |
Acute MI and successful reperfusion with LVEF ≤ 45%, age 18–75 years |
101 |
BMMNC = 52 |
Placebo = 49 |
Three months with MRI, Echocardiography, and SPECT |
Multivariate analysis shows improvement of myocardial viability than univariate analysis |
San Roman et al. [29] |
Spain / 2015 |
RCT |
Adult, acute MI with PPCI or post-fibrinolysis PCI and rapamycin drug-eluting stent implantation |
120 |
BMMNC = 30, GCSF = 30, G-CSF + cells = 29 |
Standard therapy = 31 |
12 months with cardiac MRI |
Not many differences among the four groups |
Shah et al. [3] |
India / 2014 |
CT |
30-70 years old, acute MI with PCI |
19 |
Autologous BMCS = 12 |
Standard therapy = 7 |
24 months with Echocardiography, ECG, Holter monitoring |
Increase in LVEF with LV function improvements in stem cell group |
Srimahachota et al. [30] |
Thailand / 2011 |
RCT |
H/o STEMI with LVEF < 50% and PCI |
23 |
Autologous BMCs = 11 |
Standard therapy = 12 |
Six months with cardiac MRI |
Symptoms improved than baseline, but not many significant changes were noticed in the two groups |
Sürder et al. [31] |
Switzerland / 2013 |
RCT |
Acute MI |
200 |
BMMNC five-seven days after STEMI = 66, BMMNC three to four weeks after STEMI = 67 |
Standard therapy = 67 |
Four months with cardiac MRI |
No significant improvements |
Traverse et al. [32] |
USA / 2012 |
RCT |
MI and PCI, LVEF < 45% |
120 |
BMMNC at day three or day seven randomly = 79 |
Placebo = 41 |
Six months with cardiac MRI |
No significant improvement |
Traverse et al. [33] |
USA / 2011 |
RCT |
Acute MI and PCI, LVEF < 45% |
87 |
BMMNC after two to three weeks of MI = 58 |
Placebo = 29 |
Six months with cardiac MRI |
No significant improvement |
Traverse et al. [34] |
USA / 2018 |
RCT |
Patients of TIME trial, acute MI and PCI, LVEF < 45% |
120 |
BMMNC at day three or day seven randomly = 79. 58 patients were followed up |
Placebo = 41, 27 patients were followed up |
Two years with cardiac MRI |
No significant improvement |
Turan et al. [35] |
Germany / 2011 |
RCT |
18-80 years old with MI and LV dysfunction |
56 |
BMMNC = 38 |
Placebo = 18 |
Three, six months, and one year with left ventriculography |
Decrease in infarct size but an increase of global EF and infarct wall movement velocity in stem cell group |
Yerebakan et al. [36] |
Germany / 2011 |
RCT |
MI at least 14 days before admission and LV akinesia with an indication for CABG |
55 |
Intramyocardial CD133 (+) BMCs + CABG = 35 |
Only CABG = 20 |
18 months with 24-hour Holter monitoring, echocardiography, MRI, and CT scan |
Intramyocardial stem cell therapy was tolerable but did not have significant improvements |