Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 8;2021(9):CD013381. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013381.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Alexopoulos 2016 Wrong study design (aimed at depressive symptoms).
Anonymous 2007 Wrong study design.
Berbecaru‐Iovan 2015 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Bock 2012 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Boland 2016 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Botvinikova 2003 Wrong population (asthma).
Buist 1997 Wrong intervention (smoking cessation).
Bunnag 2007 Wrong intervention (patient perception).
Cabedo Garcia 2010 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Chrystyn 2014 Wrong intervention (patient preference and satisfaction).
Collier 2017 Wrong study design (adherence reported as a post hoc outcome).
Dahl 2003 Wrong intervention (aimed at patient perception).
EUCTR2013‐001788‐21‐SK Wrong study design.
Evans 2019 Wrong intervention (aimed at re‐admissions to hospital).
Fischer 2000 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Gallefoss 1999 Wrong population (< 50% of the study population was COPD).
Garcia‐Aymerich 2007 Wrong study design (not aimed at adherence).
Hernandez 2001 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Holzer 1988 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Kirby 2016 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Kripalani 2007 Wrong study design (systematic review; no individual studies included COPD).
Mutterlein 1990 Wrong study design (no relevance to current management).
NCT00005717 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
NCT00462540 Wrong study design (not aimed at adherence).
NCT04052906 Wrong study design (not aimed at inhaler technique or adherence).
Nishimura 2011 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Pongchaidecha 2005 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Press 2016 Wrong study design (not aimed at inhaler improvement).
Riar 2016 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Schulte 2008 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Smith‐McLallen 2015 Wrong study design (cost‐effectiveness, mixed population).
Sung 1998 Unavailable.
Tack 2011 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Tashkin 1991 Wrong intervention (main intervention was a smoking cessation programme).
Trivedi 2012 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Van Ganse 2016 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Van Grunsven 2000 Wrong population.
Vanhaecht 2010 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Van Wijk 2005 Wrong study design (systematic review; no individual studies include COPD‐only population).
Vestbo 2009 Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence).
Viejo 2001 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Weinstein 2011 Wrong study design (not an RCT).
Yildirim 2015 Wrong study design (not an RCT).

COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RCT: randomised controlled trial.