Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Alexopoulos 2016 | Wrong study design (aimed at depressive symptoms). |
Anonymous 2007 | Wrong study design. |
Berbecaru‐Iovan 2015 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Bock 2012 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Boland 2016 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Botvinikova 2003 | Wrong population (asthma). |
Buist 1997 | Wrong intervention (smoking cessation). |
Bunnag 2007 | Wrong intervention (patient perception). |
Cabedo Garcia 2010 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Chrystyn 2014 | Wrong intervention (patient preference and satisfaction). |
Collier 2017 | Wrong study design (adherence reported as a post hoc outcome). |
Dahl 2003 | Wrong intervention (aimed at patient perception). |
EUCTR2013‐001788‐21‐SK | Wrong study design. |
Evans 2019 | Wrong intervention (aimed at re‐admissions to hospital). |
Fischer 2000 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Gallefoss 1999 | Wrong population (< 50% of the study population was COPD). |
Garcia‐Aymerich 2007 | Wrong study design (not aimed at adherence). |
Hernandez 2001 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Holzer 1988 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Kirby 2016 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Kripalani 2007 | Wrong study design (systematic review; no individual studies included COPD). |
Mutterlein 1990 | Wrong study design (no relevance to current management). |
NCT00005717 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
NCT00462540 | Wrong study design (not aimed at adherence). |
NCT04052906 | Wrong study design (not aimed at inhaler technique or adherence). |
Nishimura 2011 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Pongchaidecha 2005 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Press 2016 | Wrong study design (not aimed at inhaler improvement). |
Riar 2016 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Schulte 2008 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Smith‐McLallen 2015 | Wrong study design (cost‐effectiveness, mixed population). |
Sung 1998 | Unavailable. |
Tack 2011 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Tashkin 1991 | Wrong intervention (main intervention was a smoking cessation programme). |
Trivedi 2012 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Van Ganse 2016 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Van Grunsven 2000 | Wrong population. |
Vanhaecht 2010 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Van Wijk 2005 | Wrong study design (systematic review; no individual studies include COPD‐only population). |
Vestbo 2009 | Wrong intervention (not aimed at adherence). |
Viejo 2001 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Weinstein 2011 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
Yildirim 2015 | Wrong study design (not an RCT). |
COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RCT: randomised controlled trial.