Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 26;12:709851. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.709851

Table 2.

The overall effect size of Triple P on the outcomes.

k Pooled SMD Lower 95% CI Upper 95% CI I2 Tau2 Tau
1. Social competence in child 6 0.274 0.025 0.523 0.0% 0.000 0.000
2. Emotional problems in child 13 −0.254 −0.476 −0.031 65.0% 0.102 0.319
3. Behavioral problems in child-Total 17 −1.380 −2.161 −0.599 97.3% 2.508 1.584
   3.1 Problem 15 −0.467 −0.631 −0.303 42.5% 0.042 0.205
   3.2 Intensity 17 −0.378 −0.501 −0.255 15.6% 0.010 0.100
4. Parenting Style-Total 18 −0.460 −0.717 −0.203 83.3% 0.249 0.499
   4.1 Laxness 15 −0.482 −0.653 −0.310 50.9% 0.056 0.237
   4.2 Overreactivity 15 −0.480 −0.645 −0.315 47.3% 0.048 0.219
   4.3 Verbosity 10 −0.639 −0.878 −0.399 59.6% 0.084 0.290
5. Conflict over Parenting-Total 6 −0.311 −0.515 −0.106 11.4% 0.008 0.089
   5.1 Problem 8 −0.333 −0.638 −0.029 69.0% 0.127 0.356
   5.2 Extent 9 −0.268 −0.511 −0.025 57.8% 0.076 0.276
6. Parenting Confidence-Total 28 0.419 0.309 0.530 32.1% 0.027 0.164
   6.1 Behavior 14 0.491 0.339 0.643 34.3% 0.028 0.167
   6.2 Setting 9 0.304 0.111 0.497 32.1% 0.028 0.167
7. Parental Adjustment-Total 15 −0.265 −0.402 −0.128 19.3% 0.014 0.118
   7.1 Depression 15 −0.571 −1.003 −0.139 94.3% 0.660 0.812
   7.2 Anxiety 14 −0.278 −0.427 −0.128 48.7% 0.034 0.184
   7.3 Stress 14 −0.582 −1.055 −0.108 95.0% 0.748 0.865
8. Parent-Child relationships 5 −0.714 −1.292 −0.135 85.2% 0.368 0.607
9. Relationship Satisfaction of parents 9 0.063 −0.228 0.354 64.4% 0.126 0.355

k, number of studies; SMD, standard mean difference; CI, confidence interval; I2, the variation in SMD attributable to heterogeneity; Tau2, the estimation of the between-study variance.