Table 2.
Characteristics of the included studies classified into 8 different technology types.
| Technology type, study | Main goal of intervention | Study design | Patient typea | Total number of patients (per group) | |||||
| Audio: music/voice message | |||||||||
|
|
Damshens et al [40] | To improve mental stateb | Randomized clinical trial | ICUc (pediatric and adult) | 80 (Id: 40, Ce: 40) | ||||
|
|
Lee et al [39] | To reduce stress and anxiety | Randomized controlled trial | ICU | 85 (I: 41, C: 44) | ||||
|
|
Johnson et al [48] | To alter physiologic response | Randomized controlled trial | ICU/trauma orthopedic unit | 40 (I: 20, C: 20) | ||||
|
|
Sharda et al [53] | To mitigate postoperative pain and anxietyb | Organizational case study | Perioperative optimization of senior health | 202 (I: 45, C: 157) | ||||
|
|
Cheong et al [55] | To enhance engagement and mood and to improve agitated behaviorb | Pilot study (for randomized controlled trial) |
Acute care unit (patients with delirium, dementia, or both) | 25 (I: 25, C: 25) | ||||
|
|
Byun et al [33] | To activate positive psychological and behavioral responses and to reduce anxietyb | Double-blind randomized controlled trial |
PACUf (pediatric) | 66 (I1: 33, I2: 33) | ||||
|
|
Munro et al [49] | To support reorientation and to comfort patientsb | Three-group prospective randomized controlled trial | ICUg | 30 (I1:10, I2:10, C: 10) | ||||
| Light: Dynamic light/natural light | |||||||||
|
|
Estrup et al [58] | To improve circadian rhythmb | Retrospective cohort study | ICU | 183 (I: 46, C: 137) | ||||
|
|
Pustjens et al [60] | To improve circadian rhythmb | Retrospective observational cohort study |
Coronary care unit | 748 (I: 369, C: 379) | ||||
|
|
Simons et al [41] | To improve circadian rhythm and sleepb | Randomized controlled single-center trial | ICU | 734 (I: 361, C: 373) | ||||
|
|
Potharajaroen et al [42] | To improve sleep-wake cycleb | Single-blind randomized controlled study | ICU | 62 (I: 31, C: 31) | ||||
|
|
Smonig et al [54] | To reduce circadian rhythm disruptionb | Prospective single-center observational study | ICU | 179 (I: 102, C: 77) | ||||
| Video/video game: information/distraction | |||||||||
|
|
Lee et al [50] | To reduce preoperative anxietyb |
Quasi-experimental | ICU | 50 (I: 25, C: 25) | ||||
|
|
Kim et al [34] | To reduce preoperative anxiety | Prospective randomized controlled trial | PACU (pediatric) | 104 (I1: 34, I2: 33, I3: 37) | ||||
|
|
Rodriguez et al [35] | To reduce preoperative anxiety | Prospective randomized trial | PACU (pediatric) | 52 (I1: 25, I2: 27) | ||||
|
|
Waszynski et al [43] | To reduce agitation in patients experiencing hyperactive or mixed delirium | Randomized controlled trial | Hospitalized/ICUh | 111 (I1: 34, I2: 40, C: 37) | ||||
|
|
Dwairej et al [36] | To reduce preoperative anxiety | Randomized clinical trial | Day case surgery unit (pediatric) |
128 (I: 64, C: 64) | ||||
| Virtual reality: information/distraction | |||||||||
|
|
Eijlers et al [37] | To reduce pain and anxietyb | Randomized controlled single-blind trial | Day case surgery unit (pediatric) |
191 (I: 94, C: 97) | ||||
|
|
Ryu et al [38] | To reduce preoperative anxiety | Randomized controlled trial | PACU (pediatric) | 86 (I: 41, C: 39) | ||||
|
|
Suvajdzic et al [57] | To reduce clinical anxiety and depression and to support sleep and relaxationa | Pilot test | ICU | 10 | ||||
| Sleep aids | |||||||||
|
|
Demoule et al [44] | To improve sleep quality | Randomized controlled trial | ICU | 45 (I: 23, C: 22) | ||||
|
|
Van de Pol et al [19] | To improve sleep quality | Interrupted time series design (preintervention and postintervention) | ICU | 421 (I: 210, C: 211) | ||||
| Communication aids | |||||||||
|
|
Garry et al [56] | To improve patient’s psychosocial statusb |
Pilot prospective trial | ICU/coronary care unit | 12 | ||||
|
|
Bott et al [21] | To provide companionship, social support, and health information to decrease loneliness and depressionb |
Case control quasi-experimental pre-post (for randomized controlled trial) | Medical and surgical unit | 95 (I: 41, C: 54) | ||||
| Others | |||||||||
|
|
Lin et al [46] | To make the children adapt to the experience of visual disturbance |
Prospective blinded randomized trial |
PACU (pediatric) | 179 (I: 89, C: 90) | ||||
|
|
Giraud et al [45] | To support mental status, earlier physical mobilization, and multisensory feedback/integration |
Pilot time-cluster randomized controlled study | ICU | 223 (I: 115, C: 108) | ||||
| Multiple components | |||||||||
|
|
Arbabi et al [51] | To support reorientation, cognitive/physical activation, human interactionb | Quasi-experimental | ICU | 148 (I: 78, C: 69) | ||||
|
|
Tovar et al [52] | To reduce environmental precipitating factors, which impair sleep and to support maintenance of circadian cycle. |
Prospective pre-experimental | ICU | 49 | ||||
|
|
Rivosecchi et al [24] | To provide cognitive stimuli and to support reorientationb | Prospective, observational quality improvement project pre-post | Medical ICU | 483 (I: 253, C: 230) | ||||
|
|
Mitchell et al [47] | To support orientation and to provide cognitive stimulation | Single center randomized controlled trial | ICU | 61 (I: 29, C: 32) | ||||
|
|
Zachary et al [59] | To prevent functional/cognitive, sleep and visual/hearing impairment, and dehydration | Retrospective | Medical, surgical/telemetry unitsi | 4850 (I: 2146, C: 2704) | ||||
aAll patients are adults unless mentioned as pediatric patients.
bWith our minimal interpretation.
cICU: intensive care unit.
dI: intervention group.
eC: control group.
fPACU: post anesthesia care unit.
gAbout 10% was delirious at admission.
hOnly delirious patients.
iExcluding intensive care unit patients.