Table 1.
Techniques | Cell Type | Mechanical Stimuli | Important Parameters | Advantages | Limitations | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Classical Techniques | Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) | MCF7 [104]; Human bladder [96] |
Cantilever micro indention | Tip deflection, Young’s modulus | High-resolution measurement; Provids both structural and mechanical information for local, whole, and interior measurements [23,97] | Low throughput; Mechanical hitting of AFM tip may affect cell activities and position of probe; Requires a high-resolution microscope |
Micropipette aspiration (MA) | Human cartilage [98]; Colon cancer cells [105] |
Negative force | Young’s modulus | Low-cost and well-established method | Limited spatial resolution; Low throughput; For suspended cells only | |
Magnetic twisting cytometry (MTC) | Melanoma [100]; MCF7 [106] |
Force is applied by magnetic beads | Stiffness and Young’s modulus | Inducing little heat and photodamages compared to optical tweezer [10] | Resolution limitation; Inducing non-uniform stress; Beads are localized randomly on cell; Attachment angle affects the displacement | |
Optical tweezers (OP) | RBC [99,107] | Laser-induced surface force | Deformation index | Without physical contact | Only for suspended cells; Damaging consequence of optical heating on cells; Limited magnitude of forces |
|
Parallel plate | Epithelial ovarian cancer [23]; MCF7 [106,108] |
Shear stress | Aspect ratio | Homogeneity of the applied shear stress; Simplicity; Ability to study cell population | Need bulky devices; Large amount of reagents; Difficult to visualize deformation | |
Microfluidic Techniques | Fluid-induced deformation | PBMCs [102] | Fluid shear stress |
Deformation index, size | High throughput; Simultaneously, other chemical assays can be done; The measurment can be done continuously; Contactless deformation; Applicable for both suspended and adhered cells | Needing expensive high-speed camera for imaging |
Constriction-induced deformation | K562 [109]; MDA-MB-231 [110] |
Mechanical squeezing | Passage time, entry times, stiffness | Wide-ranging applications in cell deformation; Applicable for different geometry structures; Adjustable dimension for different cell types |
Clogging and channel blockage; Possible effects of friction between cell and channel’s wall on measurements; Ignoring the effects of membrane rigidity and viscosity | |
Aspiration-induced deformation | Neutrophils [24] | Negative pressure | Young’s modulus, cortical tension | Straightforward method; Well-established mathematical model | Leaking problem; Rectangle-like cross-section of microfluidic channels; Time-consuming process; Requiring high-vacuum pressure | |
Optical stretcher | MCF7 [106]; MCF-7, MCF-10, MDA-MB-231 [111]; Red blood cells [99]; Melanoma cells [112] |
Optically-induced surface forces | Deformation index, cell elasticity | No physical contact; Relatively high-throughput measurements | Alignment problem; Optical heating; Thermal damage |
|
Electrical-induced deformation | MCF-10A, MCF-7 [113] | Electroporation-induced swelling | Deformation index, size of cells | Fast heat dissipation; Better resolution; Automation and parallelization of test with reduced amount of samples |
High energy consumption and high voltage | |
MEMS Techniques | Suspended microcantilever | Circulating tumor cells [114]; Fibroblast [101] | External actuator | Frequency of cantilever, passage time, transit time | All-inclusive systems; Parallel analysis; Better quality factor; Automation | Fabrication is expensive; Non-transparent channels; High stiffness of silicon; calibration process |
MEMS resonator | MCF7 [115] | External actuator | Frequency of cantilever | High throughput | Expensive fabrication; Requiring external electrical system; Only for adherent cells |