Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 1;10(17):3968. doi: 10.3390/jcm10173968

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

Participants (E/C) Eccentric Exercise Group Comparison Group Outcome Measures
Eccentric exercise + adjuvant treatment vs. adjuvant treatment
Anitha and Prachi (2018) [36] N = 30/30
Age (y), NR/NR
Sex (M/F), NR/NR
Duration (mo), NR/NR
Eccentric exercise + Standardized conventional therapy
Device: Rubber bar
3 sets of 15 repetitions
6 session/week
Duration, 2 weeks
Standardized conventional therapy (pulsed ultrasonic therapy) Pain: Numerical pain rating scale (0–10)
Grip strength (maximum)
Croisier et al. (2007) [37] N = 46/46
Age (y), 40 (SD, 8)/38 (SD, 8)
Sex (M/F), 36/56
Duration (mo), 8 (SD, 4)/8 (SD, 3)
Isokinetic eccentric exercise + Non-strengthening rehabilitation
Device: Cybex Norrn dynamometer
2 sets of 10 repetitions for wrist extensors and forearm supinators
3 times/week
Duration, 9 weeks
Non-strengthening rehabilitation (e.g., ultrasound, analgesic TENS, ice, deep friction massage, and stretching) Pain: VAS score (0–10)
Eccentric muscle strength
Disability questionnaire
Martinez-Silvestrini et al.
(2005) [38]
N = 31/33
Age (y), 46.6 (SD, NR)/43.1 (SD, NR)
Sex (M/F), NR/NR
Duration (mo), NR/NR
Eccentric exercise + Self-applied ice massage and stretching of wrist extensors
Device: Elastic resistance band
3 sets of 10 repetitions
Daily
Duration, 6 weeks
Self-applied ice massage and stretching of wrist extensors Pain: VAS score (0–100)
Grip strength (pain-free)
DASH
PRFEQ
SF-36
Soderberg et al.
(2012) [40]
N = 20/22
Age (y), 48 (SD, 12.4)/50 (SD, 10.8)
Sex (M/F), 24/18
Duration (mo), NR/NR
Eccentric exercise + Forearm band and warm-up exercise
Device: Bucket
2→3 sets of 8–12 repetitions
Daily → Twice a day
Duration, 6 weeks
Forearm band and warm-up exercise for wrist extensors (flexion, extension, abduction, adduction and circumduction for 1 min twice a day) Pain: VAS score (0–100)
Grip strength (pain-free)
Eccentric exercise vs. Other exercises (concentric or isotonic)
Martinez-Silvestrini et al.
(2005) [38]
N = 31/30
Age (y), 46.6 (SD, NR)/47.0 (SD, NR)
Sex (M/F), NR/NR
Duration (mo), NR/NR
Eccentric exercise + Self-applied ice massage and stretching of wrist extensors
Device: Elastic resistance band
3 sets of 10 repetitions
Daily
Duration, 6 weeks
Concentric exercise + Self-applied ice massage and stretching of wrist extensors
Same protocol with eccentric exercise
Pain: VAS score (0–100)
Grip strength (pain-free)
DASH
PRFEQ
SF-36 results
Peterson et al. (2014) [39] N = 60/60
Age (y), 48.8 (SD, 6.7)/47.0 (SD, 9.4)
Sex (M/F), 63/57
Duration (mo), NR/NR
Eccentric exercise
Device: Dumbbell (using a specified amount of water in a plastic container)
3 sets of 15 repetitions
DailyDuration, 3 months
Concentric exercise
Same protocol with eccentric exercise
Pain: VAS score (0–100)
Forearm extensor muscles strength
DASH
Gothenburg Quality of Life instrument questionnaire
Tyler et al. (2010) [41] N = 11/10
Age (y), 47 (SD, 2)/51 (SD, 4)
Sex (M/F), 10/11
Duration (wk), 6 (SD, 2)/8 (SD, 3)
Eccentric exercise + Wrist extensor stretching, ultrasound, cross-friction massage, heat, and ice
Device: Rubber bar
3 sets of 15 repetitions
Daily
Duration, 7 weeks
Isotonic exercise + Wrist extensor stretching, ultrasound, cross-friction massage, heat, and ice Pain: VAS score (0–10)
DASH

E, experimental; C, comparison; M, male; F, female; SD, standard deviation; NR, not reported; VAS, visual analog scale; DASH, disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand; PRFEQ, patient-rated forearm evaluation questionnaire SF-36, short form-36.