Appendix 3. Benefits and drawbacks of the principal personality assessment methods utilised in studies of non-human primates, synthesised across all studies.
| Method | Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|
| Behavioural Coding | - Produces data which is comparable between subjects - Measurements are objective - Does not require experience with individual animals |
- Time-consuming; can take hours to assess each individual - May not account for variability due to confounding variables - Based on observable behaviours in one context |
| Context Tests | - High level of control limits the impact of confounders - Easy to conduct; the test can be standardised across institutions |
- Only measures a small selection of traits (e.g. fearfulness, reactivity) - Not always clear how responses should be measured and interpreted - Based on a few specific behaviours |
| Trait Rating | - Quick, straightforward to complete - Accounts for variability in behaviour across contexts |
- Differences in familiarity with subjects - Measurements depend on subjective judgement - Requires validation to confirm surveyed traits correlate with observable behaviours |