Table 1:
Author | CT/MRI | N (Train / Valid) | Extraction Tool | Specific Outcome Measured | Statistical Result | Clinical Model | RQS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dankerl 2013 | CT | 372 | CADx | Differentiation of benign vs. malignant lesion (nodule vs. HCC) | AUC 0.75 for textural features AUC 0.91 for texture + semantic |
No | 5 |
Song 2019 | CT | 84 | Omni-Kinetic | Differentiation of benign vs. malignant lesion (HCC vs. HH vs. FNH vs. HA) | AUC 0.927 for textural features | No | 9 |
Stocker 2018 | MRI | 108 | Matlab | Differentiation of benign vs. malignant lesion | AUC 0.92 arterial phase | No | 7 |
Li 2017 | MRI | T: 112 V:50 |
Internal | Differentiation of HH from HCC | AUC 0.73 for GLCM Energy-mean | No | 10 |
Oyama 2019 | MRI | T: 50,50 V: 50 |
Matlab | Differentiation of HH from HCC | AUC 0.95 textural features | No | 9 |
Wu 2019 | MRI | 369 | Internal | Differentiation of HH from HCC | AUC 0.89 textural features | No | 8 |
Mokrane 2019 | CT | T: 142 V: 36 |
Internal | Categorize indeterminate nodule as high-risk or low-risk for HCC | AUC 0.74 for training cohort AUC 0.66 for validation cohort |
No | 10 |
Asayama 2016 | MRI | 84 | Internal | Comparison of individual textural features of non-cancerous parenchyma between those with and without HCC | p = 0.0006 for kurtosis p = 0.0152 for skewness |
No | 6 |
Rosenkrantz 2015 | MRI | 20 | Internal | Progression of hypovascular nodule to likely HCC on subsequent MRI | AUC 0.68 for skewness | No | 7 |
CT: computed tomography; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; AUC: area under the curve; HCC: hepatocellular carcinoma; HH: hepatic hemangioma; FNH: focal nodular hyperplasia; HA: hepatic adenoma