TABLE 1.
First author, year (reference number) | Study aims | Category | Intervention type | Nutrition topic | Data collection | Theoretical perspective |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Shelton RC, 2018 (94) | To examine and discuss conceptual and methodological issues in studying sustainability | Systems framing or language | Scope of Implementation | Intervention methods | Review | Dynamic sustainability framework |
Stave KA, 2015 (95) | To explain and demonstrate the system dynamics approach for examining food systems closely | Systems modeling (SDM) | Planning and organizing interventions | Agriculture policy, nutrition education, communication, and behavior | Modeling | Whole systems approach |
Brownson RC, 2018 (90) | To aid practitioners in building organizational-level capacity and assist researchers in conducting participatory research | Systems framing or language | Planning and organizing interventions | Methods to translate health information | Review | n/a |
Erasmus E, 2016 (63) | To investigate the scope of health and systems education among partners in the organization | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Food and health policy and systems | Cross-sectional | Social science theory |
Yamey G, 2012 (75) | To understand how to scale up health tools in low- to middle-income countries | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Health and food access | Qualitative Study | Diffusion of innovation |
Glegg SMN, 2019 (104) | To comprehensively map ways social network analysis are used in D&I | Systems modeling (SNA) | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Review | Whole systems approach |
Hammer JM, 2010 (76) | To improve the understanding about what reasonably to expect from large group interventions and how best to design them | Systems framing or language | Planning and organizing interventions | Health and nutrition education | Case study | Large group intervention theory |
Hitziger M, 2018 (97) | To improve the integration, governance, and coordination of implementing the One Health framework into practice | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of evidence-based practices (EBPs) | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Case study | One Health framework |
Zhang J, 2015 (91) | To build an agent-based model (ABM) of adolescent BMI and test the impact of social influence on combined overweight and obesity prevalence in the population | Systems modeling (ABM) | Planning and organizing interventions | BMI and obesity (nutrition-related) | Secondary data analysis | Social learning theory |
Kalim K, 2006 (86) | To describe systems thinking and illustrate its value in understanding the complexity of the diabetes national service framework | Systems modeling (SDM) | Planning and organizing interventions | Diabetes (nutrition-related disease) | Qualitative study | Systems thinking/systems theory |
Johnston LM, 2014 (59) | To explore the utility of the intervention-level framework | Systems framing or language | Planning and organizing interventions | Obesity policy | Review | Intervention-level framework |
Limbani F, 2019 (87) | To report the relationships, benefits, and challenges of process evaluation and complex interventions | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of an EBP | Hypertension (nutrition-related disease) | Case study | n/a |
Loyo HK, 2013 (77) | To align prevention efforts and maximize the effect of limited resources; to pioneer an innovative, systems-oriented approach to understand the dynamic dimensions of health protection policies | Systems modeling (SDM) | Planning and organizing interventions | Chronic disease/obesity policy (nutrition-related diseases) | Modeling | Whole systems approach |
Luig T, 2018 (57) | To explore implementation strategies using the interactive systems framework | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of an EBP | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Qualitative study | Interactive systems framework |
McGlashan J, 2016 (60) | To explore the application of network analysis to a community-developed causal-loop diagram (CLD) to advance understanding of the system drivers of obesity to plan for interventions | Systems modeling (SNA and SDM) | Planning and organizing interventions | Obesity (nutrition-related) | Modeling | Whole systems approach |
Widener MJ, 2013 (85) | To contribute to the current discourse on food deserts by presenting an agent-based model (ABM) that tests several spatial and aspatial interventions | Systems modeling (ABM) | Planning and organizing interventions | Health and food access | Modeling | Whole systems approach |
Nianogo RA, 2015 (88) | To review studies that used agent-based modeling (ABM) to study noncommunicable diseases as well as their risk factors in the context of public health | Systems science modeling (ABM) | Scope of implementation | Physical activity, diet, and diabetes (nutrition-related) | Review | Whole systems approach |
Buchthal OV, 2015 (103) | To identify communication and collaboration patterns among organizations involved in nutrition education within a diverse community | Systems modeling (SNA) | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Qualitative study | Whole systems approach |
Peterson H, 2018 (82) | To describe the importance of implementation science in health | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Review | Active implementation framework/interactive and synergistic framework |
Phillips W, 2006 (102) | To investigate multilevel networks and their impact on diffusion of innovation | Systems framing or language | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Case study | Systems of innovation |
Ramaswamy R, 2019 (98) | To develop an interdisciplinary practice-focused curriculum to teach Master of Public Health (MPH) students D&I | Systems framing or language | Curriculum development | Health and nutrition education | Review | Kirkpatrick model of learning evaluation |
Resnicow K, 2008 (92) | To provide a summary on chaos and complex adaptive systems (CAS) use in public health | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Intervention methods | Review | Chaos theory/complex adaptive systems |
Riley B, 2012 (78) | To integrate the lessons emerging from the literature with those of identified leaders in public health; to begin to identify useful principles to help public health better understand, assess, and shape the creation and use of EBP | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of EBP | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Review | Complex adaptive systems |
Hammond R, 2014 (96) | Re-examine a “follow the average” hypothesis to test whether the central insight from the original model holds and explore what new insights can be gained from a more detailed and complex model | Systems modeling (ABM) | Planning and organizing interventions | BMI (nutrition-related) | Modeling | Whole systems approach |
Smith T, 2016 (100) | To explore how communities translate evidence-based and promising health practices to rural contexts | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of EBP | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Case study | Interactive systems framework |
Theobald S, 2018 (89) | To provide key features in implementation research in low-/middle-income countries | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Case study | n/a |
Wang Y, 2015 (93) | To review current strategies used to model health-related issues by using systems science | Systems modeling (SDM) | Scope of implementation | Obesity and noncommunicable chronic diseases (nutrition-related) | Review | Systems thinking/systems theory |
Williams J, 2010 (83) | To explore how systems thinking might be used to guide state officials in developing a research-based evaluation plan for training programs and improve the understanding of the relationships and dependencies among units in an organization | Systems framing or language | Utilization/adoption of EBP | Health and nutrition education | Review | ABCD model approach inquiry: Phase A—Where do we want to be? Phase B—How will we know when we reached it? Phase C—Where are we now? Phase D—How do we get from here to our desired place? During the process, researchers continously consider the ongoing changes to the environment |
Woltering L, 2019 (84) | To demonstrate the problems underlining successful scalability of the sustainable development goals | Systems framing or language | Scope of implementation | Intervention methods | Review | n/a |
Li Y, 2015 (79) | To use ABM to help understand the potential impact of implementing lifestyle interventions | Systems modeling (ABM) | Utilization/adoption of EBP | Lifestyle intervention (smoking, overweight, diet, and physical activity) | Qualitative study | Whole systems approach |
Yousefi-Nooraie R, 2015 (80) | Tested whether engagement of staff in the intervention and their behavior were associated with being chosen as information source | Systems modeling (SNA) | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Longitudinal | Transactive memory principles/whole systems approach |
Yousefi-Nooraie R, 2012 (101) | A quantitative social network analysis designed to understand how the staff of a health department in Canada turned to peers to seek information regarding research evidence to inform practice-based decisions | Systems modeling (SNA) | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Cross-sectional | Whole systems approach/social capital theory/social influence theory |
Yousefi-Nooraie R, 2014 (81) | To model how managers and professional consultants seek information to inform evidence-informed decisions in a public health department in Canada | Systems modeling (SNA) | Dissemination | Methods to translate health knowledge/information | Cross-sectional | Whole systems approach |
Zenni E, 2006 (99) | To implement and evaluate the effectiveness of scenario-based learning in enhancing medical residents’ competencies of systems thinking to address patients | Systems framing or language | Evaluation | Health and nutrition education | Case study | Systems thinking/systems theory/adult learning theory |
ABM, agent-based modeling; CAS, complex adaptive system; CLD, causal-loop diagram; D&I, dissemination and implementation; EBP, evidence-based practice; n/a, not available; SDM, systems dynamic modeling; SNA, systems network analysis.