Mitochondrial Dysfunction: A Common Denominator in Neurodevelopmental Disorders?

Abstract

Mitochondria, the organelle classically seen as the powerhouse of the cell, are increasingly associated with a wide variety of neurodevelopmental disorders. Although individually rare, a myriad of pediatric neurogenetic disorders have been identified in the last few years thanks to advances in clinical genetic sequencing and data analysis. As this exponential growth continues, mitochondrial dysfunction is increasingly implicated in childhood neurodevelopmental disorders, with clinical presentations ranging from syndromic autism, intellectual disability and epileptic encephalopathies to childhood onset neurodegeneration. Here we review recent evidence demonstrating mitochondrial involvement in neurodevelopmental disorders, identify emerging mechanistic trends and reconsider the long-standing question of the role of mitochondria in light of new evidence: causation versus mere association?

INTRODUCTION

Although mitochondria are well known as the mainstay of energy production via oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS), they also play a role in a plethora of crucial cellular functions. These include regulation of calcium homeostasis, initiation of apoptosis, thermoregulation, maintaining red-ox balance and generating bioactive metabolites that mediate epigenetic regulation by means of methylation, acetylation or phosphorylation[1,2]. More recently, signaling from the mitochondria to the nucleus has been explored in cancer and inflammatory disorders[3,4]

Genetic variants in either nuclear DNA or mitochondrial DNA can clinically present with primary mitochondrial disorders [5]. Usually these molecular defects affect proteins known to be critical for mitochondrial function, such as those comprising the electron transport chain, involved in mitochondrial import/transport/solute exchange, or mtDNA translation and maintenance. Mitochondrial disease can be clinically heterogeneous, presenting with a broad range of systemic involvement, variable age of onset and severity[6]. Most often in the pediatric realm we consider mitochondrial disorders in children with progressive neurologic decline in the setting of systemic manifestations such as sensorineural hearing loss, failure to thrive, hepatopathy or cardiomyopathy. Nevertheless, as our understanding of the genetic underpinnings of many neurodevelopmental symptoms continues to grow, genes encoding proteins with mitochondrial localization or function are increasingly associated with clinical manifestations such as epileptic encephalopathy, intellectual disability or autism spectrum disorders. On the other hand, recent data is connecting to mitochondria well-known genes associated with intellectual disability, that were not previously suspected to be implicated or remotely linked to mitochondrial function. This review will address the emerging role of mitochondrial dysfunction in neurodevelopmental disorders from the most common causes of syndromic autism to recently identified ultra-rare pediatric neurodegenerative disorders. As emerging data accumulates linking mitochondrial dysfunction to neurodevelopmental disorders, a provoking question arises: if all roads lead to Rome, can the mitochondria relay signals that impact the cell’s ultimate fate? From cancer to inflammation, a recent explosion in the literature points to mitochondrial retrograde signaling as a key regulator of cell signaling in health and disease [7–9],[10]. Neurologic disorders are likely no exception [11] as we will address in the context of pediatric neurodevelopmental disorders..

New twist to an old story: Mitochondrial dysfunction in the “classic” syndromic autismdisorders

Fragile X

Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is one of the most common causes of syndromic intellectual disability and autism, but only recently the idea that mitochondrial dysfunction may have a significant role in the pathogenesis of this disorder has been entertained. Early hypothesis (reviewed in [12]) pointed to a role of the FMPR protein as an RNA binding protein regulating the expression of mitochondrial and cytosolic Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD1), suggesting increased mitochondrial oxidative stress could lead to secondary mitochondrial dysfunction. Fast forward 10–15 years and the total number of publications for “Fragile X and mitochondria” has increased 10-fold. Using drosophila models, it has been shown that alterations in FMRP can alter axonal transport of mitochondria [13], as well as mitochondrial morphology and electron transport system capacity [14]. The concept of a pathological mitochondrial proton leak as a unifying hypothesis in FXS is recently emerging. In mouse neuronal models, FMRP was shown to regulate closure of the ATP-synthase c-subunit leak. In isolated forebrain mitochondria derived from Fmr1 mice, inefficient respiration and an abnormal “proton leak” was described, which leads to ineffective oxidative phosphorylation [15]. Further studies with primary mouse neurons derived from Fmr1^-/y mice suggest that mutant FMR protein is unable to close the developmental c-subunit leak, impairing oxidative phosphorylation and disrupting stimulus-dependent synaptic maturation [16]. Recent studies also suggest that Fmr1 knockout mouse astrocytes also exhibit mitochondrial dysfunction, including reduced membrane potential and mtDNA content. Taken together, current evidence suggest that bioenergetics defects in Fragile X may involve both neurons and astrocytes [16,17]. Therefore, not only has mitochondrial dysfunction emerged as a key to unravel the pathophysiology of Fragile X syndrome, but these recent studies open the possibility for new druggable therapeutic targets. Repletion mitochondrial coenzyme Q levels was able to block the pathological proton leak in isolated Fmr1 knock out mice forebrain mitochondria and rescue some autistic phenotypes in vivo[15]. The same group also reported a different approach with Fmr1^-/y mice treated with the ATP synthase modulator, dexpramipexole showed amelioration in some behavioral measures of autistic behaviors [16].

Angelman Syndrome

Angelman syndrome is another well-known and common autism and intellectual disability syndrome, associated with chromosomal deletions of the maternal chromosome 15 including the UBE3A gene. Early studies examining mitochondrial function in hippocampal neurons from a UBE3A mouse model found abnormal mitochondrial morphology and oxidative phosphorylation defects[18]. Mitochondrially derived oxidative stress, particularly superoxide levels, were found to be elevated in UBE3A hippocampal neurons, and mitochondrial-targeted antioxidants could rescue behavioral impairments in mice [19,20]. More recent transcriptome data also suggest that Ube3a deletion in mouse cellular models result in differential gene expression profiles of mitochondrial associated pathways [21].

Tuberous sclerosis complex

Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is caused by pathogenic variants in the genes TSC1 and TSC2, which are known to modulate the mTORC (mechanistic target of rapamycin complex) Given the myriad of known bidirectional interactions between mTORC signaling and mitochondria[22–24], it is perhaps unsurprising that mitochondrial alterations have been found in TSC disease models Mitochondrial quality control via autophagic degradation of dysfunctional mitochondria (mitophagy) is also long known to be linked to mTORC1 (mTOR complex 1) signaling[25]. In primary hippocampal Tsc2-deficient neurons, mitochondria were progressively accumulated in cell bodies but depleted in axons. Mitochondria from tsc2-deficient neurons had impaired respiratory chain function and reduced membrane potential. Upon conditions that should stimulate mitophagy (inhibiting the electron transport chain with Antimycin A), tsc2-deficient neurons had a blunted mitophagy response. Alterations in autophagy and mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (mitoROS) were also observed in a human iPSC derived Purkinje cell model of TSC[26]. Interestingly, gene expression data on this study also revealed down regulation of several components of the FMRP (Fragile X Mental Retardation) protein targets in TSC2-deficient human Purkinje Cells. Overall, these studies have raised the potential of targeting mitochondrial quality control as a therapeutic target for tuberous sclerosis, as enhancing mitochondrial quality control via mTOR-independent autophagy may rescue the mitochondrial phenotype [27] Furthermore, the same group has speculated whether induction of autophagy to improve mitochondrial quality control could be a therapeutic target for other MTORopathies in addition to TSC [28].

Rett Syndrome Spectrum Disorders

Classic Rett syndrome is the result of mutations in the X-linked gene MECP2, but other phenotypically overlapping neurodevelopmental disorders are caused by variants in FOXG1 and CDKL5, for instance. Patients with these disorders often have autistic behaviors, intellectual disability as well as epilepsy, all of variable severity. In MECP2 mouse models of Rett’s, \ several altered mitochondrial parameters have been identified. Changes in mitochondrial morphology have been reported in hippocampal neurons [29]. Isolated mitochondria from hippocampi of Mecp2-knock out mice showed increased oxygen consumption and generated higher ROS levels[30]. Multiple reports converged on decreased ATP levels and increased oxidative stress [31,32], which has been found across brain regions in neurons [33] as well as astrocytes [34], prompting the testing of free radical scavengers in animal models [35]. Although significant evidence for a role of disrupted redox homeostasis in Rett syndrome has been building (for dedicated reviews refer to [36,37], the larger question remains of whether mitochondrial dysfunction constitutes cause or effect in the pathogenesis of neurodevelopmental disorders in the Rett Spectrum. Nevertheless, convergence of current evidence towards a model of altered redox homeostasis may be worth exploring as it may open therapeutic avenues in the future.

MECP2 is thought to be a transcription factor, and there’s some evidence that it regulates a gene encoding a protein essential for mitochondrial ADP/ATP exchange, the adenine nucleotide translocator (SLC25A4 or ANT1) [38]. ANT1 mRNA levels were found to be increased in human and mouse cell lines with MECP2 deficiency, and in Rett’s patient’s fibroblasts. To understand the potential consequences of ANT1 upregulation in cellular function, the physiological roles of ANT1 must be considered. In addition to ADP/ATP exchange, recent studies suggest additional intriguing physiological roles for this protein, including regulating mitophagy [39] and mitochondrial uncoupling via proton transport [40]. Perhaps due to is multiple roles, mutations in SLC25A4/ANT1 are clinically fascinating because of their heterogenous mode of inheritance and divergent phenotypes. Dominant variants present with severe neonatal encephalopathy while recessive loss of function variants lead to progressive cardiomyopathy mostly in adults. In addition to variable age of onset and target organ affected, even with dominant variants the neurologic involvement ranges from fatal encephalopathy [41] to isolated gross motor delay [42]. Therefore, the effects of ANT1 dysregulation in the context of Rett’s is unclear and should be further examined. In particular, it may be relevant to recent observations suggesting defective mitophagy in Rett syndrome. Impaired autophagosome biogenesis and retention of mitochondria in peripheral RBCs were observed [43]. Additional recent studies from fibroblasts proteomic profiling have identified differential expression of mediators of mitochondrial dynamics and mitophagy, and apparent failure of induction of mitophagy upon FCCP stimulation [44]

In addition to MECP2 associated Rett syndrome, mitochondrial dysfunction has also been identified in other genetic disorders within the same phenotypic spectrum. Although less data is available, both CDKL5 and FOXG1 have been linked to mitochondrial dysfunction. In cdkl5-null mice in vivo proton NMR spectroscopy was used to characterize metabolic brain activity. Their data suggested mitochondrial dysfunction, based on reduced ATP levels and reduction of complex IV expression [45]. This study is consistent with reduced ATP brain levels assayed ex-vivo with traditional biochemical assays using cdkl5-null mice, where mitochondrial respiratory chain defects were identified in complex III, IV and V [46]. Regarding FOXG1, recent studies suggest a fraction of the protein localizes to the mitochondrial matrix, and its localization is membrane potential dependent. [47]. Overexpression of the full length as well as the mitochondrial-localized portion reduced mitochondrial respiratory function in a mouse neuronal cell model.

Mitochondrial disorders presenting as epileptic encephalopathies

As our understanding of human genetic disorders continue to expand, and novel disease genes are identified, our understanding of the strong genetic basis of epileptic encephalopathies (EE) continues to grow. Most of the genes initially linked with epileptic encephalopathy, such as SCN1A and KCNQ2, encode for ion channels expressed in the brain. We are now well past the “channelopathy era” [48] and are increasingly finding genes that are associated with medication refractory epilepsy that are not obviously linked to neuronal excitability. In fact, is not uncommon to find variants in novel disease genes that have little to no known previous data to inform its physiologic function. Such is the case for multiple genes that encode proteins localized to the mitochondria but have unclear functions or that are found to alter mitochondrial homeostasis by unknown mechanisms.

Given that mitochondrial disorders are traditionally thought to be clinically distinct from epileptic encephalopathies, it is particularly interesting to note an increasing number of genes encoding mitochondrial proteins and carriers causing epileptic encephalopathies. Mutations in mitochondrial transport machinery proteins such as TIMM50 [49], and proteins implicated in mitochondrial fission/fusion control such DNM1L [50] have been found in patients clinically presenting with epileptic encephalopathy. In fact, it is not uncommon that patients with a previous clinical diagnosis of mitochondrial disease are found on whole exome sequencing to carry variants in genes associated with epileptic encephalopathy, but that may have yet unclear physiologic function. [51]. Such is the case of SPATA5, initially identified as causative of microcephaly, intractable generalized epilepsy and intellectual disability [52]. Although little is known of the function of the protein it encodes, previous studies had suggested a mitochondrial localization sequence [53]. Cortical rat neurons deficient in SPATA5 (by shRNA knockdown) showed abnormal mitochondrial dynamics and decreased ATP levels, suggesting that indeed there may be a yet to be identified mitochondrial function for this protein[51].

Defects affecting mitochondrial metabolite exchange pathways are also critical for neurodevelopment. Biallelic variants in mitochondrial solute carriers such as the mitochondria glutamate carrier (SLC25A22), can present with epileptic encephalopathy of variable severity, from the spectrum of Ohtahara syndrome (epileptic encephalopathy with burst suppression) [54] to migrating partial seizures of infancy or childhood onset absence seizures [55,56]. Mechanistically, it is worth nothing that reduced levels of glutathione have been reported both in SLC25A22 as well as with loss of function of SLC25A10. SLC25A10 transports dicarboxylates and phosphate across the inner mitochondrial membrane and is linked to epileptic encephalopathy with complex I deficiency [57]. Reduced glutathione (GSH) is a key free radical scavenging compound in the nervous system and can attenuate the effects of oxidative stress.

Interestingly, previous data measuring in vivo glutathione brain levels in adult patients with focal epilepsy via (1)-H MRS, suggested that patients with epilepsy have reduced glutathione levels, regardless of seizure burden, relative to healthy controls [58]. As our imaging capabilities evolve and new in vivo techniques allow for monitoring of glutathione[59] and other oxidative stress markers[60], we are poised to further probe the role of mitochondrial oxidative stress and its potential as a therapeutic target in a wide range of neurodevelopmental disorders. In particular, it deserves further exploration the question of whether the beneficial effects from the ketogenic diet in the management of seizures could be at least in part due to elevated glutathione levels in vivo. Although these has been reported in animal studies earlier, the first human studies showing that the ketogenic diet can elevate glutathione levels in children with epilepsy was recently reported with in vivo imaging techniques [61]

Mitochondrial Dysfunction: A Unifying Element in Genetically Heterogenous Pediatric Neurodegenerative Disorders?

As the number of ultra-rare neurogenetic syndromes that manifest with pediatric onset neurodegeneration expands, so does the evidence that many of these disorders, from the novel to the well-known, share an element of mitochondrial dysfunction. From aberrant mitophagy and mitochondrial respiratory defects in a classic lysosomal disorder, Neimman Pick disease[62–64], to the recent elegant work showing that mechanistically several of the NBIA (neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation) disorders converge on the mitochondrial acyl carrier protein[65], evolving mechanistic insights implicate mitochondria. In terms of more recently discovered neurogenetic disorders, often clinically patients were clinically suspected to have mitochondrial disorders, and variants are found in genes of unclear function but no previous data to support a mitochondrial connection. Nevertheless, integrating this clinical insight may reveal that indeed, despite no yet clear connection to mitochondria, functional studies may reveal mitochondrial dysfunction. This is the case for instance, for CTBP1 neurodevelopmental disorders, which can present with developmental delay (and sometimes regression), ataxia and spasticity [66]. Pathogenic variants were found to alter transcriptional regulation of pathways linked to apoptosis [67] in cellular models. Interestingly, a patient with known complex I and complex IV deficiency presumed to have a mitochondrial disorder, was instead found to have the same recurrent de novo pathogenic variant in CTBP1 [68]. Similarly, patients diagnosed with the recently described TBCK Encephaloneuronopathy syndrome [69,70] also exhibit what appears to be secondary mitochondrial dysfunction[71], perhaps due to lysosomal dysfunction compromising mitochondrial quality control [72]

Although we often think of mitochondrial disorders as a separate entity clinically, it is also worth noting that the majority of patients with primary mitochondrial disorders also exhibit neurodevelopmental symptoms such as delayed milestones, seizures and intellectual disability. Many of them go on to develop frank neurodegenerative features, such as see in the mitochondrial depletion syndrome associated with variants in POLG [73], or the progressive ataxia, neuropathy and dementia seen in Kearns Sayre Syndrome.

The question then becomes, are mitochondria just another subcellular victim of divergent pathways leading to neurodegeneration or are they a common denominator, a crucial stepping stone in the path that culminates in neurodegeneration?

The implicated pathways to date vary but all lead to disrupting mitochondrial homeostasis, from altering respiratory chain function to mitochondrial morphology, dynamics, transport and quality control (mitophagy for instance). One of the challenges in establishing strong common underlying mechanisms is the lack of systematic mitochondrial characterization across different neurodevelopmental disorders. Some studies may examine mitophagy while others look at respiratory capacity while others may report mitochondrial network. This makes it challenging to address the causality question, and the field may benefit for more comprehensive and consistent bioenergetic characterization across various disorders in order to examine if common mechanisms exist. As we continue to expand our understanding of the molecular basis of a growing number of neurodevelopmental disorders, perhaps deciphering the critical role of maintaining mitochondrial homeostasis will illuminate the pathways critical in disease pathogenesis but open new venues for therapeutic target development.

Table 1:

Neurodevelopmental Disorders with Evidence of Mitochondrial Dysfunction

Neurodevelopmental Disorder/Phenotype	Genetic etiology	Mitochondrial Data	References
Fragile X Syndrome	FMR1	Impaired OXPHOS, abnormal proton leak, abnormal mito morphology and axonal transport	[13–17]
Angelman Syndrome	15q11.2-q13 deletion/UPD, UBE3A	Increased mitoROS, altered hippocampal CA1 mito morphology and reduced complex III activity	[18–21]
Tuberous Sclerosis	TSC1, TSC2	Impaired mitophagy, impaired respiration and membrane potential	[27,28]
Rett Spectrum Disorders	MECP2, CDKL5, FOXG1	Increased mitoROS, hippocampal morphological changes, impaired mitophagy	[29,33–38,43–47]
Early infantile epileptic Encephalopathy 31 (EIEE31)	DNM1L	Impaired mitochondrial fission	[50]
Epilepsy, hearing loss and ID	SPATA5	abnormal mitochondrial dynamics and decreased ATP levels	[51]
Hypotonia, ataxia and Developmental delay	CTBP1	Reduced respiratory chain activities (complex I and Complex IV)	[68]
TBCK encephaloneuronopathy	TBCK	COX negative fibers, decrease respiration, impaired mitophagy	[71,72]
Noteworthy but not covered in this review
Phelan Mcdermid Syndrome	22q13deletion SHANK3	SHANK3 interactome data suggests interaction with mitochondrial proteins, low complex I and IV in PMS patients	[74,75]
Other 15q11 CNVs/Prader Willi Syndrome	15q11.2–13		[76,77]
Down Syndrome	Trisomy 21	Reduced respiration, decreased membrane potential, lower ATP levels, see 80 for review	[78–82]
DiGeorge/22q11.2 deletion	22q11.2 del	Altered mito interactome, Impaired mito Calcium buffering, reduced OXPHOS (complex I and IV), reduced ATP levels	[83–85]