Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 16;16(9):e0257236. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0257236

Table 1. Effects of different seed priming agents on germination characteristics under low temperature and drought conditions.

Cultivar Priming Stress GP (%) GR (%) GT (days) GI SVI
ZY15 Control T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.000a 4.09±0.031h 89.73±3.418c 1.81±0.093d
T15W15 79.04±1.701d 79.04±1.701c 4.64±0.025de 43.02±0.463f 0.62±0.095hi
H2O T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.02±0.006ij 97.33±0.764ab 2.29±0.161c
T15W15 82.05±2.123cd 82.05±2.123c 4.60±0.056e 50.43±1.623e 0.77±0.100gh
SA T25W0 82.05±2.123cd 90.00±0.001a 4.09±0.012h 90.41±1.048c 2.22±0.201c
T15W15 80.64±1.065d 86.17±3.314b 4.51±0.044f 44.57±1.242f 0.87±0.081g
GA T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.02±0.006ij 96.84±1.242b 2.76±0.189b
T15W15 86.17±3.314b 86.17±3.314b 4.65±0.023de 50.34±0.367e 0.92±0.060g
SNP T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.01±0.006j 98.50±1.041ab 2.37±0.324c
T15W15 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.53±0.010f 49.98±1.070e 0.97±0.081g
CaCl2 T25W0 88.09±3.314ab 90.00±0.001a 4.01±0.015j 98.68±1.481ab 3.13±0.123a
T15W15 87.29±4.694ab 87.29±4.694ab 4.52±0.029f 48.51±2.162e 0.83±0.071gh
ABA T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.01±0.001j 98.94±0.098ab 2.31±0.052c
T15W15 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.53±0.035f 49.45±0.376e 0.95±0.156g
HY49 Control T25W0 86.17±3.314b 86.17±3.314b 4.08±0.036h 90.33±3.884c 1.48±0.055f
T15W15 48.25±0.667h 48.83±0.334g 4.60±0.056e 25.83±1.126j 0.33±0.046k
H2O T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.02±0.006ij 97.61±0.348ab 1.58±0.096ef
T15W15 58.54±3.025g 58.74±2.861f 4.79±0.055b 29.20±2.502i 0.38±0.017jk
SA T25W0 88.09±3.314ab 88.09±3.314ab 4.07±0.015hi 92.48±2.019c 1.53±0.103ef
T15W15 70.94±0.540ef 73.98±1.677d 4.64±0.062de 42.17±2.517fg 0.61±0.091hij
GA T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.00±0.001j 100.00±0.001a 1.86±0.087d
T15W15 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.38±0.044g 60.83±4.072d 0.94±0.080g
SNP T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.001a 4.01±0.010j 98.83±0.764ab 1.67±0.097def
T15W15 69.53±2.609f 69.53±2.607e 4.66±0.045cd 39.86±2.333gh 0.51±0.035ijk
CaCl2 T25W0 85.38±4.178bc 86.17±3.314b 4.01±0.010j 98.22±1.345ab 1.55±0.453ef
T15W15 68.69±2.961f 71.58±0.956de 4.71±0.04cd 38.07±1.458h 0.46±0.006ijk
ABA T25W0 90.00±0.001a 90.00±0.000a 4.01±0.001j 98.94±0.098ab 1.75±0.142def
T15W15 73.65±2.129e 73.65±2.129d 5.23±0.031a 27.26±0.675ij 0.37±0.017k

Averages of germination potential (GP), germination rate (GR), germination time (GT), germination index (GI), and seed vigor index (SVI) are given. Treatments that do not have the same letters are significantly different (p < 0.05) as determined by Duncan’s multiple range tests. Each point represents the mean of three replicates. The values presented are the mean ± standard deviation (SD). Significant differences among treatments were determined using a three-way analysis of variance (ANOVA).