Merits | Risks and research gaps | Proposed solutions | |
---|---|---|---|
Speed of response | Rapid response to emerging pandemic | Haste in funding, development and implementation may have jeopardised scientific and ethical rigour | Develop protocols for fast track procedures in emergency scenarios balancing rigour and urgency |
Number of trials and sample size | Impressive research scale‐up, many trials being launched | Most trials relatively small, limited statistical power to detect effects on clinically important outcomes (eg, mortality) | Consider evidence synthesis opportunities throughout trial conduct, facilitate collaboration and coordination to enable pooling of data and results |
Core outcomes and evidence synthesis | Core outcomes have been developed early in the pandemic to enable successful evidence synthesis | Data sharing/collaboration intentions are low | Encourage and create infrastructure for collaboration (eg, in prospective meta‐analyses) through funding bodies and trial registries |
Low proportion of trials collecting core outcomes (eg, only 53% assess mortality) | Establish a recognition system for collaboration and data sharing following FAIR principles | ||
Innovation | Range of innovative interventions (eg, vaccine solutions and digital health solutions) balanced with repurposing of existing treatments | Lack of innovation in trial design (eg, only two trials using adaptive designs) | Increase use of adaptive designs to respond to the rapidly changing evidence landscape |
Innovation in trial conduct (digital recruitment and delivery modes) | |||
Types of interventions and populations studied | Broad array of drug categories investigated | Extensive media coverage and public opinion may have misled research prioritisation (eg, too many hydroxychloroquine trials) | Improve research coordination and prioritisation through infrastructure (eg, funders, trial registries) to ensure a variety of priorities are met and to avoid duplication of effort |
Few non‐pharmaceutical trials and no trials on public health communication or community transmission prevention | |||
Few trials included populations at high risk of poor outcomes from COVID‐19 such as those with comorbidities |
FAIR = findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable.