Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 17;109:108035. doi: 10.1016/j.jmgm.2021.108035

Table 3.

The average binding free energies calculated by MMGBSA method for the wild-type RBD and the E484K mutant, respectively, complexed with various neutralizing antibodies and nanobodies based on the five MD simulation trajectories for each systema.

Neutralizing antibodies RBD ΔEvdw ΔEele ΔGpolar ΔGnonpolar ΔEvdw+ΔGnonpolar ΔEele+ΔGpolar ΔGbind Standard deviation
BD23 WTb −71.28 −122.61 149.54 −9.89 −81.17 26.93 −54.24 7.54
MTc −75.06 44.91 7.04 −9.85 −84.91 51.95 −32.96 7.71
Nanobody H11-D4 WT −62.60 −2.90 26.09 −8.36 −70.96 23.19 −47.77 4.68
MT −64.60 271.64 −236.30 −7.89 −72.49 35.34 −37.15 4.63
BD368-2 WT −74.68 −92.73 128.59 −9.59 −84.27 35.86 −48.41 5.76
MT −70.23 3.98 35.93 −9.21 −79.44 39.91 −39.53 6.14
Nanobody Nb20 WT −82.75 −237.52 268.30 −12.09 −94.84 30.78 −64.06 6.09
MT −75.69 −47.65 85.08 −10.53 −86.22 37.43 −48.79 7.44
Nanobody MR17-K99Y WT −102.33 −299.26 344.51 −13.63 −115.96 45.25 −70.71 7.04
MT −106.09 −226.00 274.81 −13.94 −120.03 48.81 −71.22 7.11
S2M11 WT −71.59 −74.16 97.06 −9.33 −80.92 22.90 −58.02 5.05
MT −72.79 31.18 8.59 −8.50 −81.29 39.77 −41.52 5.40
a

The unit of the values is kcal/mol.

b

WT represents wild-type RBD.

c

MT represents the mutated RBD.