Table 1.
Overview of included papers.
Author Year | Design | Participants, N and characteristics | Criteria included | Equivalents described |
---|---|---|---|---|
Bakken et al. 2007 | Qualitative Case reports |
N = 8, ASD, Moderate/severe ID, SCZ/psychosis, severely impaired functioning | Disorganized behaviour/speech, Negative symptoms Suggested hallucinations |
Disorganization NS Hallucinations |
Bakken et al. 2008 | Quantitative Staff communication |
N = 4 Patients Moderate/severe ID, SCZ/psychosis, severely impaired functioning |
Disorganized behaviour Disorganized speech |
Disorganized behaviour/speech |
Bakken et al. 2009 | Single-case design. Validation of behavioural disorganization | N = 84 episodes of dyadic patient – staff interaction | Disorganised behaviour Disorganised speech |
Disorganized behaviour/speech |
Bakken 2014 | Case series. Differing SCZ from ASD | N = 12, Mild ID / Borderline IQ. Tentative ASD and / or SCZ at admission | Delusions Hallucinations Disorganized speech/behaviour Negative symptoms Globally impaired function |
Disorganizes speech Disorganized behaviour Negative symptoms |
Engebretsen et al. 2019 | Clinical study. 22q11.2 DS and psychosis. |
N = 1 Patient with mild ID, 22q11.2 DS and psychosis |
Hallucinations Disorganized speech Disorganized behaviour Negative symptoms |
Disorganized speech Disorganized behaviour Negative symptoms |
Hurley 2003 | Clinical study; psychosis in adults with ID in two groups. | N = 106 adults with ID. One group with ‘ID only’. One group with ID + Down Syndrome. | Delusions Hallucinations |
Disorganized speech? Hallucinations |
Kildahl et al. 2017 | Clinical study. Assessment of psychosis in ID / ASD |
N = 1 Patient with mild ID, ASD and severely impaired global functioning |
Disorganized speech Disorganized behaviour Negative symptoms |
Disorganized speech Disorganized behaviour Negative symptoms |
Rumsey et al. 1986 | Group comparisons | N = 56 Four groups of adults; one group ASD, one group SCZ inpatients, one group mania inpatients, one group neurotypicals (no mental problem) | Formal thought disorder (disorganized speech) | Disorganized speech |
The first column refers to first author and year published. *NS = negative symptoms.