Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 28;2013(12):CD006577. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006577.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Aragon 2002 Not a randomized controlled trial
Argstatter 2006 This study was included in the original review but is now excluded because not all participants had confirmed CHD
Bally 2003 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Bonny 1983 Not a randomized controlled trial. Pretest‐posttest single group design
Byers 1997 Not a randomized controlled trial
Chang 2011 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Claire 1986 Not a randomized controlled trial
Diamandi 2008 No standard care control group. Study compared music therapy with music listening
Dritsas 2006 Insufficient data available
Escher 1996 Insufficient data available
Garcia 2003 Not a randomized controlled trial
Ghetti 2011 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Goertz 2011 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Guzzetta 1989 This study was included in the original review but is now excluded because not all participants had confirmed CHD
Hamel 2001 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Harris 1971 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Hatem 2006 Interquartile ranges are reported instead of standard deviations. This suggests that the outcome distribution was severely skewed.
Ibhler 2011 Insufficient data available
Jiang 2008 The study intervention was a combination of relaxation training and music listening
MacNay 1995 Not a randomized controlled trial
Mandel 2007b Not a randomized controlled trial
Micci 1984 Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Moradipanah 2009 Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Nilsson 2009b Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Nilsson 2012 Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Okada 2009 Not a randomized controlled trial
Reisinger 1995 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Richardson 2004 No standard care control group. Study compared music listening with music/imagery
Robichaud 1999 This study was included in the original review but is now excluded because not all participants had confirmed CHD
Schwartz 2002 No randomization used
Schwartz 2009 Group assignment was based on availability of space
Short 2011 Experimental group was not randomized and there was no control group
Slyfield 1992 Insufficient data
Taylor‐Piliae 2002 Not all participants had confirmed CHD
Thorgaard 2004 Unclear randomization methods. Poor data reporting
Twiss 2003 Lack of proper randomization method. In the thesis author explicitly states that only 4 CD players were available. If all CD players were in use, the next group of participants were placed in the control group
Vanderboom 2012 Participants received diagnostic cerebral angiography procedure
Watanabe 2011 Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Weeks 2011 Participants received diagnostic angiography procedure
Zimmerman 1988 This study was included in the original review but is now excluded because not all participants had confirmed CHD