Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 17;34(4):820–832. doi: 10.1007/s10278-021-00498-3

Table 2.

3D contour-focused segmentation. Number and percentage of stable features with good (0.75 ≤ ICC < 0.9) and excellent (ICC ≥ 0.9) interobserver reliability grouped according to feature class and image type. GLCM, gray-level cooccurrence matrix; GLDM, gray-level dependence matrix; GLRLM, gray-level run length matrix; GLSZM, gray-level size zone matrix; ICC, intraclass correlation coefficient; LoG, Laplacian of Gaussian

3D Feature class Image type Total features (n) ICC ≥ 0.75 (n) ICC ≥ 0.75 (%) ICC ≥ 0.90 (n) ICC ≥ 0.90 (%)
CT First order LoG 72 64 88.89 44 61.11
Original 18 14 77.78 9 50.00
Wavelet 144 114 79.17 93 64.58
GLCM LoG 88 86 97.73 65 73.86
Original 22 22 100.00 19 86.36
Wavelet 176 169 96.02 153 86.93
GLDM LoG 56 50 89.29 24 42.86
Original 14 13 92.86 8 57.14
Wavelet 112 98 87.50 71 63.39
GLRLM LoG 64 62 96.88 30 46.88
Original 16 14 87.50 9 56.25
Wavelet 128 112 87.50 86 67.19
GLSZM LoG 64 46 71.88 19 29.69
Original 16 11 68.75 2 12.50
Wavelet 128 93 72.66 67 52.34
Shape Original 14 12 85.71 7 50.00
Overall 1132 980 86.57 706 62.37
T1w First order LoG 72 67 93.06 43 59.72
Original 18 12 66.67 7 38.89
Wavelet 144 121 84.03 89 61.81
GLCM LoG 88 77 87.50 47 53.41
Original 22 16 72.73 10 45.45
Wavelet 176 151 85.80 125 71.02
GLDM LoG 56 42 75.00 24 42.86
Original 14 9 64.29 7 50.00
Wavelet 112 85 75.89 60 53.57
GLRLM LoG 64 50 78.13 31 48.44
Original 16 9 56.25 6 37.50
Wavelet 128 99 77.34 77 60.16
GLSZM LoG 64 47 73.44 21 32.81
Original 16 10 62.50 5 31.25
Wavelet 128 97 75.78 55 42.97
Shape Original 14 14 100.00 11 78.57
Overall 1132 906 80.04 618 54.59
T2w First order LoG 72 70 97.22 53 73.61
Original 18 17 94.44 11 61.11
Wavelet 144 126 87.50 94 65.28
GLCM LoG 88 81 92.05 69 78.41
Original 22 21 95.45 15 68.18
Wavelet 176 169 96.02 145 82.39
GLDM LoG 56 55 98.21 41 73.21
Original 14 14 100.00 9 64.29
Wavelet 112 106 94.64 73 65.18
GLRLM LoG 64 64 100.00 53 82.81
Original 16 16 100.00 11 68.75
Wavelet 128 122 95.31 92 71.88
GLSZM LoG 64 62 96.88 46 71.88
Original 16 16 100.00 11 68.75
Wavelet 128 122 95.31 70 54.69
Shape Original 14 14 100.00 9 64.29
Overall 1132 1075 94.97 802 70.85