Skip to main content
. 2002 Apr 22;2002(2):CD002873. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002873
Study Reason for exclusion
Bentur 1990 Not a randomised controlled trial. No control group.
Bremont 1992 Not a randomised controlled trial. Used infusion rather than inhaled medication.
Closa 1998 No placebo group. Comparison of nebuliser versus inhaler.
Connor 1989 Age range outside specified ‐ up to 36 months. Author contacted for data < 24 months.
Daugbjerg 1993 Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.
De La Luz 1999 Age range beyond specified (0 to 72 months)
Hayden 1998(b) Not a randomised controlled trial. Not randomised.
Hayden 1998a Not a randomised controlled trial. Not randomised.
Henderson 1993 Included only healthy infants.
Hickey 1994 Heterogenous patient group with >= 50% having RSV.
Holmgren 1992 Not a randomised controlled trial. Not randomised.
Jackson 1999 Not a randomised controlled trial. No control group.
Lenney 1978 Not a randomised controlled trial. No control group.
Mallol 1987a Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.
Mallol 1987b Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.
Naspitz 1992 No placebo group. Comparison of fenoterol plus or minus ipratropium bromide. Some patients on first episode of wheeze only.
O'Callaghan 1986 Not a randomised controlled trial. No control group.
O'Callaghan 1988 Not a randomised controlled trial. Not randomised and no control group.
Orlowski 1991 Not a randomised controlled trial.
Ploin 2000 Age range beyond specified (0 to 60 months)
Prendiville 1987b Not a randomised controlled trial. Active and placebo treatments given in order.
Prendiville 1987c Not a randomised controlled trial. Active and placebo treatments given in order.
Radford 1975 Not a randomised controlled trial. No contemporaneous control group.
Rubilar 2000 Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.
Rutter 1975 No a randomised controlled trial. Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.
Schweich 1992 Heterogenous patient group with >= 50% having RSV.
Seidenberg 1991 Not a randomised controlled trial. 
 Phase 1 not controlled. Phase 2 not randomised.
Spier 1985 Abstract only. 
 Probable mixture of recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis. Study during RSV season.
Tal 1983 Heterogenous patient group with recurrent wheeze and bronchiolitis.