Table 2.
Potential outcome means, discrete change of mental health over survey waves, and estimated causal effect among students attending 43 secondary schools with linked survey data across three waves of the COMPASS study
| Depression |
Anxiety |
Flourishing—reversed |
||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model 2 | Model 3 | Model 2 | Model 3 | Model 2 | Model 3 | |||
| Potential outcome mean | 2018 | Mean [95% CI] | 7.64 [7.36, 7.92] | 7.65 [7.37, 7.94] | 5.28 [5.02, 5.55] | 5.29 [5.03, 5.55] | 7.01 [6.61, 7.40] | 6.99 [6.61, 7.37] |
| 2019 | 8.61 [8.40, 8.83] | 8.62 [8.42, 8.82] | 6.05 [5.82, 6.28] | 6.06 [5.84, 6.28] | 7.61 [7.30, 7.93] | 7.59 [7.30, 7.89] | ||
| 2020 | 9.09 [8.66, 9.53] | 9.09 [8.66, 9.52] | 6.36 [6.04, 6.68] | 6.32 [5.97, 6.66] | 7.70 [7.27, 8.13] | 7.61 [7.14, 8.08] | ||
| Average discrete change | 2019–18 (Pre) | Dif. Mean [95% CI] | .97 [.81, 1.14] | .97 [.79, 1.14] | .77 [.62, .91] | .77 [.62, .92] | .61 [.42, .79] | .61 [.42, .80] |
| 2020–19 (Per) | .48 [.10, .87] | .47 [.10, .83] | .30 [.07, .53] | .26 [.02, .50] | .09 [−.24, .41] | .01 [−.35, .38] | ||
| Estimated causal effect | Per - Pre | Dif.-In-Dif. [95% CI] | −.49 [−.93, −.05] | −.50 [−.94, −.05] | −.47 [−.74, −.19] | −.51 [−.83, −.20] | −.52 [−.92, −.13] | −.59 [−1.05, −.14] |
Model 1 (Not shown): Base model. Fixed effect model controlling for time-invariant unobservables; the lagged variable is the outcome; covariates used: sex interaction with age at entry.
Model 2: Model 1 but constraining sex/age effects on outcomes to be fixed across time and sample selection correction with predictors of selection: age, sex, and weekly spending money.
Model 3: Model 2 with predictors of selection: age, sex, weekly spending money, province, and school connectedness (predictor IMR).
Depression: CESD-10, range 0–30; Anxiety: GAD-7, range 0–21; Flourishing—reversed: Diener's 8-item Flourishing Scale, range 0–32 with lower numbers depicting higher flourishing.
CI = confidence interval; COMPASS = Cannabis use, Obesity, Mental health, Physical activity, Alcohol use, Smoking, and Sedentary behavior.