Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 16;29(10):3467–3477. doi: 10.1007/s00167-020-06297-7

Table 2.

Study characteristic, demographics and LoE of studies meeting inclusion criteria

Study Year Type of Study Type of Prosthesis (Fixed bearing/mobile bearing) No. of Patients No. of Knees mean Age, range (years) BMI categories Follow-up period (months) Secondary outcomes of Interest Level of Evidence (LoE)
Seyler [36] 2009 Cohort Fixed bearing 68 80 72(44–91)  < 30, > 30

60 months

(24–128)

2b
Bonutti [8] 2011 Retrospective Fixed bearing 67 80 66.5(45–81)  < 35, > 35

36 months

(24 to 84)

3b
Plate [33] 2015 Retrospective Fixed bearing 672 746 64  < 18.5, 18.5–25, 25–30, 30–35, 35–40, 40–45, > 45

33.6 months

(24 +)

3b
Zengerink [45] 2015 Retrospective Fixed bearing 130 141 60.5  < 30, > 30

60 months

(24–144)

Unexplained pain 3b
Venkatesh [40] 2016 Cohort Fixed bearing 148 175 61.7  < 30, > 30 67.2 months (24–120) Unexplained Pain, aseptic loosening, KSS 2b
Woo [42] 2017 Retrospective Fixed bearing 673 673 62  < 25, 25–30, 30–35, > 35

64 months

(30–102)

Unexplained pain, aseptic loosening 3b
Murray [30] 2013 Cohort Mobile bearing 2438 64  < 25, 25–30, 30–35, > 35, 35–40, 40–45, > 45 55.2 months (24–144) Unexplained pain, infection, aseptic loosening, OKS, KSS 2b
Xu [44] 2019 Cohort Fixed bearing 184 184 59.5  > 30, < 30 Minimum 120 months Aseptic loosening, infection, KSS, OKS 2b
Polat [34] 2019 Retrospective Mobile bearing 104 104 60.2  > 30, < 30

46 months

(31.4– 60.6)

Aseptic loosening, infection 3b