Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 23;2021(9):CD007651. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007651.pub3
Trial ID Interventions and comparators Trial period Ethnic groups (%) Sex (% female) Age, years(mean (SD)/range) BMI, kg/m²(mean (SD))
Breheny 2020 I: Daily Mile 2016 to 2018 52 White British
16 South Asian
8 Black African Caribbean
24 Other/unknown
48 8.9 (1.0)
C: usual school routine
 
Ketelhut 2020 I: high‐intensity interval training during PE 50 10.8 (0.6) 19.6 (4.6)
C: usual PE 41.7 10.7 (0.7) 19.7 (4.0)
Belton 2019 I: multi‐component PE, whole‐school and parent‐targeted intervention 2013 to 2015 51 12.8 (0.4) Male: 20.0 (3.1)
Female: 20.8 (3.5)
C: usual care 50 12.8 (0.4) Male: 19.3 (3.2)
Female: 20.3 (2.8)
Corepal 2019 I: pedometer challenge 2015 to 2016 53
C: usual school
Ickovics 2019 I1: PA school wellness policy 2011 to 2015 47 Hispanic
35 Non‐Hispanic black
18 Non‐Hispanic white 62 10.9 (0.6)
I2: PA + nutrition school wellness policy 50
C1: nutrition school wellness policy 50
C2: delayed control 50
Jago 2019 I: Action 3:30R after school PA club 2017 to 2018 49 8.4/8‐10 16.9 (2.5)
C: — 17.2 (2.4)
Leahy 2019 I: Burn2Learn, multi‐component high‐intensity interval training 2017 71 Australian
19 European
6 Asian
4 other 46 16.2 (0.4) 22.2 (3.0)
C: usual school activities
Lonsdale 2019a I: teacher PE training 2015 to 2016 58 English and European
9 Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander
33 Other
48 13.0 (0.6)
C: standard teaching 57 English and European
10 Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander
32 Other
41 12.9 (0.5)
Müller 2019 I1: PA only 2015 to 2016 "Colored children (mixed race ancestry), usually Afrikaans speaking, and black African children, mainly Xhosa speaking" 50 9.2 (0.9) 17.1
I2: PA + health education
I3: PA + health education + nutrition
C1: health education + nutrition 50
C2: no PA
Ordóñez Dios 2019 I: 2 x 45‐minute PE sessions per week and daily run 19.1 (3.1)
C: 2 x 45‐minute PE sessions per week 20.1 (3.8)
Seibert 2019 I: 4 core strategies to increase PA 49 11.1 (—) 22.0 (—)
C: usual PE 46 11.2 (—) 21.7 (—)
Seljebotn 2019
 
I: physically active lessons, active homework, physically active recess 2014 to 2015 48 9‐10 17.6 (3.0)
C: continued normal routine, approximately 135 minutes/week of PA 51 17.3 (2.9)
Zhou 2019
  I1: enhanced PE 2015 to 2016 —
  47 12.7 (0.6) —
 
I2: after school programme
I3: enhanced PE and after school programme
C: regular PE 
Adab 2018 I: 30 minutes of additional MVPA on each school day, cooking workshops, a 6‐week healthy eating programme, information sheets for families 2011 to 2015 45 White British
31 South Asian
8 Black African Caribbean
16 other 51 6.3 (0.3)
C: ongoing Year 2 health‐related activities and education resources, excluding topics related to healthy eating and PA 47
Carlin 2018 I: brisk walking intervention 2014 100 12.4 (0.6) 20.3 (3.9)
C: continued with normal PA habits 100 19.3 (4.3)
Harrington 2018 I: support for PA, PE, and school sport culture and practices with support of the Youth Sport Trust and a hub school 2015 to 2016 77 White European
12 South Asian
11 other 100 12.8 (0.8)
C: usual practice of PE and sport 100
Have 2018 I: active math lessons 2012 to 2013 52 7.2 (0.3) 16.1 (1.7)
C: regular classroom instruction 48 15.7 (2.2)
Pablos 2018 I: lunchtime extracurricular PA 50 10.7 (0.7)
C: continued with daily activities 54
Robbins 2018 I: an after school PA club, counselling, interactive Internet‐based sessions 2011 to 2016 56 Black
44 Non‐Black
16 Hispanic or Latino
84 not Hispanic or Latino
100 12.1 (0.8) 22.9 (6.0)
C: no additional after school programming 64 Black
36 Non‐Black
13 Hispanic or Latino
87 not Hispanic or Latino
100 23.6 (6.1)
Siegrist 2013 I: weekly lifestyle lessons "Mainly Caucasian" 40 11.1 (0.6) 19.1 (3.5)
C: usual activities 47
Ten Hoor 2018 I: strength training and motivational interviewing 2015 to 2016 52 13.0 (0.5) 19.7 (3.5)
C: usual curriculum 47
Donnelly 2017 I: Academic Achievement and Physical Activity Across the Curriculum lessons, 160 minutes/week of MVPA 85 not Hispanic or Latino
11 Hispanic or Latino
2 unknown
2 refused or missing 49 8.1 (0.6) 17.4 (3.1)
C: traditional classroom instruction and typical PE schedule 54 8.1 (0.6)
Farmer 2017 I: school‐specific playground action plan 2011 to 2013 19 Māori
12 Pacific
7 Asian
46 New Zealand
16 unknown 47 8.0 (1.2) 17.4 (2.8)
C: no change to school play spaces 14 Māori
11 Pacific
9 Asian
52 New Zealand
13 unknown 53 7.9 (1.1) 17.4 (2.7)
Sutherland 2017 I: modified Supporting Children's Outcomes using Rewards, Exercise, and Skills programme 2014 to 2015 51 10.2
C: delivered school PA practices according to the curriculum 10.1
Torbeyns 2017 I: cycling desks 2014 to 2015 50 14.3 (0.6) 19.7 (3.5)
C: no lifestyle change 46 20.1 (3.7)
Daly 2016 I: specialist‐taught PE intervention 2005 to 2009 92 Caucasian
6 Asian
1 Indigenous Australian or Polynesian descent
1 unknown 48 8.1 (0.4) Girls: 17.2 (0.2)
Boys: 16.9 (0.2)
49 Girls: 17.2 (0.2)
Boys: 17.0 (0.2)
C: usual PE programme
de Greeff 2016 I: physically active mathematics and language lessons 55 8.1 (0.7) 17.0 (2.8)
C: usual curriculum 59 16.9 (2.6)
Drummy 2016 I: teacher‐led activity break 9.5/9‐10 19.4 (3.5)
C: normal daily routine 18.3 (2.4)
Jarani 2016 I1: group circuit training‐based PE 50 8.4 (1.6) 17.4 (3.2)
I2: games‐based PE 49 8.3 (1.6) 17.9 (3.3)
C: traditional PE school 44 8.3 (1.6) 17.8 (3.4)
Kocken 2016 I: theory and practical lessons on nutrition and PA 2009 to 2011 87 Western
13 non‐Western 52 9.2 (0.6)
C: regular school programme or curriculum on nutrition and PA 85 Western
15 non‐Western 51 9.1 (0.6)
Lau 2016 I: Xbox 260 Kinect gaming sessions after school Asian 28 9.2 (0.5) 19.4 (3.6)
C: regular PA and PE class 35 19.8 (3.6)
Resaland 2016 I: physically active Norwegian, mathematics, and English lessons on the playground; PA breaks and PA homework 2014 to 2015 47 10.2 (0.3) 18.0 (3.0)
C: curriculum‐prescribed PE and PA 49 18.1 (3.0)
Sutherland 2016 I: 7 PA intervention strategies and 6 implementation strategies 2012 to 2014 5 Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander 52 12 19.9 (3.6)
C: only measurement components of the trial, regular PA and PE 8 Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander 51 20.2 (3.8)
Tarp 2016 I: 60 minutes of PA during school time, PA homework 2013 to 2014 Boys:
98 Danish
2 European
Girls:
96 Danish
2 European
1 other
49 12.9 (0.6) 19.8 (2.9)
C: normal practice Boys:
94 Danish
2 European
4 other
Girls:
91 Danish
2 European
7 other
52 19.3 (3.0)
Cohen 2015 I: teacher learning, PA policies, school‐community linkages 2012 to 2013 14 Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander
86 Australian
1 Asian
5 European
7 other 54 8.5 (0.6)
C: usual PE and school sport programmes 54
Jago 2015 I: after school dance classes 2013 to 2014 100 11‐12 19.5 (3.4)
C: provided data only 100 19.5 (3.7)
Madsen 2015 I: nutrition education curriculum, Playworks structured recess before or after school activities, PA and games implemented by teachers 2011 to 2013 6 White
9 Black
55 Latino
15 mixed
16 other 49
C: — 6 White
13 Black
45 Latino
14 mixed
22 other 56
Muros 2015 I1: extracurricular PA sessions 2012 54 10.7 (0.5) 19.7 (3.7)
I2: PA and nutrition 44
I3: PA and nutrition and extra virgin olive oil during the final month 42
C1: nutrition and lifestyle education sessions 54
C2: usual activities 51
Suchert 2015 I: multi‐level intervention targeting students, classrooms, schools, and parents 2014 to 2015 47 13.7 (0.7)
C: no intervention 49
Andrade 2014 I: ACTIVITAL individual‐ and environment‐based intervention 2009 to 2012 66 12.9 (0.8) 19.8 (3.4)
C: standard curriculum 59 19.7 (2.9)
Jago 2014 I: Action 3:30 activity club 2012 to 2013 59 10 (0.6) 18.8 (3.4)
C: schools provided data only 18.4 (3.3)
Kipping 2014 I: PA education intervention 49 9.5 (0.3)
C: continued standard education provision 52
Kobel 2014 I: teacher training, PA education, active breaks 2010 to 2014 31 migration background 53 7.1 (0.6) 15.98 (2.14)
C: no intervention 49
Martinez‐Vizcaino 2014 I: MOVI‐2 extracurricular PA programme 2010 to 2011 55 9.5 (0.7) 19.0 (3.68)
C: standard PE curriculum 49
Nogueira 2014 I: high‐intensity capoeira sessions Female:
97 Caucasian
3 Asian or Black
Male:
96 Caucasian
4 Asian
41 10.6 (0.6) 18.5 (3.1)
C: usual school activities 50
Santos 2014 I: healthy buddies, healthy living lessons, structured aerobic exercise 2009 to 2010 25 First‐Nations
75 non‐First‐Nations 48 9.3
C: standard curriculum 31 First‐Nations
69 non‐First‐Nations 8.8
Toftager 2014 I: physical and organisational environmental changes 2010 to 2012 91 Native Danish parents 51 12.5 (0.6) 18.9 (3.0)
C: — 92 Native Danish parents 48 12.5 (0.6) 18.8 (3.0)
Fairclough 2013 I: weekly lesson plans, worksheets, homework tasks, lesson resources 2010 to 2011 95 White British 10.6 (0.3) 17.9 (3.0)
C: normal instruction 10.7 (0.3) 18.1 (3.7)
Ford 2013 I: accumulated brisk walking programme 48 5‐11 17.1 (3.3)
C: normal school lessons 16.4 (2.9)
Grydeland 2013 I: structured lessons, PA breaks, PA promotion 2007 to 2009 54 11.2 (0.3) 17.8 (2.5)
C: — 60 17.9 (2.6)
Melnyk 2013 I: goal‐setting, education, PA homework 2010 to 2012 65 Hispanic or Latino 55 14.7 (0.7) 29.7 (7.1)
C: Healthy Teens attention control curriculum was intended to promote knowledge of common adolescent health topics and health literacy 49
Sacchetti 2013 I: daily PA in schoolyard and classroom 2006 to 2009 48 9‐11 18.0 (2.9)
C: standard programme of PE 48 17.8 (2.9)
Siegrist 2013 I: JuvenTUM educational and environmental intervention 2006 to 2007 48 8.4 (0.7) 17.4 (2.9)
C: continued with usual school activities 17.3 (3.0)
Aburto 2011 I1: basic intervention of environmental and policy‐level change 2006 to 2007 Hispanic 50 10.2 (0.7) 19.8 (3.8)
I2: plus intervention adding additional resources and daily morning exercise 55
C: no change to standard practices 50
Ardoy 2011 I1: 4 sessions/week of PE 2007 35 13 (0.7) 22.3 (5.1)
I2: 4 sessions/week of PE with emphasis on increasing intensity 30
C: 2 sessions/week of PE 44
de Heer 2011 I: Bienstar intervention of health education and 45 to 60 minutes of after school PA 2008 Predominantly Hispanic 46 9.2 (1.0) 20.3 (4.4)
C1: Grade 4 health workbooks and incentives 45 20.0 (4.4)
C2: spillover control group 51 19.5 (4.2)
Jago 2011 I: education, social marketing, food environment, PE curriculum, equipment provision 2006 to 2009 59 Hispanic
20 Black
21 White 53 11.3 (0.6)
C: recruitment and data collection only 52
Jansen 2011 I: 3 PE sessions/week, additional after school sport and play, classroom education, parent health promotion 2006 to 2007 Grades 3 to 5:
14 Dutch
9 Surinam
6 Antillean
27 Moroccan
22 Turkish
4 Capeverdean
18 other or missing
Grades 6 to 8:
14 Dutch
11 Surinam
5 Antillean
22 Moroccan
24 Turkish
5 Capeverdea
19 other or missing
Grades 3‐5: 51
Grades 6‐8: 53
9.2 (1.0) Grades 3‐5: 17.1 (2.8)
Grades 6‐8: 19.1 (3.8)
C: continued with the usual curriculum Grades 3 to 5:
7 Dutch
11 Surinam
4 Antillean
36 Moroccan
20 Turkish
4 Capeverdean
17 other or missing
Grades 6 to 8:
8 Dutch
13 Surinam
3 Antillean
35 Moroccan
24 Turkish
5 Capeverdean
15 other or missing
Grades 3‐5: 51
Grades 6‐8: 49
Grades 3‐5: 17.1 (2.8)
Grades 6‐8: 19.8 (4.1)
Magnusson 2011 I: students engaged in PA during PE lessons, during recess, and during classes; schools had access to PA equipment to use in school lessons; teaching materials promoting PA were provided 2006 to 2008 52 7.4 (0.2) 15.8 (1.1)
C: followed the general PA curriculum 59 16.3 (1.0)
Okely 2011 I: PA action plan 2009 to 2010 100 13.6
C: continuation of usual programmes 100
Thivel 2011 I: 120 minutes of additional supervised PE 2003 51 6‐10 Normal weight: 15.6 (1.1)
C: habitual 2 hours of PE/week Obese: 20.6 (2.6)
49 Normal weight: 15.5 (1.1)
Obese: 20.2 (1.8)
Wilson 2011 I: Active by Choice Today programme: PA homework, in‐school PA, motivational skills training 76 African American 56 11.3 (0.6) 22.8 (6.2)
C: General Health Education Programme 69 African American 52 11.4 (0.6) 22.9 (5.9)
Kriemler 2010 I: 2 additional 45‐minute PE lessons/week, activity breaks, PA homework 2005 to 2006 Migrant families
Grade 1: 34
Grade 5: 25 Grade 1: 49
Grade 5: 55 Grade 1: 6.9 (0.3)
Grade 5: 11 (0.5) 17.1 (2.5)
C: usual, mandatory PE lessons Migrant families
Grade 1: 26
Grade 5: 24 Grade 1: 55
Grade 5: 46 Grade 1: 6.9 (0.3)
Grade 5: 11.3 (0.6) 17.0 (2.6)
Neumark‐Sztainer 2010 I: New Moves curriculum (nutrition and self‐empowerment, motivational interviewing, lunch meetings, parent outreach) 2007 to 2009 32 African American
27 White
17 Asian
13 Hispanic
8 mixed/other
3 American Indian 100 15.7 25.9 (7.1)
C: participation in all‐girls PE class 24 African American
22 White
30 Asian
16 Hispanic
7 mixed/other
2 American Indian 100 15.8 25.5 (6.5)
Angelopoulos 2009 I: educational intervention covering self‐esteem, body image, nutrition, PA, fitness, and environmental issues with motivational methods to increase knowledge, skills, self‐efficacy, self‐monitoring, and social influence 2005 to 2006 90 Greek
10 Immigrant 57 10.3 (0.4) 20.3 (3.6)
C: — 88 Greek
12 Immigrants 54 10.3 (0.4) 20.1 (3.4)
Donnelly 2009 I: 90 minutes/week of moderate to vigorous physically active academic lessons 77 Caucasian
6 African American
10 Hispanic
2 Native American
1 Asian
4 multi‐ethnic 52 Grade 2: 7.7 (0.3)
Grade 3: 8.7 (0.4) 17.9 (3.1)
C: regular classroom instruction Grade 2: 7.8 (0.4)
Grade 3: 8.7 (0.4) 18.0 (3.7)
Dorgo 2009 I1: PE manual resistance training programme 45 15.9 (1.2) 24.4 (6.1)
I2: PE manual resistance training plus cardiovascular endurance training 15.2 (1.2) 24.8 (5.9)
C: regular PE programme that followed the usual school curriculum 15.8 (1.1) 24.9 (5.4)
Gentile 2009 I: 'Switch' programme: promoted healthy lifestyles targeting family, school, and community 2005 to 2006 90 White 53 9.6 18.4 (3.3)
C: no intentional exposure to the 'Switch' programme 50 9.6 18.5 (3.5)
Neumark‐Sztainer 2009 I: after school theatre sessions, booster sessions, family outreach 2006 to 2007 54 African American
13 Asian
7 White
3 Hispanic
23 other or mixed 10.3 (1.1) 20.9(5.1)
C: theatre‐based control condition (i.e. children participated in a play focused on environmental health issues using a prepared script)
Peralta 2009 I: curriculum and peer‐facilitated lunchtime PA session, parent newsletters 2007 0 12.5 (0.4) 22.8 (4.1)
C: PA curriculum 0 20.4 (4.1)
Walther 2009 I: 1 unit of physical exercise (45 minutes) with at least 15 minutes of endurance training/school day, plus lessons on healthy lifestyle once/month 47 11.1 18.0 (2.6)
C: German standards, 2 units (each 45 minutes) of PE/week, 12 units (45 minutes/unit) of high‐level endurance exercise training/week plus participation in competitive sporting events 42 11.1 18.2 (2.8)
Reed 2008 I: Action Schools!BC whole‐school PA approach 2003 to 2004 49 10.2 (0.6) 18.8 (3.5)
C: regular programme of PE and school‐based PA 50 10.2 (0.6) 19.1 (3.7)
Salmon 2008 I1: behavioural modification group 2002 to 2003 51 10 (0.4)
I2: fundamental motor skills group 53
I3: combined behavioural modification and fundamental motor skills group 51
C: usual classroom lessons 51
Wang 2008 I: 'FitKid' after school intervention sessions 2002 to 2006 61 Black
31 White
2 Asian
2 Hispanic
5 other 52 8.5 (0.6) 19.4 (4.7)
C: — 19.3 (4.4)
Webber 2008 I: health education lessons to enhance behavioural skills known to influence PA participation (self‐monitoring, setting goals for behaviour change) 2003 to 2006 46 White
24 African American
12 Hispanic
18 other 100 12 20.7
C: — 100 20.9
Weeks 2008 I: directed jumping activity at the beginning of every PE class 58 Girls: 13.7 (0.4)
Boys: 13.8 (0.4) Girls: 19.5 (3.5)
Boys: 20.3 (3.6)
C: regular PE warm‐ups and stretching at the beginning of every PE class
49 Girls: 13.7 (0.5)
Boys: 13.8 (0.4) Girls: 19.5 (2.1)
Boys: 21.5 (5.1)
Barbeau 2007 I: after school PA programme 100 Black 100 9.5/8‐12 20.9 (5.0)
C: — 100 Black 100 9.5/8‐12 20.9 (5.6)
Williamson 2007 I: Healthy Eating and Exercise programme to increase PA during the school day and at home 95 White
2 Black
3 other 50 9.2 (4.1)
C: Alcohol/Drug/Tobacco abuse prevention programme
Haerens 2006 I1: a computer‐tailored intervention to increase MVPA to 60 minutes/d, increase fruit consumption, increase water consumption, and reduce fat 2003 to 2005 37 13.1 (0.8) Girls: 20.2
Boys: 19.2
I2: group 1 plus parental involvement Girls: 20.2
Boys: 19.3
C: no PA and nutrition intervention Girls: 19.1
Boys: 18.5
Young 2006 I: PE curriculum taught 5 days/week and family 83 African American 100 13.8 (0.5) 25.0 (6.9)
C: standard PE class 100 25.2 (6.7)
Bayne‐Smith 2004 I: Physical Activity and Teenage Health programme, education sessions plus 20 to 25 minutes of PA 1994 to 1996 13 White
46 African American
29 Hispanic
12 Asian American 100 16.2 (1.3) 22.8 (4.1)
C: same frequency or duration of PE classes, but without lecture or discussion 5 White
45 African American
28 Hispanic
12 Asian American 100 15.9 (1.2) 23.6 (5.0)
Simon 2004 I: an educational component focusing on PA and sedentary behaviours and new opportunities for PA during and after school hours 2002 to 2006 23 recomposed family 54 11.6 (0.6) 18.7 (3.7)
C: — 26 recomposed family 48 11.7 (0.7) 18.9 (3.9)
Trevino 2004 I: health programming regarding 3 health behaviour messages associated with diabetes mellitus control and goal‐setting 2001 to 2002 6 Asian
7 African American
83 Mexican American
5 other 50 9.8 (0.5) 20.6 (5.1)
C: — 6 Asian
13 African American
77 Mexican American
4 other 49 9.8 (0.5) 20.3 (4.8)
Stone 2003 I: food service, skills‐based classroom curricula, family, and PE 1993 to 2000 "American Indian" 48 7.6 (0.6)
C: —
Burke 1998 I1: standard PA and nutrition programme including classroom lessons, fitness sessions daily, and nutrition programme 1993 to 1994 49 11 Low‐risk girls: 17.5
High‐risk girls: 19.2
I2: I1 plus a PA enrichment programme for higher‐risk children
C: no programme Low‐risk boys: 16.8
High‐risk boys: 21.1
Ewart 1998 I: 50‐minute 'Project Heart' aerobic exercise classes 1991 to 1994 30 White
70 African American 100 24.8 (5.8)
C: 50‐minute standard PE classes 100 24.1 (5.0)
Luepker 1996 I1: school food service modifications, PE interventions, and Child and Adolescent Trial for Cardiovascular Health curricula 1991 to 1994 69 White
13 African American
14 Hispanic
4 other 48 8.8 17.6 (0.1)
I2: I1 plus a family‐based programme
C: usual health curricula, PE, and food service programmes 17.6 (0.1)
Bush 1989 I1: 'Know Your Body' curriculum focusing on nutrition, fitness, prevention of smoking, a personalised health screening, and results on a 'health passport' for parents 1983 to 1988 "Predominantly black" 54 10.5 14.3
I2: 'Know Your Body' curriculum and health screening, but students do not receive the results of their screening; only parents receive the results
C: health screening only 14
Walter 1988 I: special curriculum targeting voluntary changes in risk behaviour in the areas of diet, PA, and smoking 1980 to 1985 Bronx:
32 White
43 Black
25 other
Westchester:
90 White
3 Black
7 other
Bronx: 49
Westchester: 46 Bronx: 9.0
Westchester: 8.9 Bronx: 11.8 (0.3)
Westchester: 11.3 (0.3)
C: — Bronx:
29 White
49 Black
22 other
Westchester:
79 White
15 Black
6 other
Bronx: 46
Westchester: 53 Bronx: 9
Westchester: 8.9 Bronx: 11.8 (0.3)
Westchester: 11.9 (0.3)