Skip to main content
NIHPA Author Manuscripts logoLink to NIHPA Author Manuscripts
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Feb 9.
Published in final edited form as: Leonardo (Oxf). 2021 Aug 9;54(4):398–401. doi: 10.1162/leon_a_01915

ENDLESS FORMS MOST BEAUTIFUL: A GARDEN SHOWS THAT CANCER IS A PART OF LIFE

Pamela Winfrey 1, Caspian Robertson 2, Carlo Maley 1,3,4, Athena Aktipis 1,4,5,6
PMCID: PMC8460130  NIHMSID: NIHMS1656792  PMID: 34565895

Abstract

Endless Forms Most Beautiful is a crested cactus garden that embodies both an aesthetic and medically transformative approach to cancer. The cacti in this garden have mutations in their meristem cells causing uncontrolled growths—which are, by some definitions, cancer. The garden was installed near the new Biodesign Institute C building on the Arizona State University campus in Tempe. Crested cacti, and other fasciated plants, are examples of organisms that live with cancer, but do not die from it. These plants help to widen the framework for thinking about what cancer is, how to live with it, and ultimately inspired a new center, the Arizona Cancer Evolution (ACE) Center, which investigates cancer across life.

Introduction

Cancer is a frightening disease. Creating evocative experiences and artwork around the science of cancer can be a challenge. How do you encourage people to engage with a disease that is so scary; with a disease that has likely touched their lives and perhaps even stolen their loved ones? At Arizona State University, we have created a new and different kind of artwork/experience to communicate the science of cancer: A garden composed of plants both beautiful and monstrous, whose sculptural aesthetics derive from mutations during growth and development. Endless forms most beautiful illustrates two important aspects of the science of cancer: First, the ubiquity of cancer-like processes across all forms of life and second, the promise of new therapies that aim for long-term control of cancer.

Dr. Aktipis first encountered these striking plants during a visit to Arizona almost 10 years ago. (See Figure 1). Their elegance and grace despite their apparent deformity has a certain poetic beauty and their ability to survive even with these cancer-like forms was inspiring. Aktipis’ obsession with these plants began at that point, and it was partly her aesthetic interest in them that led her to the broader questions: Are these mutated forms cancer? And: What does cancer look like across life, from coral to cacti?

Fig 1.

Fig 1.

Crested Cactus, Desert Botanical Garden. (Photo: Pamela Winfrey)

Part of being a multicellular organism means having cells that divide and can mutate during a lifetime. The cacti in Endless Forms Most Beautiful have mutations in their meristem cells causing uncontrolled growths—which are, by some definitions, cancer. The mutations cause distinctive growths, sculptural in form, and these abnormal specimens are prized as beautiful and rare [1]. They are called crested or ‘fasciated’ plants, fasciation being the more general term for plants with mutations in their growth tips that cause these unusual forms.

After moving to Arizona, Dr. Aktipis and Dr. Maley worked with Caspian Robertson, Director of the landscape design company, Caspian Gardens, to create a series of drawings that would eventually end up as the final design for the garden.

Robertson had this to say about the experience: “I was delighted to have been asked to contribute to this fascinating project, and have been amazed by the personal enthusiasm and care that those involved have given to it.

The great thing about gardens as a medium is that they are ever adapting over time; just as the caricature of the project evolves, so too does the planting!

This seems all the more poignant when designing on the theme of change being a natural and beautiful process, and it is my hope that this space will continue to transform and provoke thought for many years to come”.

The questions about cancer across life, seeded partly by these crested cacti and their beauty, have grown into a large research program, which is now a significant part of the Arizona Cancer Evolution Center. The Arizona Cancer Evolution Center (ACE) is studying cancer across life in sponges, bats, whales, elephants, and many other species.

The name of the garden, “Endless forms most beautiful”, is based on the end of Darwin’s first 1859 edition, “On the Origin of Species” where he says: “There is grandeur in this view of life… from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved”.

The idea for this garden was to represent two critical aspects of cancer:

  1. Susceptibility to cancer is a fundamental part of all multicellular life, across the tree of life [1, 2].

  2. It is possible to live with cancer and cancer-like growths [3, 4], as many of these cacti do.

Plants are radically different from animals, and yet, as multicellular organisms, they too are susceptible to cancer-like phenomena. Plant tumors are characterized by both abnormal proliferation and large cell size, suggesting that not only are these cells dividing when they are not supposed to, but that they are also acquiring more resources than is their due. Some researchers have argued that plants are particularly resistant to cancer because their cells do not migrate through their bodies and are fixed in place with rigid cell walls, preventing them from invading neighboring tissue and metastasizing to distant sites. In fact, plant tumors typically are not lethal. However, researchers have reported metastasis-like phenomena in plants, with tumor strands emanating from primary plant tumors [5]. Bacteria-free tumors have also been reported at secondary sites without the apparent presence of tumor strands [6]. So little is known about these phenomena and the genetic mutations that cause plant tumors, that many exciting opportunities for discovery and await future researchers.

This garden is different from much of the art associated with cancer - which is usually created by patients and designed to have a therapeutic impact - because the aim is to create a work about the fascinating science of cancer. Artworks that explore the thinking behind the research are rare. Many previous artworks simply present the cells themselves as a beautiful and insidious visual narrative. However, the science of cancer is filled with fascinating concepts - like the way that cancer manifests across different forms of life - that few people have had the opportunity to consider. Engaging more deeply with the nature of cancer and its relationship to multicellular life may help cancer patients and their families see cancer differently - and explore a different therapeutic approach that is aimed at cancer control rather than eradication [7–9].

As is true in most public artworks, there are multiple stakeholders. Because Robertson was not licensed for Arizona, we hired the MOORE / SWICK partnership, a local landscape architecture and planning firm which could assist him in adapting his design to Arizona conditions and design vernacular.

The process was paved with people who had their own relationship to cancer; Kevin Moore was no exception. He wore a machine, hanging from his shoulder, that was slowly leaching chemotherapy poisons into his veins during our planning meetings. “Ironically, I was going through my own cancer experience while working on this project. From the outset, I tried to maintain a positive outlook, refusing to think about my experience as a “battle” with the need to “beat” anything – an attitude I saw as too confrontational. I’ve preferred to understand my cancer for what it was, not a foreign enemy, but cells in my own body that have “gone rogue” and weren’t caught by my immune system, that needed to be managed rather than beaten. I was encouraged to hear the scientists at the ASU Biodesign Institute talk about their current understanding and approach to cancer in the same terms”.

Half of us will be diagnosed with cancer at some point in our lifetimes and it is viewed as a devastating diagnosis [10]. However, there are many ways in which cancer can be transformative.

Then we found out that we needed to add yet another layer of landscape architects because we planned on installing it on the campus of Arizona State University. Lucky for us that layer was Byron Sampson, Associate Director and University Landscape Architect, at ASU, who had yet another personal story to add to the mix.

“Through the course of gaining additional insight and meaning of the garden, I was able to discuss openly my own experiences and see them come to fruition in a beautiful garden. My father had passed away eleven years ago after a long “battle” with oral cancer, my mother is a breast cancer survivor and I am a brain cancer survivor, being diagnosed four years ago. In the ensuing conversations with Todd Briggs, the co-director of the Trueform Landscape Architecture Studio, his lead designer was adamant that she work on the project as she was a cancer survivor as well. This garden brought together many different people, all with similar stories and a unified understanding of the unique aspects of the meaning behind the garden.”

The installation of the garden coincides with the start of clinical trials to test a strategy for living with, but not dying from, cancer called adaptive therapy [7–9]. Fittingly, the innovation behind these trials comes from agriculture and the strategies farmers have developed to manage pests. High dose chemotherapy, like high doses of pesticides, kill most of the cells/pests, but leave behind mutants that are resistant (immune) to the drug. This is why, when a tumor recurs after therapy, it typically no longer responds to that therapy. However, that resistance usually comes at a cost. It either takes some energy to detoxify or expel the drug, or the variant that can avoid the drug is less well adapted to its environment than the sensitive cells/pests, in the absence of drug. Farmers have learned that they can capitalize on the cost of resistance by not spraying a part of their fields, and thereby keep some sensitive pests around to out-compete the resistant pests. Typical high dose chemotherapy kills all of the chemo-sensitive cancer cells, leaving nothing to control the chemo-resistant cells. Bob Gatenby translated this insight to cancer therapy with a strategy called “adaptive therapy” in which the dose of the chemotherapy is reduced or stopped if the tumor starts shrinking, so as to preserve sensitive cells. If the tumor regrows, chemotherapy is started again, but now the tumor is mostly composed of sensitive cells, and so it continues to respond to the drug. In mouse experiments, Gatenby and colleagues were able to keep cancers under control indefinitely (with lower and lower doses of chemotherapy over time) [7, 9]. The first pilot clinical trial tested adaptive therapy in castration resistant metastatic prostate cancer and has been able to keep control of the cancer in 10 out of 11 men for over a median of 27 months, where, under standard therapy, they would have lost control of at least half of the men’s cancers within 16 months [8]. That trial is continuing and expanding. Meanwhile, we are about to open the first pilot trial of adaptive therapy in breast cancer at the Mayo Clinic Arizona, with Drs. Donald Northfelt and Karen Anderson. We see this garden in part as an embodiment of this new approach to cancer - to live with cancer as a normal part of life, pruning it back occasionally, and managing it responsibly.

The garden is now installed and is still immature, filled with relatively new cacti; a triangular space that, given time, will grow into a fully realized landscape complete with a seating area. Additional cacti will be added as they are identified by The Tucson Cactus and Succulent Society Cactus Rescue Crew, which saves cacti and other native plants that would otherwise be destroyed during the development of Arizona real estate.

Pamela Winfrey, the Scientific Research Curator for the project, developed an opportunity for people to write the names of people they know who have been impacted by cancer onto plant identification tags. These tags are then added to the garden. We are currently developing an artist call to develop a sculpture that will house this ever growing project. This adds to the feeling that this garden is for the community; a place that is theirs; a place of solace, sympathy, and solidarity.

We envision the garden as a place where people can engage with the science of cancer while simultaneously having a peaceful and grounding aesthetic experience with the crested cacti and other plants in the garden. As one woman said who contributed a tag, “For me, this is a place of comfort”.

Many voices and collaborations have shaped this garden into an echo of Darwin’s thoughts when he wrote of the “grandeur in this view of life.” Our garden itself had “so simple a beginning” and from it “endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.” If you would like to become a part of “Endless Forms” please contact us at https://cancer-insights.asu.edu/about-ace/contact/

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2.

Planting Scheme by Caspian Robertson. An educational garden installation at Arizona State University, Second iteration. (Courtesy, Caspian Robertson).

Acknowledgements:

Support for the garden comes from the National Cancer Institute, the Arizona Cancer Evolution Center, ASU Biodesign Institute, ASU’s Frankenstein Bicentennial Project, ASU Office of the University Architect and Facility Management Grounds Department, the MOORE / SWICK partnership landscape architects, TRUEFORM landscape architecture studio, Airpark Signs, ASU’s Lincoln Center for Applied Ethics, and people who have been impacted by cancer. This garden was created by Athena Aktipis, Carlo Maley, Pamela Winfrey from ASU, Caspian Robertson of Caspian Gardens (London), and many dedicated landscape architects and gardeners.

The adaptive therapy trial at the Arizona Mayo Clinic is funded by the Arizona Biomedical Research Commission grant ADHS18–198847. The Arizona Cancer Evolution Center is funded by NIH Grant U54 CA217376. This work was additionally supported in part by NIH grants U2C CA233254, P01 CA91955, R01 CA149566, R01 CA170595, R01 CA185138 and R01 CA140657 as well as CDMRP Breast Cancer Research Program Award BC132057. The findings, opinions and recommendations expressed here are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the universities where the research was performed or the National Institutes of Health.

Biographies

BIOS

Pamela Winfrey is the Scientific Research Curator for the Arizona Cancer Evolution Center (ACE), as well as the Cancer and Evolution and the Cooperation and Conflict Labs at Arizona State University. She is an award winning playwright, screenwriter, and novelist, and an emeritus at the Exploratorium, where she worked for over thirty five years as a senior artist and curator.

Caspian Robertson is an award winning landscape architect and the director of the garden design and construction company, Caspian Gardens. His gardens have been installed in Saudi Arabia, the United States, the United Kingdom, and Russia.

Athena Aktipis is a cooperation theorist, theoretical evolutionary biologist, and cancer biologist. She is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychology at Arizona State University, co-Director of the Human Generosity Project, and co-founder and Vice President of the International Society for Evolution, Ecology and Cancer. She is the author of the forthcoming book from Princeton University Press “Evolution in the Flesh: How evolution, ecology and cooperation theory are changing how we understand and treat cancer.”

Carlo Maley is a cancer biologist, evolutionary biologist and computational biologist, working at the intersection of those fields. His team applies evolutionary and ecological theory to problems in cancer. He is co-director of the newly formed Arizona Cancer Evolution Center (ACE), and co-founder and President of the International Society for Evolution, Ecology and Cancer.

References

  • 1.Aktipis CA, Boddy AM, Jansen G, Hibner U, Hochberg ME, Maley CC, Wilkinson GS (2015) Cancer across the tree of life: cooperation and cheating in multicellularity. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 10.1098/rstb.2014.0219 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
  • 2.Aktipis A (2017) Cancer Has Been With Us Since the Origins of Multicellularity, and It’s Not Going Anywhere. In: Slate Magazine. https://slate.com/technology/2017/04/cancer-has-been-with-us-since-the-origins-of-multicellularity.html. Accessed 16 Apr 2019 [Google Scholar]
  • 3.Harach HR, Franssila KO, Wasenius V-M (1985) Occult papillary carcinoma of the thyroid. A “normal” finding in Finland. A systematic autopsy study. Cancer 56:531–538 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 4.Valle LA, Kloos RT (2011) The prevalence of occult medullary thyroid carcinoma at autopsy. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 96:E109–13 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 5.White PR, Braun AC (1942) A Cancerous Neoplasm of Plants. Autonomous Bacteria-Free Crown-Gall Tissue. Cancer Res 2:597–617 [Google Scholar]
  • 6.Agrios GN (2005) Introduction to plant pathology. Elsevier Academic Press Publication [Google Scholar]
  • 7.Enriquez-Navas PM, Kam Y, Das T, et al. (2016) Exploiting evolutionary principles to prolong tumor control in preclinical models of breast cancer. Sci Transl Med 8:327ra24 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8.Zhang J, Cunningham JJ, Brown JS, Gatenby RA (2017) Integrating evolutionary dynamics into treatment of metastatic castrate-resistant prostate cancer. Nat Commun 8:1816. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 9.Gatenby RA, Silva AS, Gillies RJ, Frieden BR (2009) Adaptive therapy. Cancer Res 69:4894–4903 [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 10.Siegel RL, Miller KD, Jemal A (2016) Cancer statistics, 2016. CA Cancer J Clin 66:7–30 [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

RESOURCES