Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 23;21:999. doi: 10.1186/s12879-021-06707-2

Table 2.

Summary of the previously reported human cases with Enterococcus hirae

Case References Age Gender Year Underlying diseases Chief complaint Method of E. hirae identification Diagnosis treatment Outcome
1 Gilad et al. [24] 49 Male 1998 ESRD with hemodialysis, Indwelling central venous catheter Fever Rapid ID 32 Strep system Septicemia VCM + TOB Complete resolution
2 Tan et al. [12] 82 Female 2000 DM N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Urinary tract infection AMPC + GEM Complete resolution
3 Tan et al. [12] 80 Male 2001 Biliary tract disease N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis

Biliary tract

infection

CMZ + 

Operation

Complete resolution
4 Poyart et al. [6] 72 Male 2002 Coronary artery disease Fever, Chills, Progressive malaise, Generalized weakness (sodA gene) sequencing Native valve Endocarditis

ABPC + GM 4 weeks, RFP 3 weeks → ABPC + GM po

Readmission: VCM + GM 6 weeks → ABPC po total 8 weeks

Complete resolution
5 Tan et al. [12] 50 Male 2002 ESRD N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Primary bacteremia VCM Complete resolution
6 Tan et al. [12] 55 Male 2003 N/A N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Urinary tract infection ABPC Complete resolution
7 Tan et al. [12] 63 Male 2004 Biliary tract disease N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Biliary tract infection ABPC/SBT + biliary drainage Complete resolution
8 Tan et al. [12] 69 Female 2004 N/A N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Urinary tract infection ABPC/SBT Complete resolution
9 Tan et al. [12] 57 Male 2006 Tongue cancer N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis

Catheter Associate

infection

VCM + Removal of catheter Complete resolution
10 Vinh et al. [9] 80 Male 2006 DM, Hypercholesterolemia, Coronary artery disease, Resection of malignant colonic polyp Dyspnea, Vague epigastric discomfort VITEK 2 automated system (bioMériux) Native-valve bacterial endocarditis ABPC 6 weeks after aortic replacement Complete resolution
11 Tan et al. [12] 59 Male 2008 Pancreatic cancer with obstructive jaundice N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis Biliary tract infection VCM + IPM + Surgical intervention Died
12 Tan et al. [12] 69 Female 2008

Lung cancer on

chemotherapy

N/A 6.5% NaCl tolerance and growth on bile-esculin agar with esculin hydrolysis

CatheterAssociate

infection

VCM + 

Removal of catheter

Complete resolution
13 Canalejo et al. [25] 55 Male 2008 DM Low back pain, Fever, Chills VITEK 2 automated system (bioMériux), rRNA gene sequencing Spondylodiscitis ABPC + GM 8 Weeks → Surgery → LVFX po + ST 6 months Complete resolution
14 Nicolosi et al. [26] 63 Male 2009 N/A N/A Unknown Bacteremia N/A N/A
15 Chan et al. [5] 62 Female 2010 N/A Fever, Chills, Urinary irritation BD Phoenix ID/AST Panel Inoculation System Acute pyelonephritis CEZ + GM → ABPC → AMPC for total 12 days Complete resolution
16 Chan et al. [5] 86 Female 2010 Congestive heart failure, HT, Valvular heart disease, Parkinsonism, Dementia, Recent history of hospitalization Hypotensive, Febrile, Tachycardiac, Tachypneic BD Phoenix ID/AST Panel Inoculation System Acute cholangitis CMZ 16 days → oral antibiotics (unknown) total 23 days Complete resolution
17 Talarmin et al. [7] 78 Female 2011 DM, HT, Aortic valve replacement with a bioprosthetic valve Fever, Generalized weakness, Weight loss I6S rRNA sequencing Prosthetic valve endocarditis

AMPC + GM 2 weeks → AMPC + RFP 4 weeks → 

relapse 4 months after discontinuation of antibiotics therapy, same antibiotics started as for the initial episode for total 6 weeks

Relapse → 

Complete resolution

18 Sim et al. [20] 61 Male 2012 Alcoholic liver cirrhosis, DM Abdominal pain, Fever, Chills, Generalized weakness Automated MicroScan WalkAway system; sugar fermentation tests Spontaneous bacterial peritonitis CTX → VCM + CPFX → ABPC total 17 days Complete resolution
19 Brulé et al. [18] 44 Male 2013 Alcoholic liver disease, Atrial fibrillation, Dilated cardiomyopathy Fever, Diarrhea, Vomit Gel electrophoresis Bacteremia, Pyelonephritis

CTRX + MNZ → add AMK → 

nephrectomy → AMPC total 21 days

Complete resolution
20 Anghinah R et al. [10] 56 Male 2013 HT, DM, Hypercholesterolemia, Cardiac arrhythmia with surgical ablation, Surgical removal of a gastric leiomyoma Slurred speech, Weight loss, Generalized fatigue, Depressive symptoms, Fever Unknown Native valve endocarditis

Oxacillin + 

GM → ABPC → ABPC + 

RFP total

4 weeks + 

replacement of the aortic valve → 

RFP + AMPC 2 weeks

Complete resolution
21 Alfouzan et al.[22] 48 Female 2014 DM Abdominal pain, Productive cough, Fever BD Phoenix Automated Microbiology System and DNA sequencing Multiple splenic abscesses

PIPC/TAZ + 

VCM + MNZ → Splenectomy → PIPC/TAZ + ABPC + LZD

total 2 weeks

Complete resolution
22 Dicpinigaitis et al. [27] 85 Female 2015 HT, Hyperlipidemia Nausea, Vomit, Abdominal pain MALDI-TOF MS Acute Pancreatitis PIPC/TAZ → CFPM → ABPC total 14 days Complete resolution
23 Bourafa et a. [14] 50 Male 2015 BPH, DM, Urinary catheterization Dysuria with cloudy urine, Suprapubic pain, Urinary frequency, and urgency MALDI-TOF MS Symptomatic lower UTI APBC + GM total 10 days Complete resolution
24 Paosinho et al. [3] 78 Female 2016 Atrial fibrillation, Chronic renal disease Nausea, Lipothymia, Generalized weakness Unknown Acute pyelonephritis AMPC/CVA → PIPC/TAZ total 14 days Complete resolution
25 Atas et al. [21] 70 Female 2017 CKD, Dialysis Abdominal pain, Cloudy dialysate Unknown Peritonitis Intraperitoneal CXM-AX + CPFX PO → did not respond to therapy → VCM 3 weeks → discharge → relapse → Intraperitoneal VCM 3 weeks Relapse → Complete resolution
26 Hee Lee et al. [4] 78 Male 2017 DM, HT, Coronary arterial occlusive disease Left flank pain, Febrile sensation BacT/ALERT 3D Microbial Detection System (bioMérieux Inc., Durham) Acute Pyelonephritis CTRX → CPFX po 14 days Complete resolution
27 Hee Lee et al. [4] 74 Male 2017 DM, HT, Coronary arterial occlusive disease Left flank pain, Febrile sensation, Chills BacT/ALERT 3D Microbial Detection System (bioMérieux Inc., Durham) Acute pyelonephritis CTRX → CPFX po 14 days Complete resolution
28 Gittemeier et al. [8] 70 Male 2019 N/A Bilateral leg edema, Dyspnea on exertion, Fatigue MALDI-TOF MS Aortic valve endocarditis VCM → ABPC + CTRX → Aortic valve replacement → CTRX + PCG total 6 weeks Complete resolution
29 Merlo et al. [17] 57 Male 2019 DM, COPD, Hepatic cirrhosis Child–Pugh B secondary to HCV Dyspnea, Disorientation, Fever MALDI-TOF MS Pneumonia PIPC/TAZ + AZM + Rifaximine PO → AMPC/CVA total of 8 days Complete resolution
30 Pinkes et al. [11] 67 Female 2019 COPD, Recurrent DVT, Atrial fibrillation, HT, Hypothyroidism, Hodgkin’s lymphoma fever, hypotension, atrial fibrillation with a rapid ventricular response, and a two-week history of lightheadedness MALDI-TOF–MS Native-valve endocarditis Aortic valve replacement, ABPC + CTRX total of 6 weeks Complete resolution
31 Brayer et al. [19] 7 months Male 2019 Gastroschisis, Jejunal atresia Fussiness, Fever Vitek 2 system (bioM.rieux)

Catheter

associated

infection

VCM

 + PIPC/TAZ → VCM

 → VCM + CTRX → ABPC + 

CTRX and for 2 weeks with synergistic GM

Complete resolution
Our case Nakamura et al. 57 Male 2020 Neurogenic bladder, Alcoholic cirrhosis 3 days fever and chills MALDI-TOF–MS Acute pyelonephritis CTRX → add ABPC → LZD PO Complete resolution

Vancomycin, VCM; tobramycin, TOB; flomoxef, FMOX; ampicillin, AMPC; gentamicin, GM; rifampin, RFP; PO, oral administration, Levofloxacin, LVFX; trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, ST; Amoxicillin, AMPC; Ceftriaxone, CTRX; Ciprofloxacin, CPFX; Cefazolin, CEZ; Cefmetazole; CMZ, cefotaxime; CTX, metronidazole; MNZ, amikacin; AMK, piperacillin/tazobactam; PIPC/TAZ, linezolid; LZD, Cefepime, CFPM; benign prostatic hyperplasia, BPH; amoxicillin-clavulanic acid, AMPC/CVA; penicillin G, PCG; azithromycin, AZM, ESRD, end-stage renal disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; HT, hypertension; cefuroxime axetil CXM-AX; chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, COPD; deep vein thrombosis, DVT