Table 2.
Comparison | Participants; Duration (in weeks) | Change between CHM and Control Group MD (95% CI) | Change within CHM group; MD (95% CI) | Change within Control group; MD (95% CI) |
1. CHM vs Placebo | ||||
Zhang 2016 | 96;60 | 1.33 [−0.34,3.00] | 0.68 [−0.80,2.16] | −1.32[−2.52, −0.12] |
Zhang 2014 | 12;28 | 0.68 [−0.67,2.03] | 1.50 [0.52, 2.48] | 0.50 [−0.95, 1.95] |
Zhou 2007 | 48;79 | 0.64 [−0.09,1.37] | 2.22 [1.68, 2.76] | 1.81 [1.11. 2.51] |
Wu 2016 | 12;78 | 2.53 [0.92, 4.14] | 1.35 [0.68, 2.02] | −0.60 [−2.77,1.57] |
2. CHM vs Other drugs | ||||
CHM vs Nimodipine | ||||
Zhang 2018 | 12;60 | 3.15 [1.30, 5.00] | 4.68 [2.17,7.19] | 2.12 [0.79, 3.45] |
Zhao 2009 | 12;60 | 0.32 [−0.09, 0.73] | 1.35 [0.68,2.02] | −0.60 [−2.77,1.57] |
Cui 2015 | 12;32 | 0.13 [−0.92,1.18] | 2.00 [1.16, 2.84] | 2.06 [1.16, 2.96] |
CHM vs Aniracetam | ||||
Guo 2010 | 12;64 | 1.09 [0.18, 2.00] | 2.91 [2.21, 3.61] | 1.94 [1.24, 2.64] |
Zhong 2007 | 12;166 | −0.06 [−0.61, 0.49] | 0.77 [0.16, 1.38] | 0.57 [0.01, 1.13] |
Gu2015 | 12;100 | −0.39 [−1.04, 0.26] | 1.00 [0.13, 1.87] | 0.63 [0.02, 1.24] |
Chen 2016 | 12;86 | 0.24 [−0.41, 0.89] | 0.42 [−0.04, 0.88] | 0.97 [0.41, 1.53] |
Wang 2011 | 12;80 | 1.41 [0.44, 2.38] | 3.40 [2.47, 4.33] | 1.68 [0.73, 2.63] |
CHM vs Piracetam | ||||
Zhu 2010 | 12;100 | 0.90 [0.37, 1.43] | 2.48 [1.94, 3.02] | 1.58 [1.04, 2.12] |
Li 2016 | 12;60 | 0.29 [−0.23, 0.81] | 1.00 [0.49, 1.51] | −0.97 [−1.44, −0.50] |
CHM vs Donepezil | ||||
Lin 2020 | 12;88 | −0.21 [−0.95,0.53] | 1.57 [0.79, 2.35] | 1.57 [0.84, 2.03] |
Miao 2012 | 12;72 | −0.17 [−0.80, 0.46] | 0.11 [−0.34, 0.56] | 0.36 [−0.48, 1.20] |
CHM vs Huperzine | ||||
Chen 2017 | 24;69 | 0.54 [−049, 1.57] | 1.72 [1.47,1.97] | 2.22 [2.03, 241] |
Sheng 2016 | 24;64 | 0.03 [−0.22, 0.28] | 2.63 [1.35,3.91] | 2.18 [1.16, 3.20] |
3. CHM + Other drugs vs Other drugs | ||||
Wang 2012 | 12;52 | 2.72 [0.32, 5.12] | 4.68 [2.17,7.19] | 2.12 [0.79, 3.45] |
Xu 2013 | 12;60 | 1.00 [−0.14, 2.14] | 1.40 [0.50,2.30] | 0.42 [0.52, 1.36] |
Wu 2017 | 8;102 | 3.94 [3.52, 4.36] | 8.15 [7.62,8.68] | 4.04 [3,48, 4.60] |