Table 1.
Author (location) | Design | Outcomes | Sample | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Shankaran et al. [6] (Seattle, WA) |
Non-randomized pilot study of an in-person or online financial education course followed by monthly contact with a financial counselor and a case manager for 6 months. | Self-reported financial burden and anxiety about costs | 34 cancer patients with nonmetastatic solid tumors | High financial burden and anxiety about costs were reported at baseline by 37% and 47% of patients, respectively [6]. |
Watabayashi et al. [11] (Seattle, WA) | Non-randomized pilot study | Baseline and 6-month follow-up reports of patient financial hardship using the Comprehensive Score for Financial Toxicity–Patient-Reported Outcomes and caregiver work and financial strain using the Caregiver Strain Index measure | 32 cancer patients and 18 primary caregivers for those patients | Financial burden and caregiver stress did not change significantly during the pilot despite the fact that participants received a mean of $772 per household (with an additional $647 for some families with non-medical expenses). |
Sadigh et al. [14] (Atlanta, GA) | Non-randomized pilot study | This study used the COST tool as a measure of financial distress at study entry and 3, 6, and 9, and 12-months and tracked the number of issues patients discussed regarding debt, disability, employment, insurance, medical decision-making and psychosocial support. | 12 brain cancer patients | At 3 months, five patients who completed a follow-up COST tool measurement showed no significant difference in scores from baseline; two of the total 12 patients completed the COST tool at 12 months, with only one-point difference from initial COST assessment. Patients discussed 12 total issues with counselors, of which 93% were resolved within 6 months, with a total of $15,110 debt relief assistance provided. |
Kircher et al. [16] (Chicago, IL) | Two-arm randomized controlled trial | Self-reported financial distress, health-related quality of life, and acceptability | 95 patients with advanced solid cancers receiving intravenous chemotherapy | No significant changes in financial distress were found between arms. Seventy-six percent of patients reported having no difficulty understanding the information, suggesting high clarity. |
Yezefski et al. [15]. (four hospitals in the United States) | Non-randomized evaluation study | Data on financial assistance and hospital revenue. Outcomes for patients included: annual counts of the number of patients receiving navigation, the amount of assistance, and the types of assistance (free medication, new insurance enrollment and benefit maximization, premium/co-pay assistance, transportation, medical equipment). | Financial navigators at 4 hospitals | Trained financial navigators saved patients $39 million in financial assistance, an average of $3.5 million per observation year [15]. Patients saved an average of $33,265 annually on medication most often through connecting patients to foundations or pharmaceutical assistance programs, $12,256 through assistance with enrollment in insurance plans, $35,294 with premium assistance paid by the hospitals, $3076 through referrals to co-pay assistance programs. |