Table 1.
Studies addressing recurrent water stresses in different crop species. For each study, the species, genotype and nature of each water stress is provided. FC, Field capacity; VWC, Volumetric Soil Water Content; SWC, Gravimetric Soil Water Content; DAS, Day After Sowing; DAP, Day After Planting.
Plant Species (Genotype (s)) |
PRIMING When? How? |
SECOND STRESS When? How? |
THIRD STRESS When? How? |
Reference |
Triticum aestivum(Winter wheat) (Luhan-7, Yuangmai-16) |
Tillering or jointing Moderate drought (55–60% FC) |
Postanthesis Severe drought (35–40% FC) |
Abid et al., 2016 [28] | |
Triticum aestivum(Winter wheat) (Luhan-7, Yuangmai-16) |
Tillering Moderate drought (58–60% FC) |
Postanthesis Severe drought (38–40% FC) |
Abid et al., 2017 [29] | |
Triticum aestivum(Winter wheat) (Yangmai-16) |
Seedling Osmopriming (PolyEthylene Glycol, PEG) |
Tillering or jointing Severe drought (35–40% FC) |
Abid et al., 2018 [30] | |
Oriza sativa(Rice) (BRS Querência, AN Cambara) |
Vegetative stage V5 10% VWC vs. 40% VWC |
Preflowering stage R1-R2 10% VWC vs. 40% VWC |
Auler et al., 2017 [31] | |
Oriza sativa(Rice) (BRS Querência, AN Cambara) |
Vegetative stage V5 10% of pot capacity, during 7 days |
Preflowering stage R1-R2 10% of pot capacity, during 7 days |
Auler et al., 2021 [32] | |
Solanum tuberosum(Potato) (JSY, CIP 706205) |
One-month old plant Decrease of 10 to 20% of SWC |
One day after priming Decrease of 10 to 20% of SWC |
Chen et al., 2020 [33] | |
Arabidopsis thaliana |
Three-weeks old plant Air drying: 2 h at 22 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 2 h at 22 °C |
22 h after second stress Air drying: 2 h at 22 °C |
Ding et al., 2012 [25] |
Zea mays(Mays) (B73) |
Two-weeks old seedling Air drying: 2 h at 22 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 2 h at 22 °C |
Ding et al., 2014 [26] | |
Coffea canephora(Cofee) (clone 120 and 109) |
9 month old plants 25% FC during 14 d |
≈ 10 days after priming 25% FC, during 14 d |
≈ 10 days after second stress 25% FC, during 14 d |
Guedes et al., 2018 [34] |
Glycine max(Soybean) (Daepoong) |
7 days old plants Water withholding during 4 days |
One day after priming Water withholding during 4 days |
Kim et al., 2020 [35] | |
Arabidopsisthaliana (Transgenic recombinant aequorin) |
Seedling Hydrogen peroxide Manitol |
6 to 7 days-old seedling Hydrogen peroxide Manitol |
Knight et al., 1998 [36] | |
Beta vulgaris(Sugar beet) (Pauletta OVK, 8GK) |
35–54 DAS Water withholding |
86–102 DAS Water withholding |
135–151 DAS Water withholding |
Leufen et al., 2016 [37] |
Oriza sativa(Rice) (Zhonghua 11) |
4-weeks old seedling Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
22 h after second Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
Li et al., 2019 [38] |
Arabidopsisthaliana (Wt, cfl mutant) |
Three-weeks old plant Air drying: 90 min at 22 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 90 min at 22 °C |
22 h after second stress Air drying: 90 min at 22 °C |
Liu et al., 2014 [39] |
Saccharum spp.(Sugarcane) (IACSP94-2094) |
55–days old plant PEG for 5 days |
3 days after priming PEG for 5 days |
3 days after second PEG, during 5 days |
Marcos et al., 2018a [40] |
Saccharum spp.(Sugarcane) (IACSP94-2094) |
6-month old plant 20% vs. 60% VWC, during 9 days |
6 days after priming 20% vs. 60% VWC, during 9 days |
6 days after second 20% vs. 60% VWC, during 9 days |
Marcos et al., 2018b [41] |
Solanum tuberosum(Potato) (Unica, Sarnav, Désirée) |
After tuber initiation or Seed tuber from previous experiment 50% FC |
55 DAP 50% FC |
Ramirez et al., 2015 [42] | |
Arabidopsisthaliana (Col-0) |
4 leaves stage 5 mM NaCl |
10 days after priming Water withholding for 2 weeks |
Sani et al., 2013 [11] | |
Arabidopsisthaliana (Col-0, abf, snrk and aba mutants) |
3-weeks old plant Air drying: 90 to 120 min at 22 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 90 to 120 min at 22 °C |
Virlouvet et Fromm, 2015 [43] | |
Zea mays(Mays) (cultivar B73) |
2-weeks old seedling Air drying: 90 min at 22 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 90 min at 22 °C |
Virlouvet et al., 2018 [18] | |
Triticum aestivum(Spring wheat) (Vinjett) |
Stem elongation (37 DAS) or Seedling (27 DAS) and Stem elongation (37 DAS) Water withholding for 8 days |
15 days after anthesis Water withholding for 8 days |
Wang et al., 2014 [44] | |
Oriza sativa(Rice) (Zhonghua 11) |
4-weeks old plant Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
22 h after priming Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
22 h after second Air drying: 80 min at 28 °C |
Yang et al., 2020 [45] |