Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 18;7(9):189. doi: 10.3390/jimaging7090189

Table 4.

Fivefold cross-validation results of the second scenario (pretrained X-ray models) using three CNN architectures—ResneXt-50, Densenet-161, and Inception-v3—and two loss functions (MSE, Huber). § Mean and STD were calculated using the average and the standard deviation of the five folds results, respectively. * the evaluation metrics were calculated using all five folds predictions. The bold is for the results of the five folds. The red, purple and blue colors are for the best performances for Mean (5 folds), STD (5 folds) and All Predictions, respectively.

Architecture Fold PC ↑ MAE ↓ RMSE ↓ PCsubj MAEsubj RMSEsubj
Fold 1 0.9453 5.24 8.77 0.9619 4.05 6.58
Fold 2 0.8569 6.68 13.39 0.9234 4.87 8.70
ResneXt-50 Fold 3 0.9083 6.17 12.53 0.9196 5.23 11.17
MSE Fold 4 0.9589 3.97 6.32 0.9884 2.31 3.22
Fold 5 0.9457 5.99 9.05 0.9674 4.92 6.43
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9230 5.61 10.01 0.9521 4.28 7.22
STD (5 folds) § 0.0371 0.9412 2.6019 0.0265 1.0577 2.6391
All Predictions * 0.9173 5.62 10.41 0.9431 4.29 7.91
Fold 1 0.9487 4.96 8.48 0.9633 3.80 6.43
Fold 2 0.8227 6.93 15.29 0.9147 4.96 9.25
ResneXt-50 Fold 3 0.9191 5.35 11.84 0.9301 4.27 10.47
Huber Fold 4 0.9622 3.70 6.09 0.9873 2.39 3.26
Fold 5 0.9507 5.50 8.80 0.9703 4.34 6.30
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9207 5.29 10.10 0.9532 3.95 7.14
STD (5 folds) § 0.0510 1.0367 3.1735 0.0267 0.8637 2.5221
All Predictions * 0.9132 5.30 10.65 0.9427 4.02 7.87
Fold 1 0.9438 5.15 8.65 0.9611 3.79 6.36
Fold 2 0.8768 6.48 12.34 0.9354 4.62 8.04
Densenet-161 Fold 3 0.9116 5.86 12.44 0.9259 4.73 10.89
MSE Fold 4 0.9576 4.11 6.65 0.9861 2.97 4.14
Fold 5 0.9479 5.79 8.99 0.9691 4.82 6.38
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9275 5.48 9.81 0.9555 4.18 7.16
STD (5 folds) § 0.0297 0.8032 2.2503 0.0220 0.7101 2.2385
All Predictions * 0.9234 5.49 10.12 0.9501 4.09 7.56
Fold 1 0.9440 4.97 8.78 0.9569 3.91 6.84
Fold 2 0.8938 6.14 11.36 0.9459 4.57 7.58
Densenet-161 Fold 3 0.9158 5.89 12.33 0.9290 4.99 10.87
Huber Fold 4 0.9643 3.67 5.93 0.9893 2.33 3.16
Fold 5 0.9526 5.48 8.71 0.9697 4.56 6.54
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9341 5.23 9.42 0.9582 4.07 7.00
STD (5 folds) § 0.0257 0.8749 2.2505 0.0205 0.9369 2.4615
All Predictions * 0.9305 5.25 9.75 0.9523 4.06 7.51
Fold 1 0.9483 5.22 8.51 0.9630 3.95 6.53
Fold 2 0.8571 6.63 13.14 0.9258 5.01 8.57
Inception-v3 Fold 3 0.9111 5.89 12.28 0.9240 5.22 10.84
MSE Fold 4 0.9605 3.91 6.22 0.9878 2.52 3.27
Fold 5 0.9463 6.10 9.22 0.9667 5.02 6.74
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9247 5.55 9.87 0.9535 4.34 7.19
STD (5 folds) § 0.0375 0.9362 2.5335 0.0248 1.0149 2.4992
All predictions 0.9163 5.90 10.57 0.9470 4.16 7.51
Fold 1 0.9526 4.81 8.43 0.9673 3.81 6.45
Fold 2 0.8905 6.17 11.64 0.9414 4.59 7.63
Inception-v3 Fold 3 0.9230 5.47 11.69 0.9324 4.75 10.41
Huber Fold 4 0.9607 3.79 6.33 0.9850 2.85 3.91
Fold 5 0.9556 5.29 8.14 0.9753 4.04 5.56
Mean (5 folds) § 0.9365 5.10 9.25 0.9603 4.01 6.79
STD (5 folds) § 0.0264 0.7896 2.1022 0.0201 0.6738 2.1786
All Predictions * 0.9330 5.34 9.44 0.9558 3.98 6.87