Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 8;11(9):894. doi: 10.3390/jpm11090894

Table 1.

Characteristics of the reviewed studies (n = 17).

Authors (Year) Location Study Design Sample Characteristics N Age = M (SD) Parental Involvement Intervention Setting Length/Frequency Instruments Relevant Findings
Aandersson et al. (2017) [39] Sweden Qualitative study 56 Parents of Children with ASD (n = 56 Children; Mage ≈ 9 Years, Female = 23.21%) Indirect Early Intervention, ABA Clinics 2 Years/25 h/Week Semi-Structured Questionnaire Thematic Content Analysis
Too much responsivity and lack of knowledge about intervention methods. Perceived support as unequal, uncoordinated, and with variations. Unequal treatments depending on socioeconomic status. lack of individualization of interventions.
Baghdadli et al. (2014) [10] France Cross-Sectional 152 Mothers (92.12%) and 13 Fathers of Adolescents with ASD (n = 152 Adolescents; Mage = 15 Years; SD = 1.6, Female = 17.8%) None Mixed Clinics NA/31.3 5 h/week Par-DD-QoL Polytomic Logistic Regression Analysis
A higher number of hours of specialized intervention is associated with lower parental emotional QoL (ORa = 2.69, 95% CI = 1.1–5.9, p = 0.04).
Derguy et al. (2018) [40] France Cross-Sectional 115 Parents (Female = 63.5%) of Children with ASD (n = 78 Children; Mage = 6.3, SD = 2.3, Female = 23.1%) None Psycho-Educational Intervention (74% of the Sample) NA NA WHOQOL-BREF Hierarchical Regression Analyses
Parents showed better QoL whether their child received psychoeducation intervention (β = 0.25, p = 0.010).
Due et al. (2018) [41] Australia Mixed-Method Study 27 Parents (Female = 48.14%) of Children with ASD (n = 27 Children; Mage = 5, SD = 2.0, Female = 18.52%) Direct Early intervention Clinics NA Quality of Life in Autism Questionnaire; Semi-Structured Interviews Thematic Content Analysis
Parental direct involvement in the intervention increased several aspects of their QoL (e.g., sense of competence and confidence as parents, community participation).
Hwang et al. (2015) [42] Taiwan Pre-Post Design 6 Mother-Child dyads (Children with ASD; Age Range = 8–15 Years, Female = 20%) Direct Parent-Mediated Home-Based Training Home 12 Months Family Quality of Life (FQoL) Paired Sample Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test
The parent-mediated home-based training was associated with marginally significant increase in family quality of life.
Ji et al. (2014) [43] China Quasi-Experimental Design 22 Caregivers (Female = 90.9%) of Children with ASD (Intervention Group, n = 22 Children with ADS; Mage = 4.93, SD = 2.03, Female = 18.2%) and 20 Caregivers (Female = 90.0%) of Children with ASD (control group, n = 20 Children with ASD, Mage = 5.65, SD = 1.74, Female = 15%) Direct Parent Education Program Clinics 8 Weeks Caregiver Burden Index (CBI) Independent-Samples t-test
Parents’ mental HRQOL significantly improved after the intervention (t = −2.138; p = 0.039). Parents’ physical HRQOL did not improve after the intervention (t = −1463; p = 0.151).
Jones et al. (2017) [44] Canada Cross-Sectional 151 Caregivers (Female = 78.95%) of children with ASD (n = 151 Children with ASD; Mage = 7.3, SD = 3.9, Female = 23.84%) Indirect None/Intensive Behavioural Intervention, Intervention from a Speech and Language Pathologist, Occupational Therapy, Physiotherapy Services NA NA Family Quality of Life Survey (FQOLS) Correlation Analyses
Time on waiting list was not significatively associated with family QoL.
Leadbitter et al. (2018) [45] United Kingdom Pre-Trial Research Design 152 Parents of Children with ASD (n = 152 Children with ASD, Mage = 45 Months, Female = 9.21%) Direct Parent-Mediated Video-Aided Pre-School Communication-Focused Intervention Clinics 13 Months Autism Family Experience Questionnaire (AFEQ) Effect Estimation Analysis
AFEQ total score improved significantly after the treatment and at the 6-year follow-up.
Leadbitter et al. (2020) [46] United Kingdom Qualitative Study 18 Parents (Female = 66.67%) of Children with ASD (n = 12 Children with ASD, Mage = 44.42 Months, SD = 7.04, Female = 8.33%) Direct Paediatric Autism Communication Therapy NA 12 Months Semi-Structured Interview Thematic Content Analysis
Post-intervention improved family wellbeing.
Mathew et al. (2019) [47] Australia Cross-Sectional 161 Parents (Female = 90.7%) of Children with ASD (n = 117 Children with ASD, Mage = 4.13, SD = 0.53, Female = 17.9%) Direct Early Intervention using the Early Start Denver Model Clinics NA Parenting Sense of Competence Scale (PSOC) Independent-Samples t-test
Significantly greater levels of depression symptoms, anxiety, and stress among mothers (who have the primary caregiver role) than among fathers of children with ASD.
McConkey (2020) [48] United Kingdom Validation Study 449 Parents (Female = 92.6%) of Children with ASD or with Suspected ASD (n = 449 Children with ASD, Age Range = 2–11 years, Female = 25.6%) Direct Family-Centred Intervention Home Median = 8 Weeks Eight Items Questionnaire Step-Wise, Linear Regression
Parental with adequate or poor engagement in intervention showed significantly lower parental well-being than those with good engagement in intervention (β = 4.72; SE 1.54; p < 0.002).
McConkey et al. (2020) [49] United Kingdom Observational Study 92 Families with Children with ASD (n = 96 Children, Mage = 7.7, Female = 20.8%) Direct Post-Diagnostic Support Home 12 Months Two Rating Scales Thematic Content Analysis
Parents reported higher self-confidence and reduced stress within the family after the intervention.
McPhilemy & Dillenburger (2013) [50] United Kingdom Observational Study 15 Families with Children or Adolescents with ASD (n = 17 Children or Adolescents with ASD, Mage= 38 Months, Age Range = 2–20 Years, Female = 11.76%) Direct ABA-based Home Program Home M = 48 Months Questionnaire Thematic Content Analysis
ABA-based home program had significant positive impact on family quality of life.
Milbourn et al. (2017) [51] Australia/Sweden Observational/Qualitative Study 521 Caregivers (Female = 81%) with Children with ASD (n = 400 Children with ASD (76.78%), Mage = 9.92, SD = 4.17, Female = 17%) Direct Mixed NA NA Multidimensional Questionnaire Thematic Content Analysis
Respondents indicated that early interventions improved their family life (71.3% answered “somewhat” or “definitely”). Respondents agreed that earlier access to intervention would have led to improved child’s quality of life (78.4% answered “somewhat” or “definitely”).
Moody et al. (2019) [52] United States Randomised Controlled Trial 67 Parents (Active Group, Female = 91.0%; Waitlist, Female = 88.2%) of Children with ASD (n = 33 Intervention Group, Female = 18.2%) (n = 67 Children with ASD, Range age 2–8 Years, Female = 14.7%) Direct Colorado Parent Mentoring (CPM) Program Mixed Six Months Family Quality of Life Survey (FQOLS) Mixed Modelling
CPM program positively impacted several areas of family quality of life, regardless the amount of formal intervention received.
Paynter et al. (2018) [53] Australia Mixed Methods 26 Fathers of Children with ASD (n = 26 Children with ASD, Age Range 2.5–6 Years, Female = 26.4%) Indirect Early Intervention Clinics NA Parenting Stress Index (PSI) Thematic Content Analysis
According to some fathers’ family adaptation was negatively affected by inaccessible and/or gender-biased formal supports.
Roberts et al. (2011) [54] Australia Randomised Controlled Trial 84 Children with ASD (n = 27 Home-Based Group, n = 29 Centre-Based Group, n = 28 Control, Mage = 3.5, SD = 0.61, Female = 9.5%) Direct and Indirect Early Intervention (Home-based Intervention vs. Centre-Based Intervention) Home vs. Clinical Centres 1 Year (40 Weeks) Family Quality of Life Survey (FQOLS), Parenting Stress Index (PSI) Analysis of Covariance
Parents of children who followed the centre-based intervention showed significant improvements in family QoL. Parents of children who followed the home-based intervention showed the least improvement in family QoL over all groups.