Table 1.
References | n | Etiology | Clinical characteristics* | BoNT trial (n) | Percent of cases reporting BoNT response** |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Blitzer et al. (23) | 20 | NR+ | NR | Yes (20) | 95% |
Jankovic et al. (24) | 62 | NR | JC (NR), JO (NR) | Yes (62) | 73% |
Hermanowicz and Truong (25) | 5 | NR | JO (20%), JC (80%), L (20%) | Yes (5) | 100% |
Van den Bergh et al. (26) | 5 | NR | JO (80%), L (20%) | Yes (5) | 100% |
Sankhla et al. (27) | 21 | NR | NR | Yes (21) | 68% |
Tan and Jankovic (28) | 162 | Idiopathic (63%), Tardive (23%), Other (14%) | JO (22%), JC (53%), M (24%) | Yes (162) | 68% |
Tan and Jankovic (16) | 116 | Idiopathic (79%) Tardive (21%) |
JO (23%), JC (49%), M (28%), L (20%) | Yes (116) | 100% |
Bhattacharyya et al. (29) | 5 | NR | NR | Yes (5) | 100% |
Adler et al. (30) | 5 | Idiopathic (100%) | JO (40%), JC (40%), M (20%) | Yes (5) | NR |
Lo et al. (31) | 5 | Post-stroke (100%) | JC (100%) | Yes (5) | 33% |
Wan et al. (32) | 12 | NR | NR | Yes (12) | 88% |
Singer and Papapetropoulos (33) | 23 | NR | JO (52%), JC (48%) | Yes (23) | 65% |
Lee (34) | 6 | NR | JC (50%), L (50%), P (67%) | Yes (2) | 100% |
Rosales et al. (9) | 49 | X-linked dystonia-parkinsonism | JO (65%), JC (24%), M (12%) | Yes (49) | 100% |
Merz et al. (35) | 30 | Idiopathic (83%)Other (17%) | JO (10%), JC (23%), M (33%), L (10%) | Yes (30) | 100% |
Esper et al. (8) | 17 | Idiopathic (47%) Tardive (41%) Degenerative (6%) Post-infectious (6%) |
JO (53%), JC (18%), M (18%), L (100%) | Yes (9) | 78% |
Teive et al. (36) | 5 | Wilson's disease (100%) | JO (100%) | Yes (5) | 100% |
Sinclair et al. (37) | 59 | Idiopathic (91%)Tardive (9%) | JO (36%), JC (48%) M (16%), L (17%) | Yes (59) | 100% |
Bakke et al. (38) | 21 | NR | JO (19%), JC (5%), M (43%) | N R | NR |
Termsarasab et al. (14) | 41 | Idiopathic (100%) | M (63%), L (27%), P (5%) | Yes (18) | 12% |
Moscovich et al. (39) | 8 | NR | M (100%) | Yes (8) | 100% |
Teemul et al. (40) | 6 | Idiopathic (83%) Tardive (17%) |
M (100%) | Yes (6) | 83% |
Nastasi et al. (41) | 30 | Idiopathic (73%) Tardive (13%) |
JO (53%), JC (17%), M (7%), L (100%), P (27%) | Yes (30) | 87% |
Kreisler et al. (42) | 14 | NR | JO (21%), JC (36%), M (7%), P (29%) | Yes (7) | (All returned for repeat injections) |
Slaim et al. (43) | 240 | Idiopathic (71%) Tardive (13%) Other (16%) |
JO (62%), JC (20%), M (27%), L (27%) | No | NR |
Scorr et al. (11) | 18 | Idiopathic (83%) Tardive (17%) |
JO (50%), JC (17%), M (33%), L (33%), | Yes (18) | 100% |
Yoshida (12) | 136 | Tardive (31%) | M (20%), L (100%) | Yes (136) | NR |
Jaw Opening (JO), Jaw Closing (JC), Mixed Jaw Phenomenology (M), Lingual (L), Perioral (P).
Not reported (NR).
Percentage does not indicate level of therapeutic effect, but percentage of cases reporting some therapeutic effect.