Table 1.
Non-surgical models of sepsis | Surgical models of sepsis | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bacteria or endotoxin (LPS) injection | Cecal slurry (CS) injection | Cecal Ligation and Puncture (CLP) | Bacteria and fibrin clot implantation | Colon Ascendens Stent Peritonitis (CASP) | |
Description | Intraperitoneal or intravenously injection of bacteria or purified LPS | Intraperitoneal injection of cecal contents from a donor | Ligation of a portion of the cecum followed by cecal colostomies via one or more needle punctures | Standardized amounts of bacteria into fibrin clots, implanted into the peritoneal cavity | Insertion of a stent into the ascending colon to allow the stool to continuous flow from the colon into the peritoneal cavity |
Pros | - Easy procedure - Replicates the physiology of severe sepsis - Highly reproducible - Dose of bacteria or endotoxin can be standardized |
- High reproducibility - No surgical tissue trauma or ischemic tissue - Advantageous in experiments that require large number of animals - Can be performed in neonatal animals with less risk of being neglected by the mother - Standardized polymicrobial inoculum (fix weight-based intraperitoneal fecal injection) |
- Easy procedure - Partly reflects human disease - Extensively studied - Sepsis severity can be adjusted based upon the length of the cecum ligated and the size and number of punctures performed - Better to study peritoneal abscess formation, local inflammation and infiltration |
- Fibrin delays systemic infection - Replicates features of sepsis in humans - Low early mortality - Highly reproducible |
- Mimic human sepsis better than CLP - Better to study bacteremia, SIRS and sepsis - Sepsis severity can be adjusted altering the size of the catheter |
Cons | - Transient inflammatory response - Intoxication model (septic shock) - Host response limited to gram negative organisms (LPS) or bacteria injected |
- High variability (lethality of the cecal preparation varies between donor batches) | - Surgical trauma - Time consuming - Bacterial dissemination in the peritoneum (more localized inflammation) - High variability - Impossible to control rate and amount of fecal material released |
- Surgical trauma - The use of a single organism in the fibrin clot does not have clinical relevance |
- Time consuming - Low characterized - High variability |