Table 1.
Nasal and sinonasal tumors
Studies | Study type | Study period (years) | n | Technique | PhT | PCT (%) | OF (%) | Morphology | Observation median (months) | Results | Toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Resto et al. [39] | Retro | 1991-2002 | 102 | PSPT | 4 | 100 | Different | 61 | 5-year: LC - 95, 82, and 87%; OS - 90, 53, and 49% in groups R0, R1, and biopsy | Not evaluated | |
Russo etal. [71] | Retro | 1991-2008 | 54 | PSPT | - | 39 | 69 | HNSCC | 82 | 5-year: LRC - 73%; OS - 47% | Stage III — in 9; IV — in 6 |
Nakamura et al. [72] | Retro | 1999-2012 | 42 | PSPT | - | 26 | 0 | Esthesioneuroblastoma | 69 | 5-year OS/PFS: 100/80% — group A; 86/65% — group B; 76/39% — group C | Stage lll-IV — in 6: visual loop — 4; liquorrhea — 1; cataract — 1 |
Takagi et al. [73] | Retro | 2002-2012 | 40 | PSPT | 0 | 0 | Adenocarcinoma | 38 | 5-year: OS - 63%; PFS - 30%; LC - 76% | Stage lll-V — in 36 (26%): III — in 24 (osteonecroses); IV — in 9 (vision loss); V — in 3 (radiation ulcers) | |
Demizu etal. [41] | Retro | 2003-2011 | 33 | PSPT | - | 0 | 0 | Melanoma | 18 | 2-year: LC-71%; OS-44% | Stage lll-IV — in 3: cataract, mucositis, and pain |
Linton et al. [74] | Retro | 2004-2012 | 26 | PSPT | 0 | 77 | Adenocarcinoma | 25 | 2-year: LC - 95%; OS - 93% (without previous radiation) | Late toxicity, stage III — in 2; IV — in 1; V — in 1 (after a repeated course) | |
Fuji et al. [42] | Retro | 2006-2012 | 20 | PSPT | - | 0 | 0 | Melanoma | 35 | 3-year: OS - 68%; PFS - 60% | Stage IV — in 1 (visual loop) |
Dagan et al. [75] | Retro | 2007-2013 | 84 | PSPT | 75 | 74 | Different | 32 | 3-year: LC — 83%; no metastases — 72%; OS - 68% | Stage lll-V (24%): cerebral necrosis — in 1; osteonecrosis/soft tissue necrosis — in 7; 3 fatal cases | |
Zenda et al. [43] | Pro | 2008-2012 | 32 | PSPT | - | 0 | 0 | Melanoma | 36 | 1-year: LC-76%; 3-year: OS - 46%; PFS - 36% | Stage >lll — none |
McDonald et al. [40] | Retro | 2010-2014 | 40 | PSPT | + | 75 | — | Different | — | — | In IMRT, tubes and narcotics were more frequently used |
Patel et al. [44] | Retro | 1975-2013 | 286 | PSPT/ C-ions | + | — | — | Different | 38 | OS >5 years in hadron therapy group (p=0.0038) and in higher observation median (p=0.037), the same as PFS (p=0.0003) |