Table 2.
The key features of included RCTs and main findings of the studies (n = 32).
| Study | Age (years)/grade | Intervention type | Intervention duration | Length of follow-up | Outcome | Effect on outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nemet et al. | 5 years | PA and diet | One year | One and two years | BMI and percentile of BMI | Positive results |
| Bonsergent et al. | 10th to 11th grades | PA and diet | Two years | Two years | BMI Z score, BMI, obesity, or overweight | Mixed results |
| Cunha et al. | 5th grades | Dietary intervention only | Nine months | Nine months | BMI, body fat percentage, and obesity | Mixed results |
| Dewar et al. | 12 to 14 years | PA and diet | One year | One year | BMI, body fat percentage, and z score of BMI | Mixed results |
| Fairclough et al. | 10 to 11 years | PA and diet | Twenty weeks | Thirty weeks | BMI, Z score for BMI, and waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Meng et al. | Six to thirteen years | PA and diet | One year | One year | BMI, Z score for BMI, obesity, or overweight | Mixed results |
| Safdie et al. | 4 to 5 years | PA and diet | Eighteen months | Eighteen months | BMI, obesity, or overweight | Mixed results |
| Rappaport et al. | 5 to 12 years | Dietary intervention only | Seventeen months | Twenty-nine months | Z score for BMI and obesity, or overweight | No difference between two groups |
| Rausch Herscovici et al. | 9 to 11 years | PA and diet | Six months | Six months | Z score for BMI and BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Annesi et al. | 4 to 5 years | PA | Nine months | Nine months | BMI | Positive results |
| Annesi et al. | 4 to 5 years | PA | Nine months | Nine months | BMI | Positive results |
| Fitzgibbon et al. | 3 to 5 years | PA and diet | Fourteen weeks | One year | BMI and Z score of BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Kain et al. | 6 to 8 years | PA and diet | One year | One year | BMI Z score | Positive results |
| Martínez-Vizcaíno et al. | Eight to ten years | PA | Nine months | Nine months | BMI, obesity, body fat percentage, and waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Santos et al. | 6 to 12 years | PA and diet | Ten months | Ten months | Z score of BMI, waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Simon et al. | Six grades | PA only | Four years | Six and half years | Z score for BMI and waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Tarro et al. | 2nd grade | PA and diet | Twenty-eight months | Twenty-eight months | BMI, Z score for BMI obesity or overweight, and waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Llaurado et al. | Seven to eight years | PA and diet | Twenty-two months | Twenty-two months | Z score for BMI and obesity or overweight | No difference between two groups |
| Lubnas et al. | 12 to 14 years | PA | Twenty weeks | 8 months | BMI, Z score for BMI and percentage of body weight | No difference between two groups |
| Meyer et al. | One grade | PA | Nine months | Nine months and three years | BMI, skinfold thickness, and waist circumference | No difference between two groups |
| Xu et al. | Four school grades | PA and diet | Ten months | Ten months | BMI and obesity or overweight | No difference between two groups |
| Elder et al. | 5 to 8 years | PA and diet | Two years | Two years | BMI, Z score for BMI, waist circumference, and percentage of body weight | No difference between two groups |
| Cao et al. | One grade | PA and diet | Three years | Three years | BMI Z score, BMI, obesity, or overweight | Mixed results |
| Greve et al. | 5 to 17 years | Other | Three years | Two years | BMI, obesity, or overweight | No difference between two groups |
| Fulkerson et al. | 8 to 12 years | PA and diet | One year | One year and twenty-one months | Z score for BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Llargués et al. | 5 to 6 years | PA and diet | Two years | Six years | BMI | Positive results |
| Leme et al. | 14 to 18 years | PA and diet | Six months | Six months | BMI, Z score for BMI, and waist circumference | Mixed results |
| Bogart et al. | Grade seven | PA and diet | Five weeks | Two years | Percentile of BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Natale et al. | 2 to 5 years | PA and diet | Two years | Two years | Percentile of BMI | Positive results |
| Kong et al. | 3 to 5 years | PA and diet | Fourteen weeks | Sixteen months | BMI and Z score of BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Hull et al. | 5 to 7 years | PA and diet | One year | Six and sixteen months | Z score for BMI and BMI | No difference between two groups |
| Annesi et al. | 9 to 12 years | PA and diet | Nine months | Nine months | BMI | Positive results |