Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 14;6(9):704–715. doi: 10.1302/2058-5241.6.200136

Table 7.

Breakdown of treatment success rate according to various different surgical management strategies

Treatment method Study Success rate (%) Total number of patients
Debridement + Exfix/ORIF + systemic antibiotic therapy Khan 2012 100.0 20
Emara 2002 95.0 20
Total 2 studies 97.5 40
Debridement + muscle flap/fasciocutaneous flap + systemic antibiotic therapy Zweiffel-Schlatter 200656 100.0 14
Lê Thua 201535 96.6 29
Smith 200651 95.00 41
Fitzgerald 198526 92.9 42
Total 4 studies 95.2 126
Debridement + bone graft + systemic antibiotic therapy Huang 201828 95.0 80
Chan 200020 82.0 50
Total 2 studies 90.0 130
Debridement + local antibiotic delivery + systemic antibiotic therapy Chan 199819 94.4 36
Li 201936 94.4 18
Ferrando 201725 92.3 13
Romanò 201445 87.7 49
Lindfors 201738 72.0 18
Lidgren 198037 88.9 18
Chan 200020 95.7 46
Zhou 202055 88.4 43
Wang 201753 86.7 15
Pape 199543 84.4 26
Chang 200721 80.0 25
Kinik 200832 88.5 26
McNally 201641 96.0 100
Ferguson 201424 90.8 195
Hashmi 200427 94.1 17
Yamashita 199854 100.0 18
McNally 199340 91.9 37
Total 17 studies 90.9 700
Debridement + hyperbaric oxygen therapy + systemic antibiotic therapy Chen 200410 92.3 13
Total 1 study 92.3 13
Debridement + bioactive glass + systemic antibiotic therapy Romanò 201445 92.6 27
Lindfors 201738 95.9 98
Ferrando 201725 91.7 12
Total 3 studies 94.9 137
Debridement+ systemic antibiotic therapy Euba 200923 90.0 50
Meissner 198942 76.7 60
Chang 200721 60.0 40
Simpson 200150 72.0 50
Jiang 201529 77.4 394
Total 5 studies 76.8 594

Note. Exfix, external fixation; ORIF, open reduction and internal fixation.