Table 1.
Studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis (N = 6)
First author (year), country |
Study design |
N | Recruitment | Participants | Sex | Exposure variable |
Outcome measures |
Number of outcome events/ cases | Comparison |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. Walia (2012), USA | Retrospective chart review | 1275 | Clinic | Employed patients | Men and women combined | Fixed shift work and rotating shift work | PSG | day shift work: 474; fixed and rotating shift work: 216 | AHI ≥ 15 |
2. Yazdi (2014), Iran | Cross-sectional study | 470 | Workplace | Workers in textile factory | Men only | Shift work | Berlin questionnaire | Non-shift workers: 204; shift workers:210 | Berlin questionnaire ≥ 2 categories positive |
3. Soylu (2014), Turkey | Cross-sectional study | 257 | Workplace | Nurses and resident doctors | Men and women combined | Shift working | PSG | Non-shift working: 1; shift working: 11 | AHI ≥ 5 |
4. Seyedmehdi (2016), Iran | Cross-sectional study | 715 | Workplace | Hospital staff | Men and women combined | Night shift | Berlin questionnaire | Day shift: 25; night shift: 24 | Berlin questionnaire ≥ 2 categories positive |
5. Motlagh (2017), Iran | Cross-sectional study | 934 | Workplace | Professional drivers | Men only | Evening and night shift work | Stop BANG questionnaire | NR | Stop BANG ≥ 3 items positive |
6. Guclu (2019), Turkey | Cross-sectional study | 604 | Workplace | Healthcare workers | Men and women combined | On-call shift | Berlin questionnaire | Day shift: 30; on-call shift: 62 | Berlin questionnaire ≥ 2 categories positive |
AHI Apnea–Hypopnea Index, PSG Polysomnography, NR not reported