Skip to main content
The Journal of Nutrition logoLink to The Journal of Nutrition
letter
. 2021 Aug 7;151(8):2496–2497. doi: 10.1093/jn/nxab213

Overestimated Impact of Lower-Carbohydrate Diets on Total Energy Expenditure

Stephan J Guyenet 1,✉, Kevin D Hall 2
PMCID: PMC8491863  PMID: 34363484

Dear Editor:

Ludwig et al. (1) report that total energy expenditure (TEE) is greater during isocaloric lower-carbohydrate diets lasting >17 days. However, the reported effect size of 135 kcal/d is likely overestimated, because the TEE differences extracted from several longer-term studies are not the most defensible values. Our reanalysis of the longer-term controlled feeding studies confirms that the TEE effect of lower-carbohydrate diets is statistically significant, but its ∼63–74 kcal/d magnitude is smaller than that estimated by Ludwig et al. (1), amounting to an energy equivalent of less than an apple per day.

Of the 6 trials included in the >17-day analysis, 3 used the doubly labeled water (DLW) method that estimates TEE via the average daily rate of CO2 production (2–4). Indirect calorimetry equations for calculating TEE additionally require the average daily respiratory quotient (RQ). Inaccurate assumptions about diet differences in RQ can lead to erroneous DLW estimates of TEE differences (5, 6). In contrast, respiratory chamber measurements of TEE avoid this potential source of error.

Ludwig at al. (1) used DLW measurements from Hall et al. (2) rather than using respiratory chamber data. This is particularly concerning since the DLW measurements were shown to be an overestimate, in part because of inaccurate assumptions about RQ (5). Therefore, we used the final respiratory chamber measurements during each diet period in Hall et al. (2), which suggest that the TEE on the lower-carbohydrate diet was greater by (mean ± SEM) 60 ± 29 kcal/d when adjusted for body weight changes; the unadjusted TEE difference is 24 ± 28 kcal/d.

Our concern about the validity of RQ assumptions in DLW calculations also extends to the 2 TEE estimates from studies by Ebbeling et al. (3, 4), neither of which measured daily RQ. For Ebbeling et al. (4), the assumed RQ difference between the high- and low-carbohydrate diets was 0.11, which we believe is unrealistic because it corresponds to the calculated food quotients of the study diets, and therefore assumes perfect diet adherence. However, an average of ∼460 kcal/d less study food was provided than reported the TEE in weight-stable subjects (4). Similarly, the other trial by Ebbeling et al. (3) indicated a several hundred kcal/d discrepancy between the food provided and the measured TEE. Thus, a substantial amount of off-study food must have been consumed, and it is unlikely that the compositions of the off-study food matched those of the provided diets.

The RQ difference between the high- and low-carbohydrate diets in Ebbeling et al. (4) is likely to have been ∼0.07, which corresponds to the RQ differences adjusted for energy balance in an inpatient controlled feeding trial (5), using diets that differed in their carbohydrate-to-fat ratio by slightly more than the study diets used in Ebbeling et al. With these more plausible RQ values, the calculated effect size for Ebbeling et al. declines from 209 ± 58 kcal/d to 104 ± 59 kcal/d. A reanalysis of the other trial by Ebbeling et al. (3) has not been performed because insufficient information has been published to make this adjustment, so we use its original value of 126 ± 72 kcal/d with the understanding that it is probably an overestimate.

An additional concern is the TEE estimate extracted from Rumpler et al. (7), which did not use the data point at the longest diet duration. A between-group difference in the TEE of 30 ± 247 kcal/d is obtained using data from day 35, which is more plausible than the 285 kcal/d effect size used by Ludwig et al. (1) (day 28), given the modest between-group difference in diet composition (66% compared with 46% carbohydrate) and the observation that the total body energy content did not significantly diverge between groups over the course of the experiment.

Using these updated values, we used a random-effects meta-analysis to pool trials according to duration cutoffs of >7, >14, >17, and >21 days. There is no detectable difference in the TEE at >7 days, with high heterogeneity (13 kcal/d; 95% CI, −46 to 73; P = 0.66; I2 = 71%). At >14 days, the TEE is slightly but significantly greater in the lower-carbohydrate group, with no heterogeneity (63 kcal/d; 95% CI, 24–102; P = 0.002; I2 = 0%). Findings are similar for cutoffs of >17 days and >21 days (within 11 kcal/d; P < 0.01; I2 = 0%). Assuming a 24-hour RQ difference of 0.09 for Ebbeling et al., which we believe is the upper bound of plausibility, yields a pooled >14-day estimate of 70 kcal/d (95% CI, 20–119; P = 0.006; I2 = 24%).

This updated estimate is consistent with the findings of a long-term inpatient controlled feeding trial, in which wide variation in the fat and carbohydrate content of the diet did not measurably impact the energy intake required for weight maintenance (8).

Ludwig et al. (1) interpret their findings as evidence that low-carbohydrate diets initially result in reduced TEE that subsequently increases after a 2- to 3-week period of physiological adaptation. While this is consistent with the pooled analysis, it is notable that the only trial to measure TEE changes in both the early and late periods found that the small increase in TEE during the low-carbohydrate diet occurred within the first week and waned over time, consistent with increased energy costs of gluconeogenesis and the efficiency of hepatic ketogenesis (2). More research is needed to understand the mechanisms by which diet composition influences TEE and its time course.

Acknowledgments

The authors’ responsibilities were as follows – both authors: conducted the analysis, drafted and edited the manuscript, and read and approved the final manuscript.

Notes

The authors reported no funding received for this study.

Author disclosures: SJG has received revenue from a weight management program (the Ideal Weight Program) and has engaged in public debate with David Ludwig. KDH has received research funding from the Nutrition Science Initiative (NuSI) and has engaged in public debate with David Ludwig.

Abbreviations used: DLW, doubly labeled water; RQ, respiratory quotient; TEE, total energy expenditure.

Contributor Information

Stephan J Guyenet, Unaffiliated.

Kevin D Hall, Intramural Research Program, Integrative Physiology Section, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, Bethesda, MA, USA.

References

  • 1.Ludwig DS, Dickinson SL, Henschel B, Ebbeling CB, Allison DB. Do lower-carbohydrate diets increase total energy expenditure? An updated and reanalyzed meta-analysis of 29 controlled-feeding studies. J Nutr. 2021;151(3):482–90. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 2.Hall KD, Chen KY, Guo J, Lam YY, Leibel RL, Mayer LE, Reitman ML, Rosenbaum M, Smith SR, Walsh BTet al. Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016;104(2):324–33. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 3.Ebbeling CB, Swain JF, Feldman HA, Wong WW, Hachey DL, Garcia-Lago E, Ludwig DS. Effects of dietary composition on energy expenditure during weight-loss maintenance. JAMA. 2012;307(24):2627–34. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 4.Ebbeling CB, Feldman HA, Klein GL, Wong JMW, Bielak L, Steltz SK, Luoto PK, Wolfe RR, Wong WW, Ludwig DS. Effects of a low carbohydrate diet on energy expenditure during weight loss maintenance: Randomized trial. BMJ. 2018;363:k4583. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 5.Hall KD, Guo J, Chen KY, Leibel RL, Reitman ML, Rosenbaum M, Smith SR, Ravussin E. Methodologic considerations for measuring energy expenditure differences between diets varying in carbohydrate using the doubly labeled water method. Am J Clin Nutr. 2019;109(5):1328–34. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 6.Hall KD, Guo J, Speakman JR. Do low-carbohydrate diets increase energy expenditure?. Int J Obes. 2019;43(12):2350–4. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 7.Rumpler WV, Seale JL, Miles CW, Bodwell CE. Energy-intake restriction and diet-composition effects on energy expenditure in men. Am J Clin Nutr. 1991;53(2):430–6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8.Leibel RL, Hirsch J, Appel BE, Checani GC. Energy intake required to maintain body weight is not affected by wide variation in diet composition. Am J Clin Nutr. 1992;55(2):350–5. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

Articles from The Journal of Nutrition are provided here courtesy of American Society for Nutrition

RESOURCES