Table 2.
Studies presenting indirect evidence on the association between executive functions and multiple-text comprehension.
Study |
Participants (n and school-level) |
Executive function | Multiple-text comprehension | Association |
---|---|---|---|---|
Banas and Sanchez (2012) | n = 62 (undergraduates) | Working memory (Automated operation span task) | Reading a website organized in a hierarchical tree structure + search questions + tree structure task (correct placement or matched terms) | Partial |
Brand-Gruwel et al. (2009) | Study 1: n = 10 (5 PhD students and 5 undergraduates) Study 2: n = 15 (undergraduates) Study 3: n = 23 (secondary school, grade 9) |
Think-aloud (Regulation) | Answering questions with information found on the Web + Think-aloud (time, frequency and sequencing of sub-skills) | Yes |
Bråten and Ferguson (2014) | n = 120 (high school, grade 10) | Working memory (Span task) | Epistemic belief questionnaire | Yes |
Bråten and Strømsø (2003) | n = 7 (undergraduates) | Think-aloud (Strategic processing) | Reading one self-selected text to be integrated with other personal sourcers + think-aloud (frequency of strategies) | Yes |
Hilbert and Renkl (2008) | n = 38 (undergraduates) | Intelligence; Think-aloud (regulation) | Reading 6 documents and concept-mapping + learning questions (correctness and knowledge increase) + think-aloud | Partial |
Isberner et al. (2013) | n = 77 (undergraduates) | Working memory (Reading span) | Reading two texts + sentence verification task + recognition task + plausibility judgment. | Yes |
Moehring et al. (2016) | Study 1: n = 120 adults Study 2: n = 171 (high school) |
Fluid intelligence (Fluid reasoning scale) | Computerized digital literacy test | Yes |
Sharit et al. (2015) | n = 60 (adults) | Working memory (Alphabetic span); reasoning (inference test); processing speed (digit symbol substitution); executive function (trail making test) | Using the Internet to answer questions (Search time; number of websites visited; switches between websites; search accuracy) | Partial |