Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 11;2021(10):CD010849. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010849.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Alhamdan 2007 Participants: couples planning to marry and applying for marriage licence
Intervention: premarital screening programme for sickle cell and beta‐thalassemia
Comparator: none
Outcome: number confirmed sickle cell and beta thalassemia carriers, decision for marriage
Design: observational, cross‐sectional study
Excluded due to non‐RCT design
Archibald 2017 Participants: woman prior to pregnancy or early in pregnancy (recommended ≤ 12 weeks gestation)
Intervention: simultaneous genetic carrier testing for CF, FXS and SMA
Comparator: none
Outcome: number of carriers for CF, FXS and SMA
Design: observational, cross‐sectional
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Bekker 1993 Participants: adults 18 ‐ 45 years
Intervention: genetic carrier testing for cystic fibrosis
Comparator: none
Outcome: anxiety
Design: observational, before and after intervention study
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Castellani 2011 Participants: infertile couples undergoing cystic fibrosis screening as part of assisted reproduction process
Intervention: genetic counselling via computer program
Comparator: standard care genetic counselling session
Outcome: knowledge
Design: RCT
Excluded because intervention was method of delivering genetic counselling and not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening compared to standard care
Cheuvront 1998 Participants: relatives of people with CF
Intervention: home‐based pretest education from pamphlet with genetic test
Comparator: clinic based pretest education via genetic counselling with genetic test
Outcome: anxiety, knowledge, satisfaction, reproductive intent
Design: RCT
Excluded because intervention was method of delivering genetic counselling and not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening compared to standard care
Childs 1976 Participants: carriers of Tay‐Sachs disease identified prospectively or retrospectively during population screening
Intervention: genetic carrier population screening
Comparator: none
Outcomes: knowledge, attitudes, anxiety, concerns, satisfaction
Design: observational, cross‐sectional
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Clayton 1996 Participants: non‐pregnant adults visiting clinical and non‐clinical sites
Intervention: genetic carrier testing for CF
Comparator: none
Outcome: attitudes, beliefs
Design: observational, before and after intervention design
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Fan 2018 Participants: adults > 18 years old with no known carriers status
Intervention: educational online module for carrier screening for Tay Sach disease
Comparator: in person genetic counselling
Outcome: post‐interventional genetics knowledge, perception of genetic risk score and anxiety score
Design: RCT
Excluded due intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening and participants are not known carrier status
Fisher 1981 Participants: adults carriers of beta‐thalassaemia 18 ‐ 65 years in a HMO
Intervention: genetic counselling through video
Comparator: conventional counselling by a trained physician
Outcome: knowledge, sexual activity, mood change, behaviour, anxiety
Design: RCT
Excluded because the intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening 
Hegwer 2006 Participants: adults of Ashkenazi Jewish background in prenatal and preconception settings
Intervention: genetic carrier screening and education programme for Tay‐Sachs disease
Comparator: none
Outcome: knowledge, concern, attitudes, perceptions of genetic risk
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Henneman 2001 Participants: adults aged 20 ‐ 35 years invited through Municipal Health Service or General Practitioner
Intervention: genetic carrier screening for cystic fibrosis
Comparator: none
Outcome: knowledge, attitudes, understanding, satisfaction, psychological well‐being, uptake, worry, reproductive intentions, sharing of information
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Honnor 2000 Participants: adults 18 ‐ 50 years in a primary care setting
Intervention: genetic carrier testing and counselling for cystic fibrosis
Comparator: none
Outcome: anxiety, knowledge
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Moudi 2016 Participants: couples went for pre‐marital counselling center
Intervention: motivational interviewing before carrier screening for thalassaemia
Comparator: usual care
Outcome: screening rate
Design: RCT
Excluded due intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening and partcipants are not known carrier status
Payne 1997 Participants: adults 16 ‐ 45 years in a primary care practice in South Wales
Intervention: genetic carrier testing for CF
Comparator: none
Outcome: knowledge, anxiety
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Punj 2018 Participants: women planning a pregnancy
Intervention: genome sequencing of the expanded genetic screening program
Comparator: screening for CF
Outcome: number of variants reported
Design: RCT
Excluded due intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening and participants are not known carrier status
Quigley 2018 Participants: parents of children who were identified as increased risk of CF following newborn screening programme
Intervention: information pack on CF
Comparator: no information pack on CF
Outcome: knowledge and stress score
Design: RCT
Excluded due intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening
Rémus 2020 Participants: parents of children who were identified SCD carrier following newborn screening programme
Intervention: methods for invitation to come for screening: letter and a follow‐up phone call;
letter and 3 follow‐up text messages within 5 days.
Comparator: invitation by letter only
Outcome: screening rate
Design: RCT
Excluded due intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening
Sallevalt 2021 Participants: consanguineous couples
Intervention: exome sequencing of preconception carrier testing
Comparator: none
Outcome: variants from exome‐sequencing and preconception carrier testing gene panel analysis
Design: cross‐sectional study
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design and intervention is not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening
Tambor 1994 Participants: adults 18 ‐ 44 years in a HMO
Intervention: invitation offering CF carrier screening and information giving either by personal education on‐site or by mailed brochure
Comparator: none
Outcome: attitudes, tolerance, utilization
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Temme 2015 Participants: parents of infants with positive newborn screening results for CF and one identified CFTR mutation
Intervention: genetic counselling plus a 4‐minute video on CF
Comparator: genetic counselling only
Outcome: knowledge: understanding of carrier status, autosomal recessive inheritance, the newborn screening process, and symptoms of CF
Design: RCT
Excluded due to intervention being the method of delivering genetic counselling and education and not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening
Watson 1991 Participants: adults 16 ‐ 44 years from primary care practices and family planning clinics
Intervention: genetic carrier testing for CF
Comparator: none
Outcome: anxiety, response to positive results, knowledge, reproductive intentions, behaviour
Design: observational, before and after intervention
Excluded due to non‐RCT study design
Wilkie 2013 Participants: adults 18 ‐ 35 years with sickle cell disease or sickle cell trait from clinics and community settings
Intervention: web‐based multimedia educational intervention
Comparator: usual care information e‐book
Outcome: knowledge, reproductive intent and behaviour
Design: RCT
Excluded because the intervention was the delivery of education and not preconception genetic carrier testing or screening

CF: cystic fibrosis
FXS: fragile X syndrome
SCD: sickle cell disease
HMO: health maintenance organisation
RCT: randomised controlled trial
SMZ: spinal muscular atrophy