Table 2.
# | Study | Group | N | MEP | NIBS technique | Measurement | Compared with the baseline or sham condition | Difference between BDNF genotypes | Comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Cheeran et al. (2008) | Val/Val | 9 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓ | SD | |
Non-Val/Val | 9 | → | |||||||
2 | Guerra et al. (2019) | Val/Val | 13 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | → | NS | cTBS+sham tACS condition |
Non-Val/Val | 13 | → | |||||||
3 | Jannati et al. (2017) | Val/Val | 12 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ? | SD | Only group data was compared by a t-test |
Val/Met | 6 | ? | |||||||
4 | Marsili et al. (2017) | Val/Val | 36 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓↓ | SD | |
Non-Val/Val | 14 | ↓ | |||||||
5 | McDonnell et al. (2013) | Val/Val | 10 | FDI | cTBS | MEP (% Max M-wave) | → | NS | |
Non-Val/Val | 15 | → | |||||||
6 | Mastroeni et al. (2013) | Val/Val | 15–17 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓ | NS | Intervention: cTBS+cTBS Monophasic TMS for single-pulse MEP |
Val/Met | 10–12 | ↓ | |||||||
Val/Val | 15–17 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓ | NS | Intervention: cTBS+cTBS Biphasic TMS for single-pulse MEP |
||
Val/Met | 10–12 | ↓ | |||||||
Val/Val | 15–17 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓ | NS | Intervention: cTBS+iTBS Monophasic TMS for single-pulse MEP | ||
Val/Met | 10–12 | ↓ | |||||||
Val/Val | 15–17 | FDI | cTBS | MEP | ↓ | NS | Intervention: cTBS+iTBS Biphasic TMS for single-pulse MEP |
||
Val/Met | 10–12 | ↓ | |||||||
7 | Antal et al. (2010) | Val/Val | 11 | FDI or ADM | C-tDCS | MEP | ↓ | NS | |
Val/Met | 8 | ↓ | |||||||
1 | Cheeran et al. (2008) | Val/Val | 8 | FDI | C-tDCS | MEP | ↓ | NS | |
Non-Val/Val | 8 | ↓ | |||||||
8 | Di Lazzaro et al. (2012) | Val/Val | 21 | FDI | C-tDCS | MEP | ↓ | NS | |
Non-Val/Val | 8 | ↓ | |||||||
9 | Strube et al. (2014) | Val/Val | 10 | FDI | C-tDCS | MEP | ↓ | NS | |
Non-Val/Val | 12 | ↓ | |||||||
10 | Nakamura et al. (2011) | Val/Val | 5 | FDI | QPS | MEP | ↓ | NS | |
Non-Val/Val | 7 | ↓ |
The NIBS effects are indicated by the arrow direction based on the statistical data (i.e., facilitatory effect: ↑; no change: →; inhibitory effect: ↓, or Not available: ?). In addition, when either of the genotype groups had a greater effect on the direction of the inhibition, two arrows were added to express this enhanced effect (i.e., ↓↓). ADM, abductor digiti minimi; BDNF, brain-derived neurotrophic factor; cTBS, continuous theta burst stimulation; C-tDCS, cathodal transcranial direct current stimulation; FDI, first dorsal interosseus; iTBS, intermittent theta burst stimulation; NIBS, non-invasive brain stimulation; Non-Val/Val, Val/Met+Met/Met; NS, not significant; MEP, motor-evoked potential; QPS, quadri-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; SD, significant difference; tACS, transcranial alternating current stimulation.