Table 3.
Checklist design and item selection
| Author | Overview of checklist design | Study setting/population | Item selection | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Literature review (Y/N) | Standards or guidelines (Y/N) | Expert panel (Y/N) | Patient consultation (Y/N) | |||
| Athreya et al26 | Adapted from the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist | Single-centre | N | Y (WHO) | N | N |
| Corso et al27 | Derived from the WHO England version for radiological intervention and CIRSE | Single-centre, all patients undergoing IR procedures | Y | Y (WHO, CIRSE) | Y | N |
| Fargen et al22 | Using the WHO specific surgical checklist as foundation | Single centre, neuro-interventional procedures | N | Y (WHO) | N | N |
| Knight et al29 | Revision of Universal Protocol | Single centre | Y | Y (Universal Protocol) | Y | N |
| Koetser et al11 | Based on SURPASS | Single centre, IR procedures frequently performed (vascular, non-vascular, elective/semi-elective) | Y | Y (SURPASS) | Y | N |
| Lee et al13 | Modified from RADPASS and WHO surgical checklist | Four centres | N | Y (WHO, RADPASS) | Y | N |
| Puttick et al31 | Modified from WHO checklist specific to IR | Single centre, all patients who underwent an IR procedure in the interventional suite | N | Y (WHO/RCR) | N | N |
| Rafiei et al23 | N/S | N/A | Y | Y (Universal Protocol) | Y | N |
| Ross et al32 | N/S | Single centre, interventional radiology and mammography | Y | Y (Universal Protocol) | Y | N |
| Sidhu et al33 | N/S | N/A | N | N | Y | N |
| Wong et al36 | Based on surgical checklist, developed with input of an interventional radiologist, vascular surgeon, IR nurse, IR technologist and vascular trainee. | Three centres, consecutive IR procedures | N | N | Y | N |