Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 8;28(11):2502ā€“2513. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocab123

Table 1.

Studies reporting effects of nursing DSSs on decision making, care delivery, and patient outcomes (nā€‰=ā€‰28)

Author, year Study design Study dates User group Setting Sample size Target population Purpose of DSS Stages of human information processing automated
Steps of nursing care process
IA IAn DS AI A PI P I E
Ajay et al, 201639 Quasi experimental 1 Dec 2012 to 21 Aug 2014 RNs Long term: community health centers
  • 22 009 patients

  • 5 CHCs

Patients above the age of 30 y, who attended participating community health centers Nursing care plan for noncommunicable diseases Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Bakken et al, 201418 RCT Not mentioned NPs Both
  • 363 NP students,

  • 34 349 unique encounters

Patients attending NP clinics Reminds nurses to screen patients, formulate nursing care plans. Y Y Y Y Y Y
Barken et al, 201738 Descriptive Oct 2015 to Feb 2016 RNs Short term: telemedicine
  • 3 nurses

  • 60 h observation

Telemedicine nurses Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y Y
Bennett et al, 201628 Quasi experimental
  • Preimplementation: 1 Apr 2009 to 31 Mar 2010

  • Postimplementation:

  • 1 Apr 2011 to 31 Mar 2012

RNs Short term: emergency department 800 patient records (400 pre and 400 post)
  • Patients with confirmed neutropenia who

  • attended emergency department

Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y Y
Boltin et al, 201829 Quasi experimental

April 2017

Simulated event

RNs Short term: emergency department

13 registered nurses

296 simulated patient encounters

Mass casualty victims (all age) Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y
Bowles et al, 201522 Quasi experimental
  • Preimplementation (control phase): 3 wk

  • Postimplementation (experiment): 4 wk

RNs Short term: adult inpatient
  • 6 hospital units

  • Control phase: 2816 assessments

  • Experiment phase: 3450 assessments

Adult patients admitted in and discharged alive from participating units Risk assessment and recommendation for discharge outcomes Y Y Y Y Y Y
Chunmei et al, 201823 Quasi experimental Year 2017. Duration not mentioned RNs Short term: adult inpatient 600 patient records (300 pre implementation, 300 post imp) Adult inpatients Risk assessment and management recommendations Y Y Y Y Y
Ciqueto Peres et al, 201524 Descriptive 1 Jan 2011 to 31 Dec 2012 RNs Short term: adult inpatient
  • 337, 056 admissions

  • 18 RNs

Patients admitted to medical and surgical units Nursing problem assessment Y Y Y Y Y
Cortez and Wells, 201636 RCT
  • 11 wk

  • (dates not mentioned)

RNs Short term: adult outpatient
  • 4 oncology clinics

  • 50 nurses (24 control. 26 intervention)

Adult oncology nurses Recommends interventions for common symptoms Y Y Y Y Y
Dallaire and Cossi, 201537 RCT
  • 3 mo

  • (dates not mentioned)

RNs Short term: ambulance 806 patients (396 control, 410 intervention) Older adults who called for ambulance Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y
Dehgani Soufi et al, 201830 Quasi experimental Not mentioned RNs Short term: emergency department
  • 10 nurses (5 in each group)

  • 537 patients

Triage patients in emergency department Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y
Febretti et al, 201443 Quasi experimental Not mentioned RNs Long term: palliative care 24 nurses End-of-life care patients Recommends intervention for pain management. Y Y Y Y Y
Geurts et al, 201731 RCT May 2010 to Dec 2012 RNs Short term: emergency department 222 patients (103 intervention, 109 control) Children aged between 1 mo and 5 y, presenting in ED with acute vomiting and/or diarrhea Assess and recommends rehydration interventions Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
Harless, 201619 Quasi experimental
  • Preimplementation start date: 15 Jun 2015

  • Postimplementation start date: 15 Sep 2015

NPs Short term: adult outpatient
  • 31 patients

  • 2 NPs

Patients over age 18 y, who presented at NP clinic with complain of nonspecific low back pain Assessment and recommendations for functional outcomes Y Y Y Y Y Y
Horner and Coleman, 201421 Quasi experimental
  • 9 mo

  • (Dates not mentioned)

Registered nurses and midwives Short term: Community health centres
  • 3 clinics

  • 900 patients

  • 3 RNs

Antenatal patients Perinatal risk assessment and management recommendations Y Y Y Y Y Y
Kihlgren et al, 201632 Quasi experimental Not mentioned RNs Short term: Emergency Department 281 patients assessed with DSS Older people Triage older people with health deterioration Y Y Y Y
Lytle et al, 201525 Quasi experimental
  • Preimplementation: Oct 2012 to May 2013

  • Postimplementation: Aug 2013 to Jan 2014

RNs Short term: Adult inpatient
  • 2-16 hospital units

  • 60 patients per unit

Adult inpatients in medical and surgical units Alerts nurses to complete fall risk assessments and documentation Y Y Y Y Y Y
Mahabee-Gittens et al, 201833 Quasi experimental 3 mo starting Nov 2015 RNs Short term: Urgent care
  • 35 nurses

  • 14, 218 patient visits

Pediatric urgent care nurses Screening and counseling for caregivers who smoke Y Y Y Y Y
McDonald et al, 201641 RCT Not mentioned RNs Long term: home care
  • 7919 patients

  • 500 nurses (335 control, 165 intervention)

Home health patients with high medication regimen complexity Identify patients with high medication regimen complexity and offers management module Y Y Y Y Y Y
McLeod et al, 202034 Observational

Preimplementation: Jul to Sep 2016

Postimplementation: Jun 2017 to Dec 2018

RNs Short term: Emergency Department

7 Eds

1491 triage assessments

Triage patients in emergency department Triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y Y
Olsho et al, 201444 Quasi experimental 12 mo RNs Long term: Nursing homes
  • 12 nursing homes in experiment group

  • 13 nursing homes in control group

Nursing home residents Risk assessment Y Y Y Y Y
Reynolds et al, 201926 Quasi experimental 1 y RNs Short term: Intensive care unit 64 nurses, 2 sites Pediatric nurses Medication dose calculation Y Y Y
Tang et al, 201945 Quasi experimental Jan 2017 to Jun 2017 RNs Long term: Nursing homes 60 admission nurses, 30 patients. Elderly patients with chronic diseases admitted to nursing homes Formulate nursing care plans Y Y Y Y Y
Telford et al, 201827 Observational 1 May 2015 to 15 Dec 2015 RNs Short term: Intensive care unit
  • 48 patients

  • 1640 blood glucose values

ICU patients receiving insulin infusion Medication dose calculation Y Y Y Y
Thoma-Lurken et al, 201840 RCT Jan to May 2017 RNs Long term: Community 67 nurses Care coordinator nurses in community based dementia care Risk assessment and management recommendations Y Y Y Y Y
Topaz et al, 201842 Quasi experimental (Pilot) Apr-May 2016 RNs Long term: Home care 176 patients (90 control, 86 experimental) Patients transitioning from hospital to home care Generates priority score Y Y Y Y Y
Vetter, 201520 Quasi experimental 3 mo NPs Long term: Home care
  • 7 NPs

  • 39 patient records

Chronically ill homebound patients with complex, comorbid conditions Recommends diagnosis and ICD code Y Y Y Y
Wouters et al, 202035 Descriptive Jul 2016 to Jul 2018 RNs Short term: Emergency Department 24 nurses Telephone triage nurses Telephone triage assessment and recommendation Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

A: assessment; AI: action implementation; CHC: community health centre; DS: decision selection; dSS: decision support system; E: evaluation; I: intervention; IA: information acquisition; Ian: information analysis; ICD: International Classification of Diseases; ICU: intensive care unit; NP: nurse practitioner; P: plan; PI: problem identification; RCT: randomized controlled trial; RN: registered nurse; Y: yes.