Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 2;3(5):848–855. doi: 10.1016/j.xkme.2021.04.015

Table 1.

Literature Review of ABBA Cases

Case Reference Age, Sex Comorbidities Kidney Impairment Autoimmunity Kidney Biopsy Treatment and Outcome
1 Morrison et al2 (1981) 59, Male Thymoma, myasthenia gravis
  • Scr not informed (described as in AKI)

  • Urine sediment with proteinuria 3+

  • 6-8 RBCs/field

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • OM: marked TIN, interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy, AKI, slight expansion of mesangial matrix

  • IF: IgG (+) in BC; C3 (+) in BC and TBM

  • EM: focal fusion of podocitary process, intramembranous subepithelial deposits in GBM, TBM disrupted

  • Hemodialysis

  • Death

2 Douglas et al3 (1981) 31, Male None
  • Scr 1.5 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 1.1 g

  • No description of hematuria

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • OM: not described

  • IF: IgG and C3 (+) in glomerular capillaries and more intensely in BC and TBM

  • EM: electro-dense subepithelial and intramembranous glomerular deposits in BC and proximal TBM

Not described
3 Rosales et al5 (2016) 73, Male DM, HTN, CAD
  • Scr 15.2 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 1.3 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • Anti-GBM (−)

  • OM: marked interstitial inflammation and fibrosis; slight tubulitis with accentuated tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury.

  • IF: IgG (IgG1, IgG2, IgG4), C3, κ and λ (+) in TBM, IgG (+) focal and segmental glomerular impairment

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM, sparse and focal subepithelial deposits with no spicules

  • Corticotherapy without success

  • Kidney transplantation with posttransplant recurrence of primary disease

4 Larsen et al6 (2018) 68, Male Recent infection by bacillus cereus
  • Scr 8.8 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/hematuria not evaluated

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: slight tubulitis and interstitial inflammation; slight fibrosis and tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (−) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Corticotherapy

  • Hemodialysis

5 Larsen et al6 (2018) 78, Male DM, HTN
  • Scr 3.0 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 3.3 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (unperformed)

  • ANCA (+) borderline

  • OM: moderate interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (+) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Corticotherapy and cyclophosphamide;

  • Scr 2.0 mg/dL and ABBAs negated at indirect IF (disease remission) after 12 months of treatment and FU

6 Larsen et al6 (2018) 76, Male COPD
  • Scr 1.7 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 0.5 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA 1:320

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (unperformed)

  • OM: mild interstitial fibrosis and moderate tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC; IgG and C3 (+) in TBM; IgG (−) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Rituximab

  • Hemodialysis

  • Death

7 Larsen et al6 (2018) 69, Female DM
  • Scr 2.7 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 1.5 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: slight tubulitis and moderate interstitial inflammation and fibrosis, with tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (+) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Corticotherapy

  • Scr 4.2 mg/dL at 15-month FU

8 Larsen et al6 (2018) 72, Male DM
  • Scr 5.0 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 0.8 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA 1:40

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: interstitial inflammation with marked fibrosis and tubular atrophy, acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM; IgG (+) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Corticotherapy

  • Hemodialysis

  • Death

9 Larsen et al6 (2018) 70, Male HTN, gout, nephrolithiasis
  • Scr 2.2 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 1.1 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA 1:640

  • Anti-DNA (weak +)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: high interstitial inflammation, fibrosis and tubular atrophy, acute tubular necrosis

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM; IgG (−) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • No specific treatment

  • Scr 2.3 mg/dL at 10-month FU

10 Larsen et al6 (2018) 66, Female DM, HTN
  • Scr 6.7 md/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 0.9 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: mild interstitial inflammation, marked interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy, acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (+) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • No specific treatment

  • Scr 2.5 mg/dL at 3-month FU

11 Larsen et al6 (2018) 77, Female Sarcoidosis
  • Scr 2.3 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 0.6 g

  • Hematuria 1+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: moderate interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (−) in GBM and (+) in BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (−) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • No specific treatment

  • Scr 2.1 mg/dL at 6-month FU

12 Larsen et al6 (2018) 80, Male HTN
  • Scr 14.7 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/hematuria not evaluated

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: medium interstitial inflammation and fibrosis, slight tubulitis and tubular atrophy, acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) in GBM and BC, IgG and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (+) in proximal tubular brush border

  • EM: electro-dense deposits in TBM

  • Corticotherapy

  • Hemodialysis

13 Dinesh et al7 (2019) 90, Female HTN, HLD, AV block, OP, PMR
  • Scr 4.4 mg/dL

  • PTN/Scr ratio 2.4 g/g

  • 5 RBCs/field

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-GBM

  • Anti-DNA (weak +)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: mild tubulitis and mild to moderate interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy; acute tubular injury

  • IF: IgG (+) (mainly IgG4), κ and λ light chains, and C3 (+) in TBM, IgG (+) also in GBM

  • EM: immune deposits in TBM, subepithelial immune deposits within glomeruli and BC

  • Corticotherapy

  • Rituximab

  • Hemodialysis

14 Dvanajscak et al8 (2020) 55, Male DM, HTN, HLD
  • Scr 1.2 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 5.7 g

  • Hematuria 2+

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (+)

  • Anti-dsDNA (+)

  • Anti-Smith (+)

  • Anti-histone (+)

  • Anti-SSA/Ro (−)

  • Anti-SSB/La (−)

  • Anti-cardiolipin (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: glomeruli with diffuse mesangial hypercellularity and mesangial matrix expansion; fibrinoid necrosis with a cellular crescent in a glomerulus; interstitium devoid of a significant inflammatory infiltrate

  • IF: diffuse, granular, predominantly mesangial and lesser capillary loop “full-house” staining; extraglomerular granular IgG deposits focally present along the TBMs and BCs and the apical brush border of numerous proximal tubules; anti-LRP2 antibody (+) along the apical brush border of the proximal tubules and focal granular positivity along the TBMs

  • EM: numerous mesangial electro-dense deposits but no discrete electro-dense deposits seen along peripheral GBMs

  • Corticotherapy

  • Mycophenolate mofetil

  • Cyclophosphamide

  • Scr decreased to within normal limits (1.0-1.1 mg/dL), marked reduction in proteinuria (UPCR 0.8 g/g)

15 Caliskan et al9 (2020) 79, Male HTN, hemochromatosis, PMR, BPH
  • Scr 3.2 mg/dL

  • Protein/Scr ratio 9.0 g/g

  • 3-5 RBCs/field

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-PLA2R (−)

  • Anti-GBM, proteinase 3 and myeloperoxidase

  • antibodies (−)

  • Serum cryoglobulin (−)

  • OM: glomeruli with largely unremarkable appearance; mild interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy involving 20 % of cortex; moderate interstitial edema without significant interstitial inflammation; Congo red stain (−)

  • IF: staining along proximal tubular brush borders seen for IgG, κ and λ light chains, equal throughout the tubulointerstitium; staining for LRP2 showed similar granular TBM deposits along the proximal tubules and brush borders

  • EM: global podocyte foot process effacement

  • Corticotherapy

  • Rituximab

  • Hemodialysis

16 Gamayo et al10 (2019) 74, Male WM, LPL
  • Scr 3.8 mg/dL

  • Protein/Scr ratio 2.0 g/g

  • No description of hematuria

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • SPEP demonstrated IgM monoclonal protein and elevated κ free light chain;

  • C3 levels low

  • OM: glomeruli with segmental membranous features; tubulointerstitium with diffuse inflammatory infiltrate; acute tubular injury; foci of mild tubulitis and occasional large TBM deposits; moderate tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis

  • IF: segmental granular peripheral capillary wall and BC staining for polytypic IgG and C3; widespread granular to chunky, near-circumferential staining of TBMs for polytypic IgG and C3; tubular brush borders with focal reactivity with polytypic IgG

  • EM: TBM and subepithelial immune deposits, with associated podocyte foot process effacement

  • Bortezomib

  • Dexamethasone

  • Rituximab

  • Hemodialysis

17 Gamayo et al10 (2019) 70, Male HTN, DM, hypothyroidism, CLL
  • Scr 2.1 mg/dL

  • Protein/Scr ratio 0.47 g/g

  • Hematuria +

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • Elevated κ free light chain and an elevated κ:λ ratio

  • SPEP negative

  • Urine protein electrophoresis demonstrated monoclonal κ light chain

  • OM: segmental membranous features; acute tubular injury; mild tubulointerstitial inflammation; large, wedge-shaped TBM immune deposits and a background of moderate tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis

  • IF: corticomedullary junction without glomeruli; bright, granular to chunky TBM staining for polytypic IgG and C3, with tubular brush border staining for IgG; IgG subclasses with IgG1 dominance and lesser staining for IgG2 and IgG4; IgG3 (−)

  • EM: TBMs and segmental subepithelial deposits without mesangial or subendothelial deposits

  • Rituximab

18 Gallan et al11 (2020) 76, Male HTN, DM, CKD
  • Scr 8.0 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 1.1 g

  • No description of hematuria

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANCA (−)

  • Normal complement levels

  • OM: glomeruli showing only ischemic changes; proximal tubules with extensive attenuation with loss of the brush borders; patchy mild interstitial inflammation; diffuse and frequently marked interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy

  • IF: diffuse granular to confluent TBM deposits staining for IgG, C3, and κ and λ light chains

  • EM: numerous large collections of electron-dense deposits in proximal TBMs without an identifiable substructure

  • Hemodialysis

19 Zhu et al12 (2020) 29, Female None
  • Scr 0.5 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 3.8 g

  • Hematuria 14.4/HPF

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-dsDNA (−)

  • Anti-GBM (−)

  • OM: glomeruli without morphologic abnormalities; no tubular injury; no tubulitis, interstitial inflammatory infiltration, or fibrosis

  • IF: deposits of IgG along the brush border of proximal tubular cells and some segments of TBM and BC, with equal staining of κ and λ chains; a few segmental granular deposits of IgG also observed along the GBM

  • EM: small granular electron-dense deposits within the proximal tubule TBMs, and podocyte foot process effacement

  • Corticotherapy

  • Cyclophosphamide

20 Arcoverde Fechine Brito et al (2021) 35, Male Silicosis, pulmonary TB, exposure to pesticides
  • Scr 3.6 mg/dL

  • Proteinuria/24 h 2.2 g

  • No hematuria

  • Indirect IF (+) on TBM brush border

  • ANA (−)

  • Anti-DNA (−)

  • ANCA (−)

  • OM: mild TIN, slight interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy; one-third of glomeruli globally sclerotic, some with segmental sclerosis

  • IF: IgG, C3, κ and λ (+) in TBM and BC

  • EM: amorphous immune-deposits in TBM

  • No specific treatment

  • Death

Abbreviations: ABBA, anti-brush border antibody; AKI, acute kidney injury; ANA, antinuclear antibody; ANCA, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody; anti-GBM, antiglomerular basement membrane; AV block, atrioventricular block; BC, Bowman’s capsule; BPH, benign prostatic hyperplasia; CAD, coronary arterial disease; CKD, chronic kidney disease; CLL, chronic lymphocytic leukemia; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; DM, diabetes mellitus; dsDNA, double-stranded DNA; EM, electron microscopy; FU, follow-up; GBM, glomerular basement membrane; HLD, hyperlipidemia; HPF, high-power field; HTN, hypertension; IF, immunofluorescence; IgG, immunoglobulin G; IgM, immunoglobulin M; LPL, lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma; LRP2, low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 2 (megalin); OM, optical microscopy; OP, osteoporosis; PLA2R, M-type phospholipase A2 receptor; PMR, polymyalgia rheumatic; RBC, red blood cell; Scr, serum creatinine; SPEP, serum protein electrophoresis; TB, tuberculosis; TBM, tubular basement membrane; TIN, tubulointerstitial nephritis; UPCR, urinary protein-creatinine ratio; WM, Waldenström’s macroglobulinemia.